Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

well who do you think would win a battle out of:

Gollum, from the lord of the rings...or

Dobby the house elf, from harry potter...


Dobby Gollum

Gollum! Gollum! Gollum!

Definitely.

There's no competition, it's gollum for sure.

well wat do u mean by win

doby would win a monopoly coz gollum would rip the board up forfeiting himself

but if u mean fighting i think doby coz doby has spells and stuff gollum doesnt

true true, dobby can cast spells and stuff, i dont think gollum would stand a chance.

Now if they went in a cuss out war my money is on gollum ( from mtv movie awards)

Dobby can't have a wand though, so I don't know how much magic he would be capable of. If he could manage something like the Stunning Spell I think Dobby would win, but if it was just a real battle it would definitely be Gollum. I mean, he did some serious fighting with the hobbits, so Dobby wouldn't be much competition.

Gollum cuz he would start talking to himself and start to scare Doby!

dobbey would probley be hurting himself, so gollum of course!

this is a Lord of the rings thread i am sure most people will say Gollum.



Also Nobby is really anoying

Dobby

GOLLUM! he would scary Doby to death by talking to himself!

no competition its Gollum all the way
but if it were a case of Dobby vs. Smeagol then we might have more of a show unless somebody brought in the ring
then Smeagol would win

Kill Dobby!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Gollum can "literally" kill Dobby if he just wanted to in a real hand to hand fight without any magic. If we are to include magic on the other hand, Dobby can cast spells but if Gollum put on the Ring and be invisible, then Gollum would still win.

Gollum.

gollUm of cOurSe

yeah it depends on wether gollum has the ring

Of course everyone says Gollum. This is LOTR forum, all the harry potter fans never come here. I'm no harry potter fun or Lotr fan but I'll say gollum anyway, he's a backstabing little bastard isnt he.

u bET!

dobby would nail gollum he can perform powerful magic he doesnt require a wand and now that he is free of service from the malfoys he is allowed to use it as he wishes

infact Gollum was a bit viscous when he first saw Frodo & sam "sleeping" so i would say Gollum, but of course that dwarf did have some powers of some sort

gollum's a murdering psyco. dobby's too nice to beat him. plus he just isn't the hurting/kililng type. gollum definately is. go gollum, go gollum, go gollum.........

GOLLUM

strengths: speedy agile little thing, spindly fingers ideal or strangling..schitzophreniac so can swith from peace to war at a moments notice ideal for ambush suprise attacks, is all disfgured so nobody wants to touch him

weakness: the PRECIOUS (shower everthing with spit when sayig P)


DOBBY

strengths: can disappear and use magic
weakness: cannot do anything without masters permission...unfortunately master is dumbledore who does not condon violence and make dobby try and 'talk' it out, dobby would then be eradicated



hmm sounds about 100% - 0%

fairest i can say really

Gollum because he would bite dobby's finger off before he does magic, plus dobby is a wimp.

total wimp. and he's not as strong.

Die Dobby Die...

no ones gunna ask me so ill just butt in the convos(not) lol i definately think that gollum would win cuz hes awesome and dobbys gay.

Gollum against Dobby- Two against one.
almost unfair, Id definitely say Gollum

well, depends on if you're going by the evil part of gollum or the nice part of gollum. the evil part would kill dobby. the nice part would kill him if he took the ring. ha! that'd be hilarious! dobby gets the ring and gollum chases after him to get it back!! haha!!! filthy house elf, he stole the precious!!!!

true i guess dobby would lose cos he cant really be provoked that easily into using magic whereas gollum is a right out angry lil man

gollum would charm the socks off dobby becaise dobby has lots of socks. umm then he would rip them up dobby would cry leaving gollum feeling bad. then he would comfort dobby and they would get married. the only real winner is the government =s i dont know why. anyway at the wedding dobby levitates the cake (who guessed he's the bride) and it landed on his babyboo. umm thats all i got thankfully

uhhhhh.............. anyone else confused by that?

did anyone see that animation where gollum runs along and rips gandalf's head off?

DOBBY!!!!!!!! of corse dobby wud win, he can do spells. Even if gollum had the ring he wud still win. Dobby could probably face that Saruman guy and win!

GO DOBBY!!!
http://images.killermovies.com/forums/moresmilies/boxing.gif DOBBY
http://images.killermovies.com/forums/moresmilies/boxed.gif
GOLLUM

you're not serious. are you????

yeah i saw gollum wiping out gandy

dobby beating gollum and saruman....right theres a third person i must ban from blue smarties

do more harm than they do good these smarties

blue smarties? what is blue smarties, precious?