Which character do you want to die in future books?

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Spider-Girl
Ron or Hermione, it would be sad but beautiful.

The Ones
hermionie

ArrghPirateGirl
.......HARRY!!!!........HEDWIG!!!!......&..........DUMBLEDORE

The Innkeeper
I want sirius to come back alive and harry to be really happy

then voldy to kill sirius again

Elondra
Percy.

celestial_moon
i dont eant them 2 die but i have a feeling that either lupin or ron might die (or both). it would b extremely sad 4 either of them 2 die.

~*~Tassie~*~
eek! No pictures?! sad You realise this thread's been done before.. you're my partner in stopping crime.. sad



But I don't want any of them to die.. everyone character contributes to the book in some way.. it'd be boring without the bad guys ninja

angelsflame265
Percy! just cause if its gonna be a weasley it might as well be him

Padfoot15
Percy!
And I heard (so did you all too, probably) that there will be no Marauders by the end of the Series. sad
I want Wormtail to die, but LUPIN MUST LIVE!!!! sad

Secosera_TD
Delehov

Elondra
lol. roll eyes (sarcastic)

frodo_dude
lol! well the HP forum wouldnt be the same without elondra's pics roll eyes (sarcastic) lol

Elondra

frodo_dude
LOL! good one!!

Elondra
I stole it form a Derren Brown forum. stick out tongue roll eyes (sarcastic) wink

frodo_dude
lol!

becz4dan4eva
I dont want any one to die but i think malfoy or ron i hope its not hrry coz i wont be able 2 watch the fim other wise or ron sad

tigress
nice little ray of sunshine this thread.but its got to be umbridge that dies next mwahahahahahahahahahahahah

ElmStreetFan01
Cho

<Tidus>
Umbrige,Voldy Boldy!, Ahhh Fudge, Malfoy, Lucifes, DOlohov, ESPECIALLY BELLATRIX!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!HAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAH
AHAHA Hem Hem sorry gone too evil ok I also want to die heheheheh ok ill stop it fine. Oh and also Petergru!

EOWYN3
I know this won't be a popular post, but I think for the series to have a really strong ending, that Harry should die. But, somehow, Voldemort dies too, and Harry dies a martyr?

ladygrim
got to agree with Eowyn3 cuz i have read to many threads were people want hp to die and reasons why that i have got my hopes up for that sort of ending

<Tidus>
It cant happen cuz this is what the prophecy sais

"Either must die at the hand of the other for neither can live when the other survives" that means that Only one of them dies by one of the others hands so only ONE.

Wizardkid233
PERCY

Wizardkid233
NOW THAT WOULD BE BEAUTIFUL

padfootluver
Hi, i'm new to this thread. I dont really want any of them to die, but if somone has to, i think Percy should go. He's turned into a git.

JessieSparrow
Percy! ugh...what crawled up his ass and died?

EOWYN3
Yeah, but that doesn't mean that the winner can't die, too. If Harry kills Voldemort in some huge fight, maybe Harry will die of exhaustion or something. I don't know; but I'm not buying that they both absolutely, positively CANNOT die around the same time period.

ladygrim
colin BLODDY creevy AAAAAAAAAAAAAAARRRRRRRRGH i have a slot for his ruddy camera

frodo_dude
lol

ada
UMBRIDGE!!!!!!!!!!!

padfootluver
that would be AWESOME!!!

I lV ArseNAl+HP
Hi y all.

UMBRIDGE - totally.
I havent really thought bout who would die.
Obviously to do with the prophecy..........either HP or Voldy will die.
Who knows...some1 else may as well, i mean WILL die (not MAY die!)
coz JKR is tough. Sirus was in like one bk (4) mainly and a bit in 3 and 5 then he has gone?!!??

He'll prob come back though! - not dead or something!

orlandoOYEA
I would like to see...well not really...but...one of the weaslys...i think its kind of inevitable...personally i think percy will die.

angelsflame265
I don't want anybody to die. . . knowing jkr she will make the death sad, no matter who it is

orlandoOYEA
Indeed^

Clovie
DUDLEY eek!

Originally posted by ElmStreetFan01
Cho yes, Cho! DIE CHO YOU BIATCH

Hermione202
i suppose Umbridge but i agree with angelsflame265.i don't wannt anyone else to die except Voldermort.It'll be too sad cry except that cursing Voldermort.No one else deserves death

Hermione202
Does anyone agree? shifty

Aldaron
Cho, Lupin and Percy are most likely to die.

Hermione202
I don't want Lupin to die.That'll be too sad sad sadangel

KKdave
I think ron's going to die at some point, along with lupin and dumbledore possible, even though i dont want them to

NightCrawler341
Dumbledore(sadly), Lupin because of Peter's silver hand, and maybe one of the Weasley's.

lizzymovies
fudge because then dumbledore willl be minister

NightCrawler341
LOCKHART! LOCKHART LOCKHART! Why? Because he is a lying b****** who deserves to die!

TheSun

shadow12
i want draco to die

harry potty
i hope dumble dore doesn't die because he is the only one that voldamorrt ever feared and harry will be too vulnerable to voldamort confused confused confused confused rolling on floor laughing sick beer

Fionnuala
Harry!! eek! ...please let him die...

shaber
no expression

TheSun
It's definitely Dumbledore.

NightCrawler341
Originally posted by TheSun
Lockhart will not be in future books, according to JKR.

So? I still want him to die...

shaber
he's no longer important.

NightCrawler341
.... It doesn't matter if he isn't in any other books. Still want him dead. I don't care if we don't see him die in the book, as long as he dies someway I will be happy. Besides, it is what I want, it doesn't have to happen.

shadow12
i want him to die too

tigress
well whoever it will be JK knows were not gunna like it so its one of our beloved characters from the order but as i said before if it is DD im sure would come back as a ghost to advise harry

star_scar_child
i dont want anyone to die. but if someone does die...i think it will be ron.. the description said an important character will die...and look at all the clues. first of all when harry and ron and the staff sat down for christmas dinner, professor trelawny said there were thirteen sitting down so the first one to get up was the first one to die and harry and ron both got up at the same time. but it cant be harry because its only the 6th book and the series is named after him. second is not noticable as a clue but it is. ms weasley sees her family one by one dead. its not much but i still think that its a little clue.and ron was made prefect so if he diesharry would become head boy. which in the end would make a good ending. thats all i got so far but im looking into it

NightCrawler341
A good ending?! Are you crazy?

TheSun
Someone is definitely going to die. It's almost certainly Dumbledore. I hate leaks and spoilers.

mcdara
Harry will die. Hermione will get married to Ron and Arthur will be Misnister of magic and Harry will probably go through the veil with Dumbledor.

TheSun
Originally posted by mcdara
Harry will die. Hermione will get married to Ron and Arthur will be Misnister of magic and Harry will probably go through the veil with Dumbledor.
Arthur doesn't become Minister for Magic, FACT. Everyone who dies goes through the veil.

mcdara
Originally posted by TheSun
Arthur doesn't become Minister for Magic, FACT. Everyone who dies goes through the veil.

The point wasn't about the veil. Anyway, it seems to me she is following the Lord of the Rings enough to indicate she will have Harry defeat the dark lord, and his scar will continue to bother him, and then he will go off to the havens.

TheSun
Originally posted by mcdara
The point wasn't about the veil. Anyway, it seems to me she is following the Lord of the Rings enough to indicate she will have Harry defeat the dark lord, and his scar will continue to bother him, and then he will go off to the havens.
Although there are certain similarities between HP and LOTR - there are similarities between HP and Nancy Drew. You can't just go and compare one author to another and say that's that.

hbanana
Cho. she's a witch.

pumpkinpie4ever
cho and most likely draco although i dont want him to cuz he is soooo hot! well he is with short hair so shut up! and never mind what i said because i just remembered that GoF is the last harry potter film tom's gonna do so down with MOlLFOY!!!hheheh

NightCrawler341
Originally posted by pumpkinpie4ever
cho and most likely draco although i dont want him to cuz he is soooo hot! well he is with short hair so shut up! and never mind what i said because i just remembered that GoF is the last harry potter film tom's gonna do so down with MOlLFOY!!!hheheh

It's Tom's last? Seriously? Why? It is going to be so awkward with a new Malfoy... it will be like when they got a new Dumbledore. It just isn't the same.

amburger1984
Hello, this is my first post on this thread! I think Professor McGonagall is the one who will die. I really don't want her to die, but I think it makes the most sense. I am listing the reasons why I think she will die below.

1. She is Dumbledore's second banana. (Deputy Headmistress)
2. She is the head of Gryffindor.
3. She is one of Harry's mentors and a Grandmother-like figure to Harry.
4. She is old. I don't think Jo will kill off another student unless there are other adult deaths. Since she is getting to be a bit older, I think Jo will kill her off because it will fuel Harry's anger and it will give him more reason to carry out her wishes of him. (i.e. OofP, Chapter 29 "Career Advice": McGonagall says to Harry "Potter...I will assist you to become an Auror if it is the last thing I do!" Think about that, people.
5. I think McGonagall will die trying to save one of her students. We know that she was seriously injured while trying to protect Hagrid last year, and perhaps she will rush into battle without thinking and get hit with a fatal curse.
6. She was alive during the last war, and it is very possible that she could be a target for a Death Eater who has a grudge against her or her family.
I'm sure there are many other reasons why McGonangall might be the next victim, but I can't think of the at the moment. Feedback is appreciated.

NightCrawler341
Which character do YOU WANT to die in the future books. And McGonagall ain't stupid enough to run into battle and die.

amburger1984
Well, in that case, I don't want ANYBODY to die. Hope that clears things up.

NightCrawler341
*Cough* Lockhart! *cough* Though I know he wonr be any other books.

TheSun
Originally posted by NightCrawler341
Which character do YOU WANT to die in the future books. And McGonagall ain't stupid enough to run into battle and die.
She already ran into a battle where she was outnumbered and in the dark to try and help Hagrid, and she almost died then.

Anoushka
Originally posted by TheSun
Although there are certain similarities between HP and LOTR - there are similarities between HP and Nancy Drew. You can't just go and compare one author to another and say that's that.

there're also similarities btn star wars and HP yes

and,i don't know,i just don't think she (prof M) will die....it's a teensy bit overkill after sirius i think....

NightCrawler341
What would be the point of killing her? I think, since we are on the subject, that Dumbledore dying will make more sense.

Anoushka
yup!i was thinking that too...we know that either voldemort or harry has to die,so what i think is (if it's a 'happy' ending) dumbledore'll die defending harry while harry kills voldemort or both harry n he will die and the end of the wizarding world as we know it will come.

then again i;m most prob being v extreme heh happy

NightCrawler341
I remember someone saying Ron should die so Harry can get Hermione and defeat Voldemort and be all happy and famous and said that was a happy ending.... Does anyone remember who said that?

TheSun
Originally posted by NightCrawler341
I remember someone saying Ron should die so Harry can get Hermione and defeat Voldemort and be all happy and famous and said that was a happy ending.... Does anyone remember who said that?
Some idiot.

NightCrawler341
I think that is what I said... or something like "Happy ending? Your a idiot" or something of the sort.

The Irish lad
How things.. i'm new.

I think Ron might sacrifice himself to save Harry like in the philosephers stone in the chess board only this time instead of just getting hurt he'll die. sad sad

star_scar_child
i diddnt say it would be a happy ending i said it would be a good ending, and i diddnt say that harry would get hermione i said it was possible, but there are alot of clues as to why ron would die

star_scar_child
i think i posted them to

SltherinQueenDM
I know one of the Weasleys have to die.. Rowling hinted that it might be one no

NightCrawler341
Let it be Percy.

star_scar_child
oh yea and it wasnt a spoiler, just a theory, with lots of evidence

JohnnyBloom
Originally posted by NightCrawler341
Let it be Percy.

yeah - most people will be thinking that because of his arguement with the family in OotP - but i'm starting to think it might not be him!!!
sad confused

NightCrawler341
Then who could it be? They way I see it, it is Percy is being attack, Mr.Weasly and him get over their fight and tries to help him, Percy says sorry and told everyone he was sorry about not believing them, and dies. But that is just my guess.

mcdara
Originally posted by TheSun
Although there are certain similarities between HP and LOTR - there are similarities between HP and Nancy Drew. You can't just go and compare one author to another and say that's that.

Nancy Drew?? Yeah right, I'll tell you what, show me the simularities that match the ones between Nancy Drew and HP

LOTR - 1st fight - Troll
HP - 1st fight - Troll

LOTR - Dark Lord
HP - Dark Lord

LOTR - Cursed Scar
HP - Cursed Scar

LOTR - Worm Tounge
HP - Worm Tail

LOTR - Shelob
HP - Aragog

LOTR - Nazgul
HP - Dementors

I could keep going ... Sam didn't die...Ron won't die.

Frodo defeated the Dark Lord

Harry will defeat the Dark Lord

Frodo went off to the Havens

Harry will go through the vale and meet up with his parents and Sirius

TheSun

NightCrawler341
Connections to different books are just coincidences.

TheSun
Originally posted by NightCrawler341
Connections to different books are just coincidences.
Exactly my point.

Director_Joe
Who did I think is gonna die? Hmmm....probably been said before but I'll say it again... Dumbledore.... yeah he's gonna kick the bucket.... he's got to....it would symbolize the death of Harry's protection and he'd have to start fighing for himself...(which he normally does but Dumbledore always has a way of telling him he was helped in someway)

NightCrawler341
Which character do you want to die in future books? Not Who do you think is going to die.

sugar&sweet
i dont no, mayb ginny coz then harry will show his true feelings for her. wink smile

NightCrawler341
But... she'd be dead...

Hermione202
nah , I don't think Ginny will die

NightCrawler341
Good. ^.^

sugar&sweet
Originally posted by NightCrawler341
But... she'd be dead... she mite come back as a ghost, i mean u never no in hp books

NightCrawler341
What would be the point though? Can't date a ghost.... or can you....

Hermione202
no you can't.................can you?

NightCrawler341
Dum dum dum!!!!

sugar&sweet
lol, good question. i wonder if it will ever be answer?

NightCrawler341
Someone go ask a ghost.

sugar&sweet
ok, but first i need to find a ghost. do u know any?

NightCrawler341
*Pulls out shotgun* Who wants to be a ghost first?

sugar&sweet
lol, * slowly leaves the thread*

NightCrawler341
xD

sugar&sweet
smile angel

kier14matrix
I want Professor Umbridge to die, even though i doubt she will even be in the books anymore. This is because i hate people like her in real life and they really get on my ****, i just feel like shoving thier teeth so far down their throat that they'll have to sit on food to eat it!

and guys reply to what the topic is asking "What character so you WANT to die in future books" instead of just writing "i think dumbedore will die (sad)" -- its not freaking asking who you think is gonna die! sorry i just like to rant once in a while.

JLRTENJAC
Let's see... Percy, Fudge, any one related to Umbrige, Lucius, Draco, Crabbe, Goyle, umm., Tom (You know evil face ), and on, and on











UMBRIGE MAKES ME WANT TO UGHHH sick sick

kier14matrix
And Fudge is also a ****, if he dies then Dumbledore will become Minister of magic :-D, hmm don't think a wand will be able to stop a shotgun...

DanFan4000
do u really think that?

kier14matrix
yeah, if i'm quick enough stick out tongue, but they'd get spawny and probs end up turning the shotgun on me and blowing my brains out confused hehe

kier14matrix
not that i'm ever gonna get in a fight with a wizard obviously but you know

mcdara

NightCrawler341
I don't think JKR followed anything. I think she written the story herself, and these are mere coincidences.

Saberstylemasta
I want Hermionie and Ron to die. sorta liek this.

ok, so Hermy's all in danger and crap cuz she pissed off voldemort, and rons all like, , "No, don't kill her!" so he kills ron instead. Then Hermy's all like, "YO PUNK!
I don't like how u killin ron and junk like that!" so voldemort kills her too.

there'd be more details and feelings described, but I dun feel like it.

DarkCanadian
Originally posted by Saberstylemasta
I want Hermionie and Ron to die. sorta liek this.

ok, so Hermy's all in danger and crap cuz she pissed off voldemort, and rons all like, , "No, don't kill her!" so he kills ron instead. Then Hermy's all like, "YO PUNK!
I don't like how u killin ron and junk like that!" so voldemort kills her too.

there'd be more details and feelings described, but I dun feel like it.
Oooooooooooooookay........

NightCrawler341
Originally posted by Saberstylemasta
I want Hermionie and Ron to die. sorta liek this.

ok, so Hermy's all in danger and crap cuz she pissed off voldemort, and rons all like, , "No, don't kill her!" so he kills ron instead. Then Hermy's all like, "YO PUNK!
I don't like how u killin ron and junk like that!" so voldemort kills her too.

there'd be more details and feelings described, but I dun feel like it.

... I'll have what he's havin'

DarkCanadian
Ron dies, but I would prefer that Harry's closest friends don't die. It'd probably make me cry.

"And right now, several hundred thousand kids are crying their eyes out over the passing of dear Professor Dumbledore."

Saberstylemasta
Originally posted by amburger1984
Hello, this is my first post on this thread! I think Professor McGonagall is the one who will die. I really don't want her to die, but I think it makes the most sense. I am listing the reasons why I think she will die below.

1. She is Dumbledore's second banana. (Deputy Headmistress)
2. She is the head of Gryffindor.
3. She is one of Harry's mentors and a Grandmother-like figure to Harry.
4. She is old. I don't think Jo will kill off another student unless there are other adult deaths. Since she is getting to be a bit older, I think Jo will kill her off because it will fuel Harry's anger and it will give him more reason to carry out her wishes of him. (i.e. OofP, Chapter 29 "Career Advice": McGonagall says to Harry "Potter...I will assist you to become an Auror if it is the last thing I do!" Think about that, people.
5. I think McGonagall will die trying to save one of her students. We know that she was seriously injured while trying to protect Hagrid last year, and perhaps she will rush into battle without thinking and get hit with a fatal curse.
6. She was alive during the last war, and it is very possible that she could be a target for a Death Eater who has a grudge against her or her family.
I'm sure there are many other reasons why McGonangall might be the next victim, but I can't think of the at the moment. Feedback is appreciated.

She could also die, because with both dumbledorr(if he dies) and Mcgonnagall gone, he'll have no addult left at Hogwarts.

NightCrawler341
Originally posted by DarkCanadian
Ron dies, but I would prefer that Harry's closest friends don't die. It'd probably make me cry.

"And right now, several hundred thousand kids are crying their eyes out over the passing of dear Professor Dumbledore."

Seriously, I think he needed to die. Hell, he has been through enough with Harry and the poor old guy needs a long vacation! I think Harry is starting to give him gray hairs anyway.

DarkCanadian
*gasp*

HE DID NOT DESERVE TO DIE!

NightCrawler341
Put yourself in his shoes. Having to have a bunch of little ungrateful brats (i'm not talking about the Harry Potter gang) bugging the crap out of you and help keep this damn kid alive each year, worrying about him and such. Give him a nice long vacation, will ya? He would have died from exhaustion anyway.

Imaginary
Sorry I disagree with you there, Night.

I reckon Hagrid... he annoys the hell outta me for some reason.

NightCrawler341
Originally posted by DarkCanadian
*gasp*

HE DID NOT DESERVE TO DIE!

I never said he deserved, I said he needed to die.

Imaginary
I suppose... it's important to the plot. Harry needs to get through this alone, which makes me think he'll stay that way until after book 7.

NightCrawler341
He wont be alone, Ginny will be with him. ^.^

DarkCanadian
Originally posted by NightCrawler341
He wont be alone, Ginny will be with him. ^.^
Finish the book, you'll see what Imag means.

Imaginary
Yep yes

NightCrawler341
Gah... fine. I'm off then and will be back later. I got to keep off this thing anyway, gotta finish book.

DarkCanadian
KMC is not a THING. It is a FORUM SITE.


I am highly protective of this place.

Imaginary
Happy reading smile

Ken Kenobi
Originally posted by NightCrawler341
He wont be alone, Ginny will be with him. ^.^

Where's the spoiler tags?

Please use the tags if this is true.

NightCrawler341
I'm a Harry/Ginny Shipper, I'm going to want Ginny with Harry if it's true or not.

shadow12
snape because he is a two-timeing traitor

Lillic0rr
SNAPE!!!! URGH im SO pissed...

And bellatrix, and VOLDEMORT, lol.

Lillic0rr
Originally posted by NightCrawler341
I'm a Harry/Ginny Shipper, I'm going to want Ginny with Harry if it's true or not.

NightCrawler341
Originally posted by Lillic0rr
SNAPE!!!! URGH im SO pissed...

And bellatrix, and VOLDEMORT, lol. Its a book, chillax. Originally posted by shadow12
snape because he is a two-timeing traitor I think that is three-timing traitor.

Anoushka
Originally posted by DarkCanadian
Ron dies, but I would prefer that Harry's closest friends don't die. It'd probably make me cry.

"And right now, several hundred thousand kids are crying their eyes out over the passing of dear Professor Dumbledore."

lot of us predicted that though so i don't think it comes as a shock -shrugs-

but it is sad,you have to admit sad

but atleast there's the portrait!roll eyes (sarcastic) not as if they'll never speak again.

DarkCanadian
I want to beat Snape's head off with a crowbar now.

TheSun
Originally posted by Anoushka
lot of us predicted that though so i don't think it comes as a shock -shrugs-

but it is sad,you have to admit sad

but atleast there's the portrait!roll eyes (sarcastic) not as if they'll never speak again.
Portraits can only repeat what the real people would have said in life, like catchphrases.

babysooner13
Something sad. Dumbledore dies in the 6th book.

DarkCanadian
Originally posted by TheSun
Portraits can only repeat what the real people would have said in life, like catchphrases.
Ah, but we don't know that for sure. Look at those two in OotP, Dilys Derwent and someone else...they acted like their selves had been actually living inside the portriat istelf.

TheSun
Originally posted by DarkCanadian
Ah, but we don't know that for sure. Look at those two in OotP, Dilys Derwent and someone else...they acted like their selves had been actually living inside the portriat istelf.
JKR herself told us that they could only repeat catchphrases. We do know for sure.

DarkCanadian
Even so, Dily Derwent acted like her normal self in OotP.

LoVeRgIrL
i dont know.............Snape

DarkCanadian
Where'd she say this, TS?

ladygrim
no expression

TheSun
Originally posted by DarkCanadian
Where'd she say this, TS?
Lol, I've read so many online chats..I'll try and find it, I definitely know she said it though.

Imaginary
Oooh that's what I was referring to when I mentioned portraits in another thread. It'd be hilarious to have Dumbledore saying "Nitwit! Blubber! Oddment! Tweak!" in portrait form laughing out loud

<< THERE IS MORE FROM THIS THREAD HERE >>