Gift giving scene.....

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



shadowy_blue
Book:

Aragorn - white jewel, sheath with protection powers
Frodo - Phial of Galadriel
Sam - garden box
Merry - silver belt
Pippin - silver belt
Boromir - golden belt
Gimli - 3 golden hairs
Legolas - bow of the Galadhrim

Movie:

Aragorn - advice (Celeborn gives him the dagger)
Frodo - Phial of Galadriel
Sam - hithlain rope
Merry - dagger of the Noldorin
Pippin - dagger of the Noldorin
Boromir - (nothing)
Gimli - 3 golden hairs
Legolas - bow of the Galadhrim

They forgot Boromir!! mad They did Aragorn, Legolas, Gimli, Frodo, Sam, Merry, and Pippin, but they forgot Boromir in the movie. Yes, he got a cloak and brooch but all of them had them as well. I mean, no specific gift just for him. sad

Kitoky
*gasp*
THEY FORGOT BOROMIR!??! HOW COULD THEY?!?! I SWEAR, I'M GONNA *beeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeep*

angelsflame265
we need to have a talk with mr. peter jackson!

Sifer
Thought they gave him a belt.

Kitoky
I THINK WE NEED TO SPEAK WITH THE EDITTORS!!

shadowy_blue
Just in the book though. They never showed him being given a gift in the movie.

Aurora
Hum.... i hadn't noticed. NOw i am upset!!!!!!!

Also a bit off subject, I was sooo excited in the EE of TTT when Sam drops the little box and Frodo caught it. I thought it was gonna be a shout out to the box that Galadriel had given him. Oh welll!

Member.
too bad.

Exa
AWWW mad mad NO PRESENT FOR BOROMIR! THAT IS SO DAMN UNFAIR!!!!

Phoenix
grrrrr!! How dare they leave him out! miffed


and poor Sam - he was sposd to renew Middle-Earth/The Shire with his magic dirt!!

Camellia
They didn't show it in the film at that scene but I'm relatively sure that I do see him wearing a golden, elven belt when in the boat before he passes over the Falls of Rauros (I seem to remember seeing it also when I saw it at the exhibition)

But then, maybe I'm wrong! confused

enya
awww bless him and i didnt even notice

i still love that whole sequence, wish it had been in the theatrical version

Kitoky
EVERYONE, GO SEARCH FOR A PICTURE OF BOROMIR GOING OVER RAUROS!

Smodden
here

Kitoky
Uh.....

Smodden
what?

Kitoky
I don't like how the cartoon Boromi looks....He's...like...duuude.....

And that's a silver belt...I thought it was a Golden Belt...

sauron
it was!!!

sam lied about the seasoning because he was embarassed about his gift...he did not see thge importance of it until the scouring big grin

sam may not be too clever but he is not stupid enough to expect a roast chicken in mordor

plus if its only seasoning why was he so worried "CATCH IT CATCH IT MR FRODO" sam would never risk his masters life like that for seasoning

Exa
It WAS a golden belt... aww poor Boromir always getting the wrong presents...

Kitoky
mad mad mad GRRRRRRRRRRR mad mad mad

Aurora
embarrasment Oh really?? embarrasment

I;m alittle happier now!

azszhz
Boromir has to have his belt!!!! thats so sad that they just skipped it

Kitoky
ARRRGH BAH HUMBUG!!

azszhz
and i was all happy for PJ winning the GG aword now i'm all mad at him
*hold head* what a headack im getting

samIam
I thought the same things !!! thanks sauron .. kinda wierd but sam does like cooking ..... and didi u ever see him get it out when they had the brace of connies ...NO !! did u see the big silver nut in the middle though ( i don't remeber it )

sauron
i dont think he opened it

that nut was the new party tree right?

well how funny would it have been if frodo just kept the ring..and sam used the seeds in mordor...flowers on barut dur big grinbig grin

Bar-en-Danwedh
this no gift for boromir thing has bothered me for a while...

and even in the book: a golden belt? how about an arrow proof vest?!?

i guess in the film, they figured he was going to die anyway so it would probably upset viewers more that he would only get to enjoy his gift for about 20 minutes of film time...

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.