Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

I believe that if JK hadn't of killed Sirius, she would have killed Dumbledore. (Sorry to any Dumbledore fans). There would have been a hufe uproar with a new headmaster / mistress and Dumbledore is the only one Voldemort was afraid of. For this reason I believe that.

Also, she could have killed a sudden wave of lesser characters. This would have made an impact in the way that Voldemort has arisen again.

On the whole, I was slightly disappointed at the 5th book, but liked it all the same.

Tom Felton Rulez

Sazii

FB MC

well ya, i think sirius shud have died either way no mater how much we all luv him*drool* , its just dat he makes da book so gud we cant drop it n its betta, if like hermione died im sure not alot of us wud notive-Jk but it wont realy b interestin-c wat i mean?

i just felt bad for harry cause he was depressed and mmisunderstood the whole damn book!

I think she should have killed a few lesser characters like seamus ,tonks ,percy Weasely, or one of the school teachers as well as killing sirius. Its a bit unbelieveable that only 1 would have person died .

Yeah...but not Tonks I like her....It was a bit weird that Sirius was the only 1 that died I would of thought the death eaters would of tried 2 kill off as many as they could.....Unless voldy wanted some of em 4 questioning

I agree that more than one person should have died, but only to a certain extent. JK killed off Sirius alone to express the full impact of his death on Harry.


If more than one person died, Sirius would just be a number of a death toll. But it is more than that.

Harry already has no parents and now no Godfather xx

Sad really cry

It is very sad.

bawling

I guess we can never say on this one because she may have a long term plan for the other characters so until all the books are out i guess we'll never be able to say whether she could have killed anyone else.

lucious shouldve died

or fudge... that choice wasnt up there

i agree .. only one death out of all those people .. and it wwas quite a big fite'battle'

And why sirius and why did he die so bloody fast .... one min hes there next hes not .. come on a character that great to die as a crap as that i dont think....

Felton's babe, I know you're new, and all, but can you please
search before starting a thread.

Sirius Threads

Sirius
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=290316

Sirius in OoTP
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f44/t14925.html

Who is Sirius??
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f44/t7518.html

Sirus- Third Book Theory
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f44/t290316.html

Reasons y sirius isn't dead
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f44/t8208.html

Sirius Black Fans here
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f44/t8320.html

Is ***** really dead?
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f44/t10318.html

well, while the poll's still open...harry should have died

and then I'd have had Cho all to myself.. droolio

who's cho

jawdrop

I demand you leave this forum. bag

glad to oblige *leaves*

This thread was made ages ago Tassie...I found it on like 1 of the last pages...& brought it back out of boredom

i also wanted to add something while it's still up. even tho noone else died arthur weasley almost did and that other person (sorry, don't remember who it was), who got put under the imperius curse, landed in azkaban. he might be dead now what with the dementors loose. i really can't say which other person should have died, all i can say is i was heartbroken when sirius died

I think if Harry died there would be no more books and i dont want that to happen

What she said...