What???? How Many Mistakes????

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



mg16
ive found so many mistakes in the second movie i cant even count them all here ya go:

In the Quidditch scene, Harry breaks his right arm, but as he sits up after he falls off his broom, he leans directly on it.

In the first film, we see that Susan Bones (the red haired girl) is sorted into Hufflepuff, however throughout the Chamber of Secrets, Susan not only has her classes with the Gryffindors BUT is also wearing a Gryffindor tie.

In the scene where the Chamber finally opens, we first see Harry, Ron and Professor Lockhart from the front, and Harry and Ron are slightly behind Lockhart, and in a position to threaten and guard him. When you next see them a moment later from behind, Lockhart is behind them and they are in no position to guard him.

When Harry first hears the whispering voice and is walking down the hallway feeling the wall as the voice gets louder. Notice he has a round red mark on the back of his right hand. In the next shot it's gone.

When Harry and Ron crash into the Whomping Willow, the tree made a big hole in the back windshield. Later, when they are escaping in the car from the spiders, the hole is considerably smaller.

When Lockhart falls down the hole into the Chamber of Secrets, we hear him hit the ground a second or two later. When Ron and Harry jump down, not only do they take longer to get down, they also slide down the pipe, rather than fall straight down.

After Errol delivers the Howler to Ron, he flies very close to Hermione's head, the wire attached to the Owl is clearly visible as it passes her hair. It looked like it actually hits her in the face.

In the scene where Professor McGonagall is teaching the class how to turn an animal into a goblet the writing on the blackboard at the front of the classroom is back to front.

In the chamber, as Harry crawls back to Ginny after killing the Basilisk, there is a pool of black ink in the water just past Ginny's head. It is only as the scene continues that Harry stabs the diary and it leaks all the ink - causing a trail down to the water, where the pool of black ink is.

When Harry and Ron can't get through the barrier at Kings Cross, they go outside to the car. The outside of the station is St Pancras station and not Kings Cross.

In the first film, Harry's family clearly live in a small close with trees behind their house - see owls delivering mail. The opening of COS shows Privet Drive to be in the middle of a large housing estate with houses to the rear.

When Harry is in Diagon Alley and Hermione fixes Harry's glasses, students are not allowed to perform magic out of Hogwarts or off the Hogwarts Express, so Hermione shouldn't have been allowed to do that magic, and she is a very law-abiding person.

After Harry has been told that he only has a minute to live, he seems to have enough strength to put the tooth right through the diary and sit up and tell Ginny what to do.

During the filming of The Chamber of Secrets, Emma Watson broke her wrist. In the trailer, when Harry, Ron, and Hermione are drinking the polyjuice potion, you can see the cast on Emma's wrist sticking out of her robes.

Notice as Harry walks into his room his hair is flat. They cut to Dobby for a bit and they return to Harry, but this time his hair is a bit messy.

The writing on the wall is is bright red from the side shot, but when you see the message full on, the writing has turned brown.

I don't blame you if you do not wish to read them all, there are so many, lol
laughing out loud laughing out loud laughing out loud laughing out loud laughing out loud laughing out loud

its_magic
holy crap dude u really look hard into these things dont ya i would never of never spotted them good work big grin big grin big grin

watadrive
how long did it take to find them all

its_magic
well i can asume he has watch the movies a thousand times lol well that how long it would take me

crazy_rock_chic
all those are on a site

mg16
im extremely observitative (sp?)

mg16
OMG! LOOK AT MY SIG. LOOK AT SEAMUS AND CRABBE! lol laughing out loud

unibrow
i cant see ur friken sig for some reason

IBTonks
the 'mistake' where hermione does magic outside of hogwarts is not a mistake! she's allowed to do it where she did because it is a wizarding village. You are only breaking the law when you do magic in a muggle village. stick out tongue

unibrow
i think it was a huge mistake in the first movie that they made quirrel turn to ash and die when harry touched him instead of just making him get boils like it says in the book. bcuz according to the movie harry kills quirell and in the book voldemort kills quirell by leaving his body so huge difference.....

krassin
dood,thoz were found by one of thoze nerds who chase after actors,pointing out technical dificulties

frootlooplucy
in cos where harrys in the hospital wing talking to dobby after he broke his arm, you can see the green ball that was dobby before the computer animations got put in reflected in his glasses.

unibrow
*cough*orange ball*cough

frootlooplucy
what??? its green!!

Phoenix
susan bones is in so many scenes cos she is played by chris combolus' daughter!

starlitegrl
i remeber a part in the second movie when Harry , ron , and Hermione have Herbiology (did I spell it right?)and Malfoy is in the class......................the books never mention that slytherin and Gryffindor had herbiology together....................there are a lot of other mistakes but i really luvd the 2nd moive...........it was much better then the 1st one.

lovethemoon
oo cares about the mistakes let it go ppl!

Phoenix
i think they probs put slytherin and gryffindor together a lot so they didnt have to hire a whole loada child extras for hufflepuff and ravenclaw

mg16
yeah, i know

Smart Hermione
Do you s have to critice the movie you cant amke the movie exactly like the book changes have to be made so get over it. just watch the movie, don't look for the mistakes! i'd like to see you's try to make the movie, i no i couldn't. so just get over them plz

Phoenix
erm... no offence, but if ya dont like movie mistakes why on earth are you in this thread?

mg16
well, excuse me! im sorry for entertaining people!

Phoenix
i think your threads are great, mg!

katie1989
all movies have mistakes and most people dont notice them anyways so in my oppinion it doesnt really matter

Phoenix
some people just enjoy talking about it - we find it interesting. if you don't, there's no problem at all, the only problem is when you say it doesnt matter in a thread where we enjoy talking about it. If you don't care about the mistakes, then don't come in these threads, simple as that!


smile

rishi
mistakes are good and masturbation too!

Marein
Hi, i'm from the Netherlands. A lot of you people often say the word lol. Did you know that's a dutch word two? It means fun. Wat does it means in English?

Phoenix
laugh out loud

Tonks
lol.........

But about the Hermione thing...... When she does magic out of school then...... well they are underaged witches and wizards!!!!! And in the fifth book of Harry Potter then one of the Weasley's say that Fred and George can do magic out of school. Now that they are the age of 17.... so it was a mistake... and for ppl that dont read Harry Potter books..... They are know going to think that Witches and Wizards can do magic out of school. which they cant and they will get expeld!!!!!!!!!


and another mistake was:

When Harry and Ron are driving in the car to Hogwarts.... Then Ron doesnt turn on the booster untill Harry says "wont ppl see us?(or something like that!) " And a Muggle man sees them......

Isnt a muggle Woman supposed to see them...?



And for Susan Bones....... A big mistake.... She is in Hufflepuff. and guys.... Gyffindors and Hufflepuff's have Herboligy(I think that is how you spell it) together!!!! yah and she is in there Defense of the Dark Arts classes to. Remember. Her and I think it is Hermione are cooing over Lockheart?


-Tonks

danagrint
I really don't care about that though

zac_j
Originally posted by unibrow
i think it was a huge mistake in the first movie that they made quirrel turn to ash and die when harry touched him instead of just making him get boils like it says in the book. bcuz according to the movie harry kills quirell and in the book voldemort kills quirell by leaving his body so huge difference.....
ya, and he saw him die so he would have seen the horses pulling the carriages in his second year. big mistake. i found that myself.

dansdaman
i noticed all of those things too....im so glad somebody else did too!!!!!

zombieman
Originally posted by Smart Hermione
Do you s have to critice the movie you cant amke the movie exactly like the book changes have to be made so get over it. just watch the movie, don't look for the mistakes! i'd like to see you's try to make the movie, i no i couldn't. so just get over them plz

Nobody was criticising, merely point the mistakes out. By the way, it wouldn't hurt you to work on your spelling and grammar!

seanjones
our spelling dont matter if you can read it..

i noticed in the second book hermione used the acculous repairo spell in diagonally she is out of school there, so y did she not get expelled???
is that a mistake?

zac_j
Originally posted by seanjones
our spelling dont matter if you can read it..

i noticed in the second book hermione used the acculous repairo spell in diagonally she is out of school there, so y did she not get expelled???
is that a mistake?
*cough*

dansdaman
double that *cough*

gshkris7272
holy there is so many mistakes in there.. buut its okay because the movie is still good!

bubbles33
my friend notices heaps of stuff like that, but she notices more little things, not mistakes

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.