Coolest part in the Battle of the Pellenor Fields/Siege of Gondor

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



shadowy_blue
OK...What would you say was the coolest of these scenes in the Battle of the Pellenor Fields and The Siege of Gondor?

For me the most awesome scenes were The Ride of the Rohirrim, Aragorn and the Army of the Dead, and Eowyn vs. Witch King.

1.Seiging of the city
http://img-nex.theonering.net/images/scrapbook/8929.jpg

2.Nazgul swooping down
http://elflady.com/legolasgreenleaf/rotk/trailer/images/014.jpg

3.Grond
http://img-nex.theonering.net/images/scrapbook/11214.jpg

4.Ride of Rohirrim
http://homepage.mac.com/elwen/.Pictures/Photo%20Album%20Pictures/2003-08-19%2002.10.26%20-0700/Image-540E643CD22411D7.jpg

5.Pyre of Denethor
http://img-nex.theonering.net/images/scrapbook/9175.jpg

6.Rohirrim vs Oliphaunts
http://img-nex.theonering.net/images/scrapbook/10034.jpg

7.Eowyn vs Witch King
http://img-nex.theonering.net/images/scrapbook/10035.jpg

8.Aragorn's Return with The Army of the Dead
http://img-nex.theonering.net/images/scrapbook/11208.jpg

9.Legolas vs Oliphaunt
http://upload.houseboat-racing.biz/files/legolas.gif

10.Aragorn freeing Oathbreakers
http://upload.houseboat-racing.biz/files/kingdead.jpg

Kitoky
I think Legolas vs. the Olliphant would be the coolest, I mean I dearly love the Dead Army but I think Legolas really had his glory at that moment.

Vegeta13
obviously when the dead fight

kalantiaw
i picked aragagorn's return with the army of dead... they just swept house... totally overwhelming... though i must say legolas and the oliphaunt came in very close second... one guy-- okay elf-- taking down a giganormous beast like that is quite a herculian task...

shadowy_blue
I also like Aragorn with the Army of the Dead though it could have been better if it was longer and we really saw how the dead fought. I mean close-up and not just like sweeping up. Still very awesomely cool, but if you'll think about it, it's a little anti-climactic due to the fact that they were the ones who rapidly finished the battle. But still, the sequence where Aragorn charged and the army just appeared behind him and of Legolas and Gimli just really took my breath away, so yeah, I still voted for it. big grin

kalantiaw
i know huh... there shoulda been scenes up close where they show the awesome fatality of the army of dead...

badkittykitty
Eowyn vs. Witch King gave me chills..how friggin awesome was she!

shadowy_blue
Seriously. I mean, Elrond even said that it is an army more deadly than any man that walks this earth. It could have been more chilling if they showed how they fought. Maybe in the EE. big grin

kalantiaw
hopefully in the EE...

fini
i'm not voting cause i have an absolute tie, cannot decide between Eowyn taking out the witch king and aragorn returning with the army of the dead.
and you are not gonna make me decide, uh uh, no way

shadowy_blue
But it's a multiple option poll....you can vote more than one.

fini
you can?.........i never knew there was such a poll here!!! why didn't you say that before

Vegeta13
eowyn v.s the witch king was not bad

Bloom4ever
i cant believe i had 2 chose btw Aragorn and the Oathbreakers, n Legolas n the Oliphant!!
Neways, i chose Eowyn, of course.
That was horrible when they threw back the heads

Kitoky
NAZGUL GO SWOOOOOOOOOOOP!!!!!

Exa
The best for me was the Ride of the Rohirrim but I voted for several -

Siege of the city (i love sieges)
Nazgul swooping down (oooh nazgulnazgulnazgul!!!)
Grond (looked amazing)
Ride of the Rohirrim (simply the best)
Rohirrim vs. Haradrims and the Oliphaunts (WOW)

FreddieFreeload
I think that their deadliness doesn't lie in their blades, but merely the fact that they are scary as hell. In the book they don't do much fighting (at least i think not), but they make the bad guys poop their pants so bad that they can't fight back, and as such it makes more sense to me if you see them scaring the enemy so bad they flee or get heartattacks rather than doing real fighting... But they ARE pretty darn effective. Within minutes of their arrival, the battle ends.

Oh. For me it would The Ride of Rohirrim (though I had hoped that they would do that singing thing for their first charge, and waited for the 'Death'-thing for Eomers despair at the apperent loss of his sister)for sure, and Eowyn and Merry fighting the Witch King.

Candy
i liked fiorst when eowyn vs. the witch king, and then that ride....
that was really cool!

hobbit_lover
Eowyn vs witchking for sure that was awsome!

samhain
the ride of the rohirrim is the most breathtaking scene I have ever seen.

Kitoky
Did anyone else notice that the Easterlings didn't make their appearance in the RotK, I assumed that they were marching with the Haradrims and the Mumirkil.

Exa
Yes, they didnt really appear, made me sad, I liked their armour sad

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.