Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Anybody read Sauron Defeated. I found it informative, and loved the Notion Club Papers.

where is sauron defeated, a seperate book, in the silmarillion, unfinished tales??

(i will never truly be defeated, not while evil still stalks the earth)

sauron defeated.....never heard of that

sauron defeated is one of a series of 12 books christopher tolkien did called the history of middle earth. i believe it is book 9? i havent finished it yet, i just got the peoples of middle earth and got excited and started it before i finish the others, oops

oh yeah, i saw that, i think that it's cool, i want to read it!

that's by chistopher tolkien right, his son?

Yes, that's right BingaBonga. Another in the series is "The Treason of Isenguard." Sauron Defeated is narrated by Sam in the early Fourth Age.

No it's not BY him he just put together everything Tolkien himself wrote and added comments and explanations.

You're thinking of the Sillmarillion, or Unfinished Tales.

I saw, in the back of one of JRR's books, that he wrote one more book called "The adventures of Tom Bombadil." I've never seen it, nor heard of it, but i'm interested. Anyone?

Hm I was thinking of the History. Christopher didnt invent that himself.


The Adventures (as far as I know) contain different poems - mostly hobbit poems, quite nice to read.
And well one of the poems is about Bombadil

Originally posted by sauron
where is sauron defeated, a seperate book, in the silmarillion, unfinished tales??

Its a book, all by itself. Type it in your search engine to find out. Its not included in the silmarillion, most of this book is Christopher Tolkien's take on his fathers book. A must for LotR fans, like me!! lolz

So you are all kind of right!

Which of the History do you like best?

so you enjoy seeing me in pain huh? your sounding very much like feanor

anywhoo turin, where the hell have you gotten too, i know that post is from like months ago but get back ere now, im not joking, i know you cant see this but so!

*gives turin about a week to return*

so on and so forth,

which shows the earlier drafts of the End of LoTR where the Ring is destroyed...

wow, are they any different, or are they the same just a tiny bit altered




*hope sauron gets the ring and mercilessly slaughters the shire-folk*

A "tiny bit" but the ring IS destroyed ... and Wiki is killed in the fires of Mt Doom poor Witchy

WOW wiki killed in mt doom, nice

well not nice for wiki but its a better way to die, than bloody folding up when some bird stabs you

wiki killed at mt doom? I don't think so...exa are you joking?...i know you are...happy mothersday exa...Have you and sauron had kids yet?...

*joking*

*imagines what offspring of a dark lord and tolkien's desendant would be like*

Wiki killed at Mt Doom in the version of "Sauron Defeated"



omg lol

hahaha

well they would be

-amazingly clever and know everything that ever happened ever in thie whole history of arda and before

-amazingly evil



iwould say thats a good combo i am like Banquo! not a king myself, but the root and father of kings!

yeeeeeeeeeeeeey


ok...macbeth getting into my brain! AAAAH

Lovely combination

The ultimate way to finally cover all, really ALL the world with darkness... yey

and have some fun in the meantime naughty

That's Really too good ...!!!

and 8 years old, too ...!!!