Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

I know that American Idol focuses on individual singers. But what if they had a version of the show where bands could play instead of just one person. I think this would be better since it would eliminate the pop singer crap and bring in some cool rock stuff.

doubt anythin cool could ever come from American Idol...

That may be true, but i would like to see some good rock bands get the chance to go on the show

Sounds like a pretty cool idea...too bad it will never happen...

Yea, IT would be tight because there are some good underground, unsigned bands there. And it would draw more of an audience. People who hate/dislike pop but lik ebands or rock. as well as the people who allready watch American Idol

we should try and sell the idea to fox

"That may be true, but i would like to see some good rock bands get the chance to go on the show"

No good rock band would want a chance on the show.

-AC

True, but if a band was desperate enough to make it big, they would...

prolly come out with a new shittier version of Maroon 5 or something

Stinky up there is right.

Yeah... besides even if a great band did go there Simon would probably just ***** about their image or something.. I really can't see any of the judges liking any good rock music.

lmao imagine randy and whats her face trying to judge a band that just played a death metal song

"That was literally the worst display of musical ability I have ever seen." *Lead singer smashes Simon over the head with a guitar*

i would love to see that

That would be great...I wouldn't mind seeing Simon get smashed with a guitar

They could get new judges.
Also, i think many bands would be perfectly willing to go on the show. It could be a perfect way to get some attention to their band and hit it big

Simon is my hero...
I've only seen the show once, and already he's my hero...
I wish I could tell singers they sucked to their faces with no repercussions

Oh yeah, I definitely love how he disses on pretty much every contestant...but still it'd be great to have him diss some group and then get smacked upside the head with a guitar or something

It's dumb though.

Why go on a show with inevitably shit people and then complain how many shit people you get?

My mother watches it. Can't STAND it.

-AC

My little sister LOVES the show...only time I watch it is the first few episodes when they show all the bad people who try out, it's hysterical.

bump

LOL, hilarious.