Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

If James Earl Jones was'nt around originally, is there any other actor who's voice would be ideal for Vader?

Christopher Lambert maybe?

Ironically, Christopher Lee would have been good.

Urkle

Cal Dod, the guy that voiced wolverine on the old x-men show

Michael Clark Duncan.

That's a great idea mephisto!!

But, JEJ cannot be replaced...

Vin Diesel!

if it could reach you, i would hurt you.

You'd have to get in line.

new opinion, the optimistic answer is C. Martin Croker. the realistic opinion is NO!

Vengeance-LOL! good i'm not the only one!

can't do any better than JEJ. although, if you could find another dude with a deep voice and an awsome brittish accent, he'd work too.

JEJ didn't have a brittish accent.
And you're absolutely right, there is nobody who can beat that. I watched ANH last night and started thinking about how different his voice is in ANH from the other two, I hope they take that into consideration when Burtt filters JEJ's voice for III.

never said he did. it would just be an added bonus.

ah. i suppose. but there's already so many in SW...

But it's Star Wars! All bad guys MUST be British!

again, if itcomes down to no JEJ, C. Martin Croker would be the man for the job

yeah.. they do have a tendency to make all the bad guys brittish. but that's a good thing.

I'm especially fond of General Veers and (in Vader voice pointing menacingly) ADMIRAL Piett

I really hope they do something with those scary advisors the emperor had in ROJ, like some screen time in 3. they're just sorta useless at the moment...

Lucas promised to back in the 80's, then again he also promised to use the falcon and han solo, and to reveal Palpatine's relation to Beru Lars. I can tellyou that you'll at least be 1/8th happy

only 1/8? pity. brittish accents are the best for bad guys. especially one who's got a cool mask.

My voice is ok. Thanks for caring.

Ian McDiamid would be excellent but maybe that would be too confusing!

well, i've got a pretty good range, if i didn't have a sore throat and had a steady supply of nitrous I could probably mimic JEJ perfectly

good idea Jello. we'll send a petition to George Lucas to let you do something.

if that could ever happen, I would bug him incessantly about the archival edition (which apparantly will happen) and about using AAD sound in all the movies. then I'd bug williams about mixing and drum miking and certain musical cues, i'd be a real pain in hte ass

Sorry everyone but Supershadows already promised me that he'll get Lucas to let ME voice vader in the DVD original trilogy.

Sir Anthony Hopkins.

"Space, agent Skywalker, is what I have instead of a view."

maybe the guy who played Sauruman could do it. he's got a pretty nice evil guy voice.

He is kinda already used...

picky picky picky............