What Did You Rate Them?

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



theEviljedi
Here's mine
TPM-*** stars
ANH-*** 1/2 stars
TESB-**** stars
ROTJ-** stars

Nim Nom

theEviljedi
There is no such thing as 5 stars.4 is the limit.

Darth Daft
Not always. A lot of reviews have up to five stars, which is what I'm going to use. (sorry EJ)

TPM = 3 1/2
ANH = 4
TESB = 5
ROTJ = 2 1/2

theEviljedi
They use that if it is a great film,but it is not an official rate.

Darth Daft
Exactly. And Empire Strikes Back IS a great film!

Ratcat
Didn't this thread already run about 4 weeks ago?

Darth Daft
Don't know, but looks I was the first to send a reply in twenty days.

theEviljedi
Yeah but 5 ***** is not an official rate.RC,I made this about 3 weeks ago.

Ratcat
It may have been a general favorite fims discussion in the GDF.

theEviljedi
Really?

Ratcat
Hey, nice pointless post there EJ. smile

In order of best to worst.

1. ESB
2. ANH
2. TPM
4. ROTJ

Yes, I know I have 2 2's, I can't decide between the two of them.

Jedimaster3838
TPM-5 stars
ANH-5 stars
ESB-5 stars
ROTJ-5 stars

Empire is the best, but all the others are great too. I don't know why so many people disliked ROTJ. If its the Ewoks, thats understandable, but Jar Jar is more annoying than an entire galaxy full of Ewoks

Darth Daft
It's not the Ewoks that annoy me. In fact the film isn't annoying at all. It just doesn't hold as many of the great lines or scenes as the others do. Do you think it was Richard Marquand's fault or was it the script?

theEviljedi
Why was it stupid RC?I didn't know and wanted to clarify it.

Darth Daft
Go and take a look yourself then you lazy-
Just kidding.

theEviljedi
Well that was all that I needed to say to get my point across.Nothing wrong in doing so.

Darth Daft
Wasn't really much of a point. He said what he said. No need to ask "really?"

theEviljedi
I guess.I just didn't know there was a post on it.I still don't see it.

Darth Daft
It's okay EJ. I was just playing wid ya. Theres no harm done in making a short post just to make sure of something. Don't worry bout it.

theEviljedi
But RC made me feel like a dummy.sad Don't worry RC,I will make longer posts.

Darth Daft
Yeah you should have said, "Really? U sure?" laughing out loud

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.