Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

i dont get get it... how can someone have a father like vader a hot mother like padme cool mentors like obi wan and yoda and still be a whiny beeyatch......" i dont wanna save the galaxy, i cant go with you i need to help uncle owen with the farm"..."thats impossible to lift the fighter jet outa the swamp noone can do it"...

because he is supposed to be young, sheltered, and naive. sheltered, naive people tend to not realize they aren't the center of the galaxy. As such, he whines. At least when Anakin whines about things, he actually has something to whine about.

How can you bring the mentor part of that up when he hasn't been trained when he says the "farm" part! And regardless of his heritage, he's only a farm boy. Put yourself in his place.

calm down....i like luke in rotj but that doenst change the fact that hes a whiner....i can bring up the mentor part because when yoda was trainin him he was still whining......and lil anakin was a farm boy and i dont remember him whining nearly as much as luke and luke was twice his age

omg you are so right

Anakin was also a lot more experienced at life at 9 years old then Luke was at...what, he was 19 or 20 by ANH, right?

Luke is probably my favourite caracter. Everyone says he's whiny, but like it's been mentioned before he's young and also a farmboy. And I agree that he was awesome in ROTJ.

he goes through a lot of shit. form the time he sees owen and beru dead to the time vader destroys the emperor, what he went through is breathtaking.

why is Luke so whiny??? It runs in the family! (from fathers side)

Good answer.
Luke's not too whiny anyway...and both he and his father went through heaps.

not too whiny??? but he wanted to go to Toschi Station to pick up some power converteeeeeeeeeeers

He didn't want to go to Alderaan either

oh wait, he really didn't, did he

I think he's related to Wedge ... That's impossible, even for a computeeeeeeeeeer

Haha! If I could change just one line in the entire saga it would be that one! I just want to throw him down and kick the Tatooine sand in his face when he says that.

no the line I want to kick out is "R2222222222" when the droid gets swollen in the swamp in Dagobah. Thats whiny, but otherwise screw you all lukes the man.

I used to bulseye womprats in my T-16 back home, they're not as big as 2 meteeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeers

come to Jaster Mereel

don't spam your threads

your killin me ....C3P0 where in the lower lever trash compactoooooooooor

I don't now who whines more luke or anikin

i'd say luke

But Ben is a great maaaaaaaaaaaaaan

"You think a princess and a guy like me?"

"No"

MAYBE IT'S A SKYWALKER TRAIT.

IT COMES FROM HIS FATHERS SIDE OF THE FAMILY SO IT MUST RUN IN HIS GENES.