Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Who wins?

Jedi Anakin (ROTS) is super hot!!! that Black Helmet doesnt do anything for Baily.... He likes his men, all hot and well not burnt... and I like women, so dont get started on me, people.... I am a ladies man... not a man's man!!

Of course Jedi Anakin wins, Vader can't fight as well as he could in the past (that black suit gives him personality but not the strenght he used to have).

but Vader seems more patient than Anakin. Anakin has a tendency to attack before thinking. He doesnt think.

that's what makes him so powerful

Vader doesn't seem patient at all... not sure where you get that idea.

Hes more cunning than the old Skywalker

i'd say vader-pre suit...because I still think he will be vader before the suit. This is when he's is at his most POWERFULL, but later with the suit, he's less powerfull, but has more KNOWLEDGE of the force, which kind of balences things out.

dude he is old broken and disabled.
pre suit wins hands down

So?

Jedi Anakin will whip Sith Vader in utter and convincing fashion.

Vader in the suit may have been more experienced but he is far too old and crippled to match the speed of Anakin before his lava pit incident.

Darth Vader should be able to beat anybody with the force choke ability, but that doesn't seem to be the case.

No, it certainly isn't the case. Anyone who can use the force can simply counter it.

So anyone that challenges Vader who isn't a force user is a dead man I'm guessing.

Vader, suit or no suit.

While Anakin just fights without thinking, Vader phykes his opponents out. He talks the entire time, much like his Master does, which gives him an edge. he throws their game off. And NOBODY try to compare Luke winning, to this. Vader gave up there, but still, Vader would defeat Anakin....but not by much.

Does the costume slow down Vader?

ummmm, obviously

he seems to handle Luke OK

...Vader hands down. The Dark Side is more powerful, and Vader knows much more then ANakin, Technigues, Pationce, and Strategies.

Yeah Darth would destroy little skywalker

Exactly.
I concure.

ANakin wins by far.

YOUR ALL MORONS! MY GOD YOU ALL LIKE THAT TWIT THAT LIKES TO GET HIS OWN WAY CONSTANTLY OTHER THAN THE COOL BLACK ARMOURED DUDE!!!! HAVE SOME COMMON SENCE!

sence?

Anyway Vader wins.
He is better, stronger and darker.

Yeah hes alot better

Sidious's a better tutor than Obi-Wan. Sith Vader prevails.

The dark side fuels Sith Anakin's power which was already considerable when he was Jedi Anakin, so I believe Sith Anakin has the upper hand. Yes I believe the dark side to be stronger.

Well I don't I just belive Vader to be.

Jedi,he would be abel to move quicker and he looks better

Vader would win however if it was evil anakin i dunno

episode III anakin easily.

Well, darkside Anakin is easily angered. I'm willing to bet if Padme's name came out, dark Anakin would mess up and light Anakin would take him down.

Actually i wanna change my vote. Vader wins. Sidious trained him better than Obi-Wan. The Jedi ANakin was foolish. Not Darth Vader

ok am i the only one who has seen the movies? cmon guys, vader wins hands down. He's waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay more powerful/experienced. some of your guys' ignorance annoys me. Seriously though, Vader would destroy anakin.

Darth is slower than Jedi Anakin.

Therefore he wins.

Not true, Obi-Wan is a bit slower and he's a lot less powerful, but Obi-Wan manages to win. MECH Vader would wait for the right moment and sever both his arms then kick him a whole bunch.

Darth Vader is actually very powerfull just doesnt have that speed. Plus he has more experience, he would abolish light side anakin and theres really not that much to it.
Anyone gonna writr a story for this i'd really like to see one?

I suppose someone should
gimme a week or two

sad...just sad...

dantheman says that vader would beat anakin, sad indeed

dantheman is right then. suit vader would whoop up on little annie.

You guys do realize that they are the same person?

they have different mindsets and different physical apperences, i think of them as two seperate beings.

thats a good assesment, yet.. One is slower and the other one twirls his lightsaber like a boat propeller. This is a hard fight.. why? One is more powerful in the force and has patience. The other is aggresive and relies on physical strength more than suit vader might...

Suited Vader relies on strength less? What the hell? He lifts a full-grown man two feet into the air, snaps his neck, and throws his corpse aside with one arm. That's inhuman strength right there. Watch also the Cloud City encounter. He beats Luke to the ground with his right arm, and towards the battle's end, hammers him like a madman. Vader relies on strength far more than his younger self, simply because he has it in incredible amounts.

Thats, his mechanical arm kicking the shit out of the poor man. I mean strength lightsaber wise..

IF he couldent beat Luke in a saberlock, well thats sad..

I personally think Vader threw the fight in ROTJ. I mean, it parrelels the Dooku/Anakin fight in ROTS in that way. OT Vader was incredibly strong (And noticeably slower, too) and for him to put up such a feeble defense against a hacking, mad young Luke just reeks of faking.