How should Padme die?

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



VengeanceGOD
If Padme dies at all, that is. (Well, obviously she dies, but we don't know if she does it in the movie.)

Personally, I think that she should die giving birth to Luke and Leia. If someone else kills her, then Anakin's rage would eventually subside. But if he's raging against the universe, and has no one at which to direct his rage...*vader breathing noises*

mephistodesigns
none of the above. presumed dead and dying sometime between 3 and 4 would suit me just fine. I just don't see Anakin doing it, but, had I not known he was to be Vader, I might have been a little shocked that he slaughtered all those tuskens too.

finti
totally agree with MD here

Lyn
This is not one of my favourite topics but...I agree with Mephisto...obviously she dies between Ep3-Ep4...I'd rather she wasn't killed in Ep3.

However...if she HAS to die on screen, I would rather she died during childbirth. I would hate to see her killed by the Jedi ((Good or Evil)) and ESPECIALLY not Anakin...her own husband.

stinkfist462
yeah i think anakin will mistakenly kill her... by like aiming the force at someone and miis and kill her... lol

VengeanceGOD
Idiot that I am, I looked at a TFN spoiler. She DOES die, sorry. It talks about her funeral. sadsadsad

Member.
yea

mephistodesigns
but, is that all for show to keep her safe? we don't know until we get the FULL story.

VengeanceGOD
oooh, very true. You know, I didn't even consider that.

Lyn
Funeral...?? sad

Lucas Sucks!
none of the options... they are all too predictible....

Elektrik_Storm
well she can't die in chilbirth can she cos later leia says that she remembers her mother as beautiful but sad.

Lucas Sucks!
Yup! but lucas is such an ass that he will say that she remembered her because of the force... she will die giving birth... how stupid... And with all the technollogy those days... they cant save her... throw me a freaking bone here.

Tired Hiker
I think she will kill herself to save her children. Probably her ship will crash into the Golden Gate Bridge.

VengeanceGOD
You're assuming that she goes into labor on Coruscant or something...what if she gives birth in the middle of the Tatooine Desert?

However, I will admit that Leia's memories are the one thing that could throw a hitch into the plan. The question is, does she remember her own mother, or Bail Organa's wife?

Maul
hmm...
i reckon that Dooku will kill her, then Anakin will take a radge and kill Dooku..
sounds very possibleto me...

VengeanceGOD
Yeah, but the reason I don't like that theory is because his anger and rage would subside into remorse, like after he killed the Tusken Raiders. It's only if she dies in a way he can't stop that his anger can be directed against EVERYTHING.

Dirty Vader
"Do your remember you mother, your REAL mother?"
Plus if Luke asks her that, it means that he was refering to his own mother, thus Padme. He knew Leia was adopted and so did she. So he and she knew that REAL mother meant their biological mother.

Padme shouldnt die in EP III or else the timeline will be messed up because Leia remembers her. We already know she dies thanks to that ROTJ scene, so she doesent realy need to die in Episode III. Maybe they can tell us in the film that she will die shortly due to a heart break or something, leaving a bit of time for Leia to remember her by.

el_barto
i would rather see her get shot in the head but begars can't be chosers

nickysan
SHE HAS TO DIE! what other think could push anakin sp far that he would turn over fully to the dark side.

Dirty Vader
He didnt turn over fully to the dark side. Killing Dooku with hate could turn him to the dark side.

VengeanceGOD
But permanently? He killed the Tuskens with hatred, and then felt remorse later and turned (mostly) BACK to the light. I still think only her death from something that he couldn't prevent and can't seek revenge for is the only way.

vvvrulz
Anakin should take care of Padme, preferrable in a fit of rage perhaps.

Rogue Jedi
she should be accidentally impaled upon annies saber. this would be the final straw for him. sith lord time.

mephistodesigns
uh, consistantly being passed over by the jedi which from his perspective means they're belittling him because he's oversensitive from his days as a slave. So he grows to dislike the jedi, has his ideas given further fuel from Palpatine, and thus leaving him open to feelings of hate that lead to the darkside.

mephistodesigns
wow, i posted that after reading a completly different page, sorry. that was in reponse to someone saying Padme has to die, why else would he turn to the darkside, just for clarification.

Rogue Jedi
we dont know how many times, if any, he was passed over.

mephistodesigns
its implied in dialogue. he's ready for the trials, obi wan won't let him take them. he wants to investigate who's been trying to kill padme, obi wan won't let him. he wants to bone padme, obi wan won't let him. Then in the discussions with Palpatine and Padme, you do get the feeling that he feels like the jedi don't give him the respect he believes he deserves. You're right, perhaps saying something as specific as passed over is too narrow. but we do know for certain that he feels like obiwan doesn't respect him, and the council obviously agrees with him because they don't tell kenobi to do otherwise so he assumes too much about what they think about him. he is very oversensitive and defensive.

mephistodesigns
not a reason we might turn to the darkside, but apparently enough for him (based on what we know now anyway)

Hell's Angel
Personally, I think Padme should die on screen. She is too important of a character not to. I'm not exactly sure how she should die or for what reaseon, but her death should be the final straw that pushes Anakin to the darkside.

I know a lot of people reject the idea of Anakin killing her, but if you think about it, it might not be such a bad idea. How GL would go about doing that, however, would be tricky.

Deckard
does Vader/anakin ever know that padme becomes pregnent? i would have thought obiwan and the jedi council hide her after she runs away from him. as shes scared by the thought of his children and the evil thoughts he has, runs to obi wan who hides her. annakin rages against the jedis til they stop him, angry at them and that padme would leave him. then he gets messed up enough to go into a suit, and his full embrace of the darkside is complete. maybe.

Dirty Vader
Something is fishy about all this. I hope Lucas wont mess it up. Deckard's right Anakin/Vader shouldnt see her pregnent, which means he shouldnt see her at all. Plus Leia has to remember her, so she shouldnt die in ep III even though her death is needed in the film.

Julie
dying at sidious' hand would be poetic.....not nice but poetic...and I dunno.... I believed for a long time she would die in EpIII.,...they just better make it creative

Lyn
I agree with Julie...I mean if she is going to die on screen... *sighs* ...GL better do it well.

VengeanceGOD
No, Vader has to know she's pregnant, because he knows about Luke. He just misses Leia's birth when she comes out second.

Dirty Vader
He didnt know about Luke BEFORE ESB. He missed both Luke and Leia. It just took him a little more time to discover Leia that's all.

VengeanceGOD
Well how did he find out, then?

mephistodesigns
Because Luke became pretty damn famous after blowing the Death Star to hell. Vader recognised his own name in hearing of the hero. Pretty crafty of him huh? wink

finti
yeah!!!!!!!

VengeanceGOD
haha. Possibly true, I suppose. I'm willing to bet GL will have him know about Luke though.

finti
if he knew about Luke vader and the emp would have turned the galaxy on its head to find him.
Just think of the words of Ghosty Obi in ROTJ...."The emperor knew as I did that if Anakin were to have any offsprings they would be a threath to him"

wuTa
it would make more sense for lucas to have luke and leia being born in the middle of the movie

Vegeta13
anakin kills her, i think...

Pinnacle
Uhm... has anybody read the book? confused

There is a book that details everything that will happen in Episode III,
you know? It was written a long, long, time ago. I remember my
friends talking about it long before Episode I even came out... roll eyes (sarcastic)

ybbil33
Ok all I know is I think that padme runs from anakin b/c he's evil and the children are hidden and then later in the 4th movie vadar finds out b/c of the force and b/c he's famous. But back to the 3rd movie ya the kids should be born in the middle and anakin shouldn't and then i heard somewhere that padme runs away like missing and so i bet they have the funeral b/c they can't find her and they assume she's dead so they have the funeral so she never dies on screen. that's what i hope happens and i think happens.

eleveninches
I think that one off the jedi/sith should have a porno scene with herand then sick snuff evil face her to stop people finding out about it.

Pinnacle
Okay, now first of all, that's not going to happen. mad

Second of all... that is really, really, sick. sick

Julie
true.....stay on TOPIC!

smokeurbesmoked
personally i think that she is going to run away....cuz anikin goes on a rage...but yea...she may die or just plain live on....either way somethings going to happen

Lyn
I agree with your idea; that she hides from Anakin or is hidden from him.

ybbil33
i defently agree with smokeurbesmoked.

((The_Anomaly))
She should be eatin by a rancor...............lol that would be hilarious... big grin

cornponious

LeAtHerRFace
Beware... spoiler.Padme dies while giving birth to the champion Jedi: Luke Skywalker. Anakin gets pissed off and fights someone, then falls in the lava and loses his body except for the head, also, losing all his hair. And then he turns into vader. Having recreated his body into a machine. Except for his head.

cornponious
Happy Dance

vishal2004
Anakin still has his shoulders and one leg

yerssot
it's not a secret that Anakin will fight OB1... it's something the old fans have been dieing to see for twenty years and counting wink

cornponious
I am one of those "old fans" ( born in 1970), and yes, I would love to see this fight. However, I don't think it should happen. Let's go back to the quote from ANH:

Vader: "When I left you I was but the learner, now I am the master."

This, to me, does not idicate that Vader and Kenobi had fought in the past. And it certainly does not indicate that it was a fight between them that led to Anakin becoming Vader (falling in the lava).

One can infer that there was obviously a falling out and parting of ways, but I would not think much otherwise. It indicates that Anakin left Kenobi BEFORE he finished his Jedi training, and sometime at a later date found his way to the dark side, becoming Vader.

Just my 2 cents.

cornponious

vishal2004
interesting
makes sense but would definetly like to see the fight, said to be the longest fight from all the movies yes yes yes yes

yerssot
wow, well erm... definitly don't look at the leaked footage than wink

vishal2004
what LEAKED FOOTAGE! confused confused confused

RobBo
Don't forget that in ANH, Ben Kenobi said that he hadn't gone by the name of Obi Wan since before Luke was born.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.