Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

okay ive been here for a few days and already ive noticed there are quite a few Good Charlotte fans around. cmon Good Charlotte??? apparently they were good when they werent so poular, and ill believe that, but now they are just terrible. but the thing is some people actually think they're BETTER than some true (contempary)punk bands, like Jimmy Eat World. which is just strange. so heres a test to see how many people believe this. who is better, Good Charlotte ( ) or Jimmy Eat World ( ) .

purely out of interest of course.

anyone who votes for GC needs a head check

Two socks! Are we stupid?

neither

GC.. i heard more of em thats why.....

I don't listen to Jimmy Eat World and I hate Good Charloette so I would have to say neither. C'mon, what kind of song is Lifestyles of the Rich and the Famous???

i dont like either band but my band nothing but losers and my firends band deem are writing a song called benji blow your brians out we are playing it this new years

Same here. But I chose Jimmy Eat World anyway because no one can be worse than GC.

gc arent that bad some of their songs are reely good.
their songs have meaning. i havent heard jimmy eat world so im not gonna dis them.

Their songs have no meaning. "Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous"? "Girls Don't like Boys"? Yea, those are truly deep songs. GC sucks. Its all power chords and complaining about supid shit when they have no idea what they are talking about in the first place

I think Good Charlotte is pretty much a newer Green Day, only difference. I like Green Day's songs. An' as for Jimmy Eat World, I don't even listen to them so I have no opinion

GOOD CHARLOTTE ALL THE WAY! besides, jimmy eats world song "in the middle" was getting annoying.

They both suck!

havnt listened to Jimmy Eat World but i voted for them anyway coz GC suck sum mighty arse

I enjoyed 'Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous' but the rest of there outputs were pretty mundane and nothing special as for Jimmy Eat World there ok done one or two good songs but nothing too special.

GC is the only band worse than Linkin Park as far as i'm concerned.
lifestyle's and that other song are sooooo terrible. a retarded dog could come up with something more original. Jimmy doesn't get flamed by me cause i haven't heard them. if they sound anything like GC, then may God have mercy on their souls.

plenTpak52 you obviously havent listened to much of gc hav u? its a bit of a shame they released the two songs with the least meanin on the whole two albums but...thats life. every other song is. oh well. if people are too small minded to give gc a chance thats their choice. if i had a pound for everyone who sed they suck id have a loooot of pounds by now believe me. im still gonna defend em if no one else will.

i hope to fist fight with the guitarist one day just ti see if he could back his shit up

Benji? He would beat the shit out of you. He can definitely back his shit up, but he wouldn't waste his time with you. He's a great person, though. And a true punk. He doesn't give a damn what anybody says about him or his band. That's what punk is all about. He is the heart and soul of that band.

Jimmy Eat World are great, and "Bleed American" is a awesome song, but GC's first album is what got me into punk. You can say they aren't punk, and I don't give a damn what your opinion is, but they opened the door for me and I am eternally grateful and I will forever defend them. The first album was badass, the second was mediocre, with a few good songs, but I truly believe the next album(which is due out this year) will be great.

Claidisa....that's a great, GREAT point. Their first album was awesome, and the second album wasn't TOO bad, either. It just seems to me that it's cool now to make fun of Good Charlotte. What have they done wrong? Gotten rich playing music they want to, and working their way up from squatters to quasi rock stars? That's the way it should be. I'm with you...I will forever defend them, especially because they got me into punk, whether they're punk or not.

benji kicks ass and he will eat jimmys world (bad joke)

lol

Jimmy Eat World is so old, plus theyre songs got old after about a week but i love GC's music

yee i like smart people

I actually do like Jimmy Eat World, and the fact that they arent't playing teenie-bopper "punk" is a major plus. But I do still like Good Charlotte even if they went WAY downhill with the new album. At least there were a couple good songs.

i vote for JEW just because they are the JEW!

HAHA
i like JEW better .. but i did vote for GC cause i havent heard much pf JEW ... if only i could change my vote .. Dammit !

but i heard that the National anti terrorism income security is after them! but thats what iheard

is after who
sounds like fun

GC is better than all your dumbass bands well not AFI and LP

AFI is one of my favs

I love AFI too!! Am listening to them right now.

I can't stand Linkin Park.

SATown you dumbass i dont like you anymore




heehee i like stinky more than you

and what dumbass bands would those be, "goth"?

You don't like me 'cause I acnt stand bands that don't play their own music? Linkin Park is talentless and all their shit is electronic. But that's my opinion.

I also like AFI.

im listening to AFI now as wel...

good for you. Old or new?

a mix .. i made ... new and old ..

great choice. I hate people that say they like AFI and have only heard "Sing the Sorrow". That's so much bullshit.

i voted for GC... i actually havent heard jimmy eat world, just like 1 song or somethin....

i would like to change my vote ... to JEW .... because i like them way better now ..

What do you mean now? As opposed to when? Did you hear something new from them or something?

no ... be4 i voted for GC cause i heard more of them .. now i heard more of JEW .. and i like JEW better ..

I like some of JEW's stuff, but it isn't all great. All of GC's first album was awesome, and there are a few good songs on the newest album, but all in all, GC's good stuff outnumbers JEW's good stuff.

I haven' actually heard any of JEW songs!
I'm just a big fan of Good Charlotte, THEY ROCK!

i agree wiv pips chick, good charlote rock!!!!! reel big fish r quite gd aswel tho



Orli, Elijah, Dominic.... HOBBITS + ELVES 4EVA!!!!!!!!!

Just thought i'd post a pic or two of my fav GC member.

Another!

who is that one again ?

Benji

who cares. there all virtually the same person.

Jimmy Eat World is from Arizona...I choose Jimmy Eat World not because of that but they have some good songs

No, they aren't all virtually the same one. Benji is the only one in the bands who actually loves the music and cares about it. If he evr left Good Chalotte to start something else, they would be awesome.

i like GC so is jimmy eat world so i am up for both

Listening to Good Charlotte makes me want to shit liquid, it's so bad. Jimmy Eat World is better, but not by much.

I think Good Charlotte's only half-decent song was the theme from "Undergrads".

oh how i hate good charlotte
...and simple plan

Good charlotte make me want to stick pins in my eyes.

good charlotte should get together with avril levine and plot how to destroy music even more

BBG> wouldn't work out, GC thinks Avril is a poser, and Avril thinks GC are posers

good charlotte is kinda better.

Anything is better than Good Charlotte

...except New Found Glory.

but the new stuff is actually really different, so if you didn't like them before, listen to that and then decide.

I agree

like, durrr, good charlotte!

I realy cant stand Shit Charlotte i mean Good Charlotte.

I choose Rage!!!!

hahaha here here! I'll toast to that drunk

^ Agreed!



I didn't vote 'cause I don't like either of them. I used to like Good Charlotte in sixth grade, but that was only because I heard their REALLY old songs (like the ones that aren't on CDs and you can't find them anywhere....stuff that they recorded in their basement and shit), which are way better than their new shit. But, strangely, GC actually got me interested in punk. Even though they're...well...not exactly punk They're poser punks. Hehe. But, yeah, I grew out of them and I went from punk to...punky...goth? What the hell, I hate labels and that's not what this thread is about. So my point is I don't like Good Charlotte or Jimmy Eat World. Gah.

has any one put up a slipknot form? and if thay have tell me and good charlotte is better thay r hot but not the drummer

GOOD CHARLOTTE SUX
GOOD CHARLOTTE ARE POSERS
GOOD CHARLOTTE IS A BOY BAND

Good charlotte is way better than Jimmy eats world. I hate jimmy eats world though so thats my vote! IF you dont like it to bad go suck an egg!

couldnt of said it better... well yeah i could have, i wouldnt use caps lock so much and spell sucks right

Remember when you used to like Good Charlotte? And we would always argue about whether they sucked or not? Ah good times...

i loved arguing with you

then again you always win

Yeah *dreamy sigh* those were the days

good charlotte may suck in your opinion, and are poseurs
but they are not a boy bands boy bands are bands made up of boys that don't play their own music and don't write their own songs and if im not mistaken gc does write their own stuff and play their own music!

Actually, boy bands do play their own music. There was a group called Milli Vannilli a while back who got sued for not actually singing on the album--they had a group of talented, but unattractive people do the singing for them, and they lipsynched on the videos. The difference between a boy band and Good Charlotte is that GC have guitars and pretend to be political... That's it.

yeahh but they're all gone now cry

Yes

^^I agree

Whoa Whoa Whoa, I completely agree they suck, but I think the shittiest band award goes to Simple Plan.

slip is rich shit award goes to simple plan








darwin award goes to good charlotte

Tight sig btw Ronny

im changing it soon and it will be mucho better

i have chino, maynard, and zack i need more people

doh How can you put Manson in there with all those sex god legends?

ne1 else notice how that new-ish GC song sounds like its been torn straight out of a From Autumn to Ashes album and made shitter?

/\
|

i agree. have we actually made a thread about which pop-punk band is the best. i think the new gc song is hilarious. i crack up everytime i hear it. its just the thought of them trying to be serious in such a horrible song.

Manson is a sex god too droolio

Manson is creepy as hell...but definitely yes droolio

i've got Good charlotte's new album, but the bloody thing is copy-protected so i can't copy it onto my pc! i'm so annoyed!

Oh, gosh darnit, Yumcarrots! I guess that sucks for you, doesn't it? I don't see why you bought their album in the first place. Alright. Tell the truth. Is something wrong with you? You should check out that You Have Bad Taste In Music guy. Go to that thread on this forum and read it. http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f59/t307058.html You need help, chick.

ooh yaya is it filled with more


waaaah my dada left me and even though i have all the money in the world from 9 year old wannabees buying my cd's i still have a horrible like waaaah

That was great, Ronny.

oops i ment lifew not like

thanks

Always see it on TV
Or read it in the magazines
Pop rock bands who want sympathy
All they do is piss and moan
Inside MTV
Whinin' about
How their daddies used to beat them

I'd like to see them spend a week
Actually living life out on the streets
I don't think they would survive
If they could spend a day or two
Walking in the shoes they sing about
I think they'd stumble and they'd fall
They would fall

Life styles of Good Charlotte
They're always complainin', always complainin'
If pop stardom is such a problem
Well they got mansions
Think we should rob them

Did you know if you were Benji you could kill your wife
And there's no such thing as 25 to life
As long as you got the cash to pay for Cochran
Did you know if you were caught
And you were smokin' crack
McDonalds wouldn't even wanna take you back
You could always just run for mayor of LA
I'd like to see them spend a week
Actually living life out on the streets
I don't think they would survive
If they could spend a day or two
Walking in the shoes they sing about
I think they'd stumble and they'd fall
They would fall

Lifestyles of Good Charlotte
They're always complain', always complainin'
If pop stardom is such a problem
Well they got mansions
Think we should rob them
Lifestyles of Good Charlotte

We'll take clothes, cash, cars, and homes
Just stop complainin'
Life styles of Good Charlotte (3x)

hysterical

i totally agree

I wouldn't call either band punk period. Nothing about their music makes them punk, perhaps the way some of the band members dress would make them look the part but their music is hardly punk. If I was to even suggest they were punk I would call them punk pop.

That's perfect!

http://pages.prodigy.net/rogerlori1/emoticons/mc101.gif