Fav OT film

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Lyn
Did you like ANH, ESB or ROTJ??
My personal favourite although I love them all is ROTJ.
Please vote in the poll, and explain why it is your favourite.

Rogue Jedi
i like ep. 5. when han is running from the star destroyers after leaving hoth is awesome.

Ushgarak
Mine is ESB... but we have had these polls before and they don't 'work' right. ANH is made to look like the least popular film when it very often is in fact the second choice of most people- if you scored films 3 points for first, 2 for second and one for third, ANH would do a lot better.

Lyn
That's a good idea, but...I'm not too sure how to do that, new remember..?? embarrasment

Ushgarak
There is no official way; you would have to do it 'manually'...

Captain REX
Manually...?

Mine is also ESB. Dark and foreboding...

Rogue Jedi
awesome film.

Lyn
Thanks for replying people...so when you say "manually" Ush, do you mean like adding it to the poll or what...??

finti
ESB, but they are all great

Ushgarak
When I say manually, Lyn, I mean getting people to rank them and adding up the scores yourself!

Lyn
Right...so how would i do that exactly?
Sorry I'm soooooooooo very very slow!! stick out tongue

Ushgarak
Right, look, you get everyone to rate the OT films in order, best to worst. Then you look at all the placings, and award each film 3 points for each first place, two for each second, and one ofr each third. Then you have a more accuarate idea of how well people rate the three films!

Lyn
Ok, I get that except it wont let me edit the poll...i can't get in..??

Ushgarak
The poll won't help you, that is why I said you would have to do it manually.

Lyn
Ok, thanks Ush. Sorry I'm so slow.
K People, from now on rate the OT films like this:
Put your most favourite, then the "middle one" and then the your least favourite one.
If you've already replied please, if it's not too much trouble, post again.
Dont forget to put why k??
Thanx everyone!! Thanx Ush!!

Ushgarak
Well...

1. Empire Strikes Back
2. A New Hope
3. Return of the Jedi

Rogue Jedi
same as ush....

Lyn
Thanx and because I'm bored....
Return Of The Jedi
Empire Strikes Back
A New Hope...but I really do love them all!!!

Julie
ROTJ
ANH
ESB
though they're all equally great in my book......you made me pick

Lyn
Aren't I mean?? wink stick out tongue

finti
depends on how you rate mean

Lyn
Mean?
Average-is that what you mean??
I dunno... huh

yerssot
who all dared to vote for ROTJ???? mad

wink

Lyn
Well what would you vote for Yerssot??

yerssot
ESB of course wink

Lyn
K, so 3 points for ESB, what about the other 2...which one would you give 2 points and which one would you give 1 point??

yerssot
ANH two and I would try to get AOTC classified as OT to give it one point big grin

Ushgarak
Yes, sdaly, we DO have to score ROTJ... hardly satisfactory, is it, yerss?

Lyn
Alright people, scores so far are as follows:

A New Hope- 9 points

The Empire Strikes Back- 12 points

Return Of The Jedi- 9 points

Thanx for voting people, keep it up thumb up

Ushgarak
See how that compares with the votes, Lyn? ANH does MUCH better this way.

Lyn
Yes, it does. happy
Thanx Ush *bows*

Lyn
I'm guessing that's it then... sad stick out tongue wink

Corran
1. Empire Strikes Back
2. A New Hope
3. Return of the Jedi

Lyn
Thanx Corran, scores are now:

A New Hope- 11 points

Empire Strikes Back- 15 points

Return Of The Jedi- 10 points

Thanx people thumb up

yerssot
still too much points for ROTJ stick out tongue

Lyn
laughing
It's only 1 point behind ANH wink

yerssot
you cheated stick out tongue

Lyn
How so?? stick out tongue wink

yerssot
you definitly miscounted stick out tongue

Lyn
You count then... stick out tongue
But ROTJ whether you like it or not is only a little bit behind ANH

yerssot
I wonder how stick out tongue

well, main point is that ESB won (smile) followed by ANH (stick out tongue) wink

Lyn
Yeah, Ush was right- look at the poll...
Thanx to all *bows*

yerssot
come again?

movie_freak
1. A New Hope
2.Return of the Jedi
3. Empire Strikes Back

Lyn
Thanx Movie Freak, scores are now:

A New Hope-14 points

Empire Strikes Back- 16 points

Return Of The Jedi- 12 poits

Yerssot, I meant Ush was right about the poll making ANH look less popular. This way it takes second place.

yerssot
gotcha smile
well, all of them are great of course

Lyn
Of course happy

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.