Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

uh green day are NOT punk rock, u no this is starting to annoy me the whole punk rock shit, green day are pop/punk!, good charlotte are pop/punk! simple plan are pop/punk!. punk/rock is screaming and shit do u really see those bands screaming? no. i had to just cover that i don have anything against green day i have their new album its just like whith the poser avril lavigne she claims her music is punk! she a ****ing idiot. and like hilary duff claiming her musics rock? i mean wat the **** is wrong with these people?. the used are punk/rock!. afi are punk/rock u no bands like that.!. i hate posers and preps and they need 2 die. anyone here into heavy metal music?

\m/
~Krissy~

i like ACDC

I don't really mind how people define what music "is". But then I guess it can be annoying to label things incorrectly....

i'd still put Greenday under the label of punk rock, they may have more soft edged songs but their music is still solid and has alot of rock in it

I call all those bands nu-punk.
They'll never stop being called punk, but they dont have the fury and the energy of the Sex Pistols, the rage of the Clash.

C'mon guys who cares what they are, they're putting punk(ish)-rock back in the charts for the first time in like a decade. Yay for Green Day!

Punk is known for being political... and Green Day are often political!

Yeah, they're not the Clash or the Sex Pistols... Nobody makes that kind of punk anymore, learn to deal with it. They're a pop rock band with punk elements, and pretty decent to boot.

Green Day makes good music, so really I could care less if they're punk or pop/punk.

>.< i DONT CARE what they are


i like them... people spend to much time worring about what the media thinks. i say if it sounds good listen to it and call it by the band name. there is not liking of a certian genre...

and greenday have been around long enough now to not be classed as `nu-school" punk anyway. without Dookie and Smash by the offspring, god knows where punk would have gone in the 90s

i like RATM




















































































































someone is pissed
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v364/youngz/ProfetTechniqueSig.gif

The correct answer is who gives a shit.

Cool pic hh

I'd call those bands shit rock.

thanks DR

I hate The Used. Green Day are better than the used whether they are punk or not. Personally I don't care if they are punk.. punk rock fans are so damn picky about what is and isn't punk.. I've heard people argue that the clash isn't punk. What difference does it make? Music should be put into two categories: good music and bad music. Beyond that you're just grouping bands together that may have a similar sound/style/whatever, which is fine, but shouldn't matter when you are deciding if you like that band or not.

Thanks professor.

G.G Allan and teh Misfits

I like metal

Welcome to the year 1994. And the Used aren't punk rock.

I like Metal.

hey greenday and simple plan r my favorite bands.
It even sez on simple plan's website they dont cliam to be rock/punk.
Dont judge music by its genre.
just beacause theyre not rock/punk doesnt make them bad. I just had to say that. Sorry if i offended any 1.

I'll sort this debate out right now. Catagories? Ok.

Green Day: Great.

Simple Plan, Good Charlotte and Avril Lavigne: Shit.

Done.

Also, someone with the name Goth_Girl99 shouldn't be saying posers need to die.

-AC

I like mahogony with a varnished finish!

You also like leather don't you Korri.

-AC

No life 'till leather pimp

i love metal im in a metal band called Nothing but Losers you can check us out with the link in my sig

clapping down with Green day


heavy metal droolio

Oaks best though.

nah not really...

She only likes Mahogany with a varnished finish coz of the....

Erm....ha.

-AC

I dont get the gag...

She does.

In many ways.

-AC

i dont feel it either..

i agree, its still got the word "punk" so its good
(if you get what i mean)

avril doesnt class herself as punk

Yeah the Used are Emo, im not a massive punk Rock Fan, but i Love Heavy Metal and Alterative metal and the occasional bit of Emo

punk rock and emo for me

Metal is my friend, it gives me life and keeps me sane. I .....thought metal was my friend.

I never used to think that greenday were punk, until i listened to all of their songs and actually compared them to other bands like the sex pistols and the clash, and you know what, they are punk. There's nothing you can do about it. Get over it and get on with your life.

i agree with wolf dog who gives a shit

green day,simple plan and good Charlotte don't claim to be any genre of music its just that ppl that write about bands needs to put them under a category