What makes Anakin turn to the Dark Side?

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



hana_skywalker
There must have happened something very important to make him think that the dark side is the best. What do you think? He got tired from the Jedi somehow (or had a conflict with them) and tried to find a quicker source of power?

NateTheGreat
I think something happens where the council finds out about Padme being pregnant, they suspend or ban Anakin, and then he goes to the Dark Side after being persuaded by Palpatine. Palpatine will play a crucial role in Anakin's turn, and in Episode III as he moves from Supreme Chancellor to Galactic Emperor.

hana_skywalker
I agree with you in many things, but I don't think the Jedi will expel Anakin from the Order. It would be too risky. I think he'll quit the Order by himself. That's my opinion, of course, I may be wrong.

Lyn

yerssot
I doubt they will ban one of their best jedi ever during a full-scale galactical war messed

well, if you look at it, his mother got killed, he doesn't feel supported by his mentor, has a big ego (come on, the nagger about how good he is!) and padme going to OB1 instead of him

NateTheGreat
Word has it the Clone Wars will be ending well before the movie's end, so he may be banned then.

I think his mother getting killed pushed him toward the Dark Side, but not into it. There is something more, something very significant which will push him and/or persuade him.

Bicnarok

yerssot
natethegreat... the rumor as it stands is that the last battle of the Clone Wars will be shown as the first scene of EpIII, and this is more or less a fact with all the spoilers and hyperspace chats we had

and bicnarok, sorry, but you got it all wrong there
you think of balance as "one on that side, so for balance you need one on the other side too"
that's not it, Lucas himself stated that there is always balance in the force with the Jedi running around but that as long as there are also sith there is imbalance
yeah, anakin did bring balance but not by first helping to kill jedi but ONLY by in the end killing sidious and redeeming himself making there be no sith anymore

Bicnarok

yerssot
you have nothing to agree or disagree about bicnarok,
Lucas himself explained this and you can not in any way disagree with him cause he is the most canon you can ever get

hana_skywalker
In my opinion, killing the majority of Jedi Knights cannot bring balance to the Force; think about it: Murdering the keepers of the peace has only brought terror to the galaxy = IMBALANCE. It doesn't necessarily need to be compared to a scale (is it Ok?? I've never used this word before in English). Balance is brought by extinguishing evil, so Anakin did it by killing Palpatine.

xeous
If your explaniation with the Sith and Jedi are true then how could there be "balance" with even one jedi and no sith?

hana_skywalker
Sorry xeous (if that post is for me), but could you explain yourself a bit more? I'm not sure if I got it right. What do you mean when you say "one jedi and no sith"?

yerssot
he just needs to reread your post above, cause that's exactly like it's ment to be, hana

again; Jedi create balance, sith create imbalance, get rid of the sith and there is balance in the force

and people, please, this is not a point to argue about, this is a stated fact, if you want to keep it with your own (and clearly wrong) answer, please do NOT post it cause it will only lead to confusing others

Gotwa
He see's my mom. End of story. D:

Cowboyography
I just hope there is a Mark Hamil CG BABY!!!!

super shadow GL
me too CG mark hamill

Bicnarok
A "Stated FACT" my bum, if you want to go down that road then Star Wars is just a load of Fiction dreamed up by someone so why bother talking about it because it never happened and never will so theres no "facts" in that now is there.

The Sith are like dark Material, when one dissapears another re-appears to cause the balance, read some Quantum Physics then you May learn some REAL FACTS.:0)

yerssot
please, before opening your mouth and making a complete @$$ off yourself, try to think once in a while and read some threads here.

Check this section, it has a sticky and it says:

"'Canon' (as in gospel) means continuity, the validity of a storyline. Its most common use is when, say, two books in aseries contradict each ither, Which one is correct? The one that is had the 'canonical' take on the subect."

and

"Lucasfilm Canon Policy: "Canon includes the screenplays, the films, the radio dramas and the novelisations. These works spin out of George Lucas' original stories, the rest are written by other writers."

This affirms the idea that only the things that GL himself directly created can count for canon. The rules that follow are awkward, but basically the films are the 'primary' canon and the books and others are 'secondary', in that you assume what they say is true unless they are contradicted by the films (like Owen Lars being Obi-Wan's brother, for example)."

and now tell me, which part of "if George Lucas says it, it's canon and there is no discussion possible" don't you understand?

hana_skywalker
laughing

Dirty Vader
Luke Skywalker rules big time! So no CG Mark Hammil pe-lease!!

super shadow GL
yeah i was just joking!do you realy think there goig to CG mark hamill.

Bicnarok
AN VERSSOT

No I dont understand to be pefectly honest, you are obviously on drugs or completely insane to be able to spit out so much waffle. Its like watching a football game and listening to golf commentary. Im a big fan of the star wars episodes I just hope i dont turn into a wassack like you.

Bicnarok
someone put this wassack out of his misery, obviously got a case of the "lets talk crap" disease

yerssot
well, I AM trying to put you out of your misery, but you just fail to listen to reason roll eyes (sarcastic)

Ushgarak
Bicnarok... play it smart now and stop talking. You are being PMed an official warning.

Lyn
You know Yerssot, he spelt your name wrong. Tsk-tsk. stick out tongue wink

Darth Jello
anakin was too old and his life too traumatic. Plus consider this: gee, there's a sithlord on the loose screwing up the whole galaxy. let's cast off the most powerful force user for screwing around with a senator and leave him hungry for revenge and easy prey for the dark side.
my point being: though I highly doubt the council finds out about anakin's trespasses (they're figting a war! they've got more urgent things at hand!!!), if they did, they could not afford to lose him because of his potential to be an unstoppable enemy (proves true), anakin falls because of a very messed up life of usury, loss, neglect, and helplessness. In his situation, i would fall victim too

yerssot
only a chick with the force as her ally can do that, Lyn wink

super shadow GL
ha ha ha ha haaaaaaaaaaaaaaa hah aha ha ha

Bicnarok

Bicnarok
Looks like someones bringing some life into this Forum,

Woo Hoo hee ho yo whooooooooooo ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha h

Bicnarok
Ok ill stop, as a matter of interest, is this site in China where theres no free speach??

Ushgarak
No, it is in a place where we don't like people wasting other's time by making pointless comments like that one. So do actually stop, thank you.

Lyn
Too true...well...I am a JeDiChiCk. wink stick out tongue Happy Dance

Lyn
I didn't want to offend you, I understand it was a typo, I was just trying to lighten the mood. Sorry...

yerssot
thanks for lightening the mood lyn smile *hugs*

Darth Ninja
Anakin finds out that Padme is cheating on him with Obi-wan. He takes his anger out on Dooku, and totally slaughters him, which turns him over to the Dark Side.
laughing

Leog14
Just wanted to add something. Way off topic. Yet it is Anakin.

Darth Jello
wow, lay of lyn there stud, all we need is someone joining this forum named "magnoliafan"(god, you'd better all get that). and for your info, we "elected" a dimwit who feels we should "watch what we say and watch what we do" so we don't have free speech anymore.

Member.
yup.

Lyn
Your welcome. happy *hugs back*

RobBo
We also need to consider the small fact that, whilst the Jedi where aware of the prophecy of the chosen one, the sith were totally ignorant of it. For did not the Emperor Himself suggest that the Son of Skywalker be destroyed. It took a former Jedi (Vader) to remind His Excellency, Lord Sidious that Luke would make an excellent ally to the sith.
Balance here? Clearly so.

yerssot
erm... the prophecy is about Anakin not about luke

RobBo
Indeed, indeed, and the point is, it was Anakin/Vader who instigated the balancing factor with Luke as the catalyst to what became a swift chain of events. Obi Wan very probably foresaw this, hence his decision to hide Luke from Anakin, knowing full well that they would meet later, Anakin could fulfill his prophesy and Luke would would complete the circle that the sith, inadvertently, had started.

Darth Sidious/Emperour Palpatine seemed to have been totally oblivious to all of this but then the Sith where unmindful of the "Living Force", they simply wished to tap into it's inherent power, not learn from it's ability to guide and teach.

Whilst the Jedi allowed themselves to be nutured and guided by the Force, the Sith took it's power to try to feed power. They cared not about the continuance of the Force, nor little about knowledge of the Force.

Perhaps all along, the Force itself ensured fulfillment of the prophecy. Perhaps the demise of Vader/Anakin and Sidious/Palpatine was simply...........the Will of the Force.

Lames.s.
Immediate power. Staying with the Jedi would have made him powerful but it would have taken too long.

yerssot
or you could just quote OB1, RobBo wink:

"The emperor knew as I did, that if Vader had any offspring, they would form a treat to him ... "

Lyn
I love that line...happy

yerssot
and I thought it would be
"Some day, I will be the most powerful Jedi ever!!" or
"I truly, deeply, love you... and before we die I want you to know." or even
"From the moment I met you, all those years ago, not a moment has passed that I haven't thought about you." stick out tongue

The One Part 2
How about this? Palpatine tries to convince Anakin that the Jedi are corrupt and they could have saved his mother. The Jedi discover Palpatine's Sith ways and attack him. Anakin, confused as ever sides with Palpatine to defeat the Jedi. This is what I have concluded from the various hints that Lucas has dropped in the commentary of the two DVD's.

The One Part 2
I would agree with the good/bad balance agreement, but Lucas clearly says that the Dark Side is clouding the Force. Therefore the force cannot be in balance until the Sith are defeated.

Lyn
You know me too well Yerssot...happy
Those lines rock too of course!! wink stick out tongue Happy Dance

Lyn
That's what I rekcon too. Palpatine manipulating things to turn Anakin against the Jedi, against Obi-Wan.

Spectra
Palpatine will work on Anakin to made it a Sith Lord by manipulate him well. Playing with his feelings at will. Anakin will also see that the Dark Side is well beyond the light side in term of tool of destruction.

jedimaster10
I agree with The One Part 2 it makes sense.
I dont know about anybody else but i want to see Anakin fall to the darkside by trying to do something good but he fails so he gets mad and turns to the darkside. Then Plapatine tells him if he was on the darkside he wouldnt of failed.

Lyn

yerssot
funny you say that lyn, it reminds me of the star wars republic comic I recently got (don't know the number), anakin tried to massage someones heart with the force

Darth Jello
I think that booth anakin and Dooku both joined the darkside with the best of intentions.

Drac39
The Emperor will lie,and corrupt Anakin someway

The line about him draining the good in Anakin in ROTJ,has lead me to believie this

Darth Jello
plus, you've gotta admit, Mace has been kind of a dick to him

ConMan381
First timer here, just thought i'd put in my two cents. From rumor that i've heard I believe that there is some big arguement between Obi Wan and Anakin that turns Anakin. I've also heard that at some point, my guess is obviously after he turns, there is a big fight between the two. Obi Wan woops Anakin and pretty much cuts him to pieces, thereby forcing Anakin to become half machine as is seen in ROTJ.

.:Space Opera:.
WELCOME!>>>>TO HELL!

JK



errr he falls into lava, on the planet mustafar, and obi gets really lucky cause ani's more powerful.

Arsenal
Anakin was just a big brat in my opinion who had a temper tantrum and this tantrum just happened to effect the whole galaxy since he's full of midichlorians.

LandoSpeeder
That's what my dad thinks, Though I pretty much agree too.

Arsenal
All he needed was some good guidance counseling and Vader would have never been born.

pundarboris

Jedi Priestess
It's already been leaked that Dooku is long since dead before Padme dies hun. smile

pundarboris
well then maybe the emperor kills her

Jedi-Knight 8k2
Most Likely, he will chosse Palpatine over Mace

XX Emperor XX
It's going to be all Sidious he's going to be chatting away at Anakin's ear throughout the entire movie and then during the duel with Windu is when we will really see Anakin turn to the dark side, Sidious may bring something up about his mother or Padme saying that its the Jedi's fault etc..etc..etc..

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.