Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

hi people

i was just wondering do u fink dat some one will make a film of the hobbit if yes do you fink it will be peter jackson and is a good idea

by da way i havent read the hobbit yet so NO SPOILERS PLEASE or cover them up

thanx

Yes I do think that there will be
Though it will take some time

And, yes again, I do think it is a good idea and I also think PJ might do it.

if there iz one PJ has to do it, it wouldnt be right if someone else done it

is it betta than LOTRs i cant imagen anyfing bein betts than LOTRS

I agree!

you know what i DONT THINK that they should make the hobbit into a movie............reasons:
1. People was say that they are making everything of tolkien into movies.......which will take the Novelty of a TOLKIEN movie being shown.
2. The stars and planets were in the right combination when PJ took up this venture.........something i think cannot happen again.
3.I have a bad feeling its gonna end up being a "sequel/prequel" type movie..........AND YOU ALL know how that has worked with other big movies.

Fink? Bat Fink? I will assume you meant "think".

yes hopefully...

i agree with fini on the prequel problems. Star Wars for instance?

She thinks she's Mike Tyson.

I also agree about the prequel thing. While I would like to see The Hobbit made into a movie, I don't know if it would be possible for everyone to leave and go on with their lives, and then come back and still have what they had before. And it might just make the whole Tolkien book thing overdone as well, like fini said.

they should have done it before the movies then it would be a lot easier to follow for people that haven't read the books, even though they should have.... lol

Ian Mckellen has suggested that The Hobbit be made into a long-running TV series that is accurate to the book. This was just his desire, not an official statement by any means.

no it shouldn't

Most probably they will make a movie. Hollywood pounces on any opportunity.

too true.

I would LOVE for them to make "the hobbit" into a movie, i really enjoyed the cartoon version of it, it was really adorable and fantastic, it would be great if they did make it into a actual movie movie

hehe

The battle of five armies would be awsome

Yes. Waiting desperately for it.

Plus Smaug. He would be soo cool

We saw an Smaug as a firework display in FOTR.

totaly not as good as the real thing.