If you picked one book of the 5 thaa are out how would you cahnge it?
Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.
Orli'sElf7
i think i would've added a little bit more dumbledore involvement in the 5th book. i mean it felt to me like jk wrote it to accompany the death of richard harris so it would be easier for the movie people, compromising the story a bit. plus i mean harry could've found out more clues about his past than squeezing every explanation and detail into one chapter. thats the only think i was anal about...like the whole explanation was in one chapter. thas bout it though the books ARE brilliant!
Darinda
That was good.Umm Iwould Change the Fourth a bit ,Becase I think that It was not fair to Ron that His Frind Had to get him a date.I would Have Gladly Been His Date if My Charecter even existed in the Books.
Polly
I WOULD CHANGE IT SO SIRIUS WOULD'NT DIE!
punkyhermy
OH YES!!!YES!!!!!!DEFINATELY!
and i'd have more lily and james parts and the marauder era!

Darinda
yah you guys are good.
hhhhr
i wouldn't change a thing, it wouldn't be "harry potter" anymore
danis4ever
yap! definitely!
but if i would like to change something, i would change percy's attitude towards his parents
RebelPhoenix
Those are all really good suggestions!
The one thing I would change is the Quidditch match where Harry lost to Cedric because of external factors he couldn't control - I would change it so that it was made known and there was a re-match at least cos he would have got the snitch otherwise and deserves his spotless record. The reason for my choice is that I really didn't like it when Cedric's dad was bragging about it to Harry's face, come on he's just a kid and the game has nothing to do with the fact that he's 'Harry Potter', it's purely down to their performance. I hate it when people rub it in or unrelated things into it, it's just rude.
Orli'sElf7
ohhhh yea i know!!! i wish harry had gotten cho first tho too <: (
celestial_moon
i would change the fourth book...i have a problem with it and i cant explain what's wrong with it. GoF felt like something was missing...thats the best way 2 describe it. so i would makeover GoF
Darinda
hhmmmmm,I would give ron a girl..I would gladly be his girl.hehehahaho-blushes-I know i am strange
Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.
Copyright 1999-2025 KillerMovies.