Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Use this thread to post hypothetical questions about comic book stories. For example, what would happen if the Hulk was injected with both Captain America's super serum and Bane's Venom?

He'd have horrible horrible diarrehea, or at least I'd imagine so...

What if Professor X had joined with Magneto in the quest to conquer humanity?

What if Uncle Ben lived?

What if Mephisto had claimed the soul of The Silver Surfer?

mutants would rule...



no spiderman... simple as that... peter would probably be a world renowned scientist...

wat if cyclops had control over his powers from the beginning?

He wouldn't need help, wouldn't know what it was like to be an outcast and therefore might even have become a villain.

not sure, i mean he was in an orphanage regardless...

maybe he'd be different personality wise, but i still think he'd be an x-man...

he'd probably be more laid back (but only slightly)

no visor though

What if......WHAT IF.......The X-Men got hit by cosmic rays instead?

-AC

as opposed to being mutants?

what if stan lee created the DC universe? (there was a comic series about this)
http://jerome.galica.free.fr/dc%20comics/Jla/justimagine/justimagine.htm

"what if stan lee created the DC universe? "

It'd be better than it is.

-AC

I doubt it. But they did release a TPB about that 'what if?'. I dont know who owned the rights to it though.

What if the maority of superheros were african american.
It'd be like
wolvie: "Yo, wasssup N!gga"
cyke: "im gonna whoop your b!tch asss, homie"
wolvie: "awww dawg, you gotta be kiddin man"
cyke: "what, you wanna piece of me, man. I will KILL your punk asss"
wolvie: "you trippin man. "
emma: "you n!ggas need to chill out. Try one of my home-made blunts"
wolvie: "this sh!t's the bomb, n!gga"
cyke: "word"

So in other words, the X-men would all be disgruntled rappers. I wouldnt mind seein magneto layin down some of those mad fat beats. I think beast would be da bombest rapper do.

What if Nick fury wasnt apart of sheild...would the punisher still be alive?

11: your sig is disturbing.....

I thought it was good.

What if: apocolypse founded the x-men

But he would still have his powers...maybe an wrestler or athlete. An intelligent one, too.

what if rogue absorbed all of the abstracts and celestials?

that too, he'd definately use them to create a good life for may and ben...

i sincerely doubt that...

/\agreed.

What if 2+2 did not make 5.

while i respect stan lee's contributions to marvel (the guy invented my favourite character), i despise what he did with dc...

I like DC the way it is now.

and if Stan Lee did that to Batman, I would flip out.

reminds me of the old hula hoops ad with harry enfield (anyone british or irish will know what i mean)...

OI! stan! nooooooooo!

what if Batman joined the Xmen....that'd be sweet.

he and cyclops would clash (leadership issues)

hmmmm...I always thought he'd and Beast would class...both being super nerds and all.

nah... he'd definately clash with cyclops (neither would take orders from the other), and he'd clash with logan also...

Batman: Scott I think your a great leader....

Scott: here it comes but...

Batman: but I think if we do my plan we can take down Magneto once and for all.

Logan: as in killing him? (smiling) Bats I like your style.

What if Jamie Madrox was bitten by the radioactive spider instead of Peter Parker?

the amazing multiple spidermen?

What if Superman had a heart attack while fighting Lex?
What if Batman had to go to the bathroom while fighting Mr. Freeze?
What if Mister Freeze got a cold and ran out of medicine?
This thread is weird.

Pot calling kettle black?

Yeah, I think so.

logan would clash with batman more than scott...

What in the world are you talking about?

what if the venom absorb half the x men muhahahaha

he'd have to be able to in the first place...

I'm finding it hilarious that you would comment on a thread being wierd, when you post uber-wierd ones ALL the time.

What if Proffessor Xavier's first recruitment drive for the X-Men was a success, as early on in a 60's issue of the X-Men, he went around and asked Spider-Man, Quicksilver, Scarlet Witch...and finally, shamefully the Mimic to join?

we'd have a weird x-men alright...

what if dr doom got the infinity gauntlet

That's a good one! He almost did...twice, though the second time it would have been useless.

What if Shriek had succeeded in corrupting Spider-man?

http://www.spiderfan.org/comics/title/spiderman_amazing-16.html#390

what if everyone in the MU was a llama?

what if dr.strange became friends with odin and learned the magik of the runes....

what if the Justice league had to fight the Apocalypse and Magneto and the Xmen had to fight Darksied and Lex Luthor in his power suit?

what if all the superman rip offs met and fought (gladiator, sentry, .....)

what if on the Teen Titans cartoon Slade was really Bruce wayne from like 20 years in the future and he wanted to kill Dick Grayson (the robin on the cartoon) for something he was gonna do that would lead to Batman becoming Slade...I know Bruce isn't Slade..but it's a what if...okay and what if Magneto killed all the normal humans...project mutant only earth...that'd be sweet.

What if franks son lived would he still become the punisher?

dude...in the make your own exile thread...I had his son Frankie live...Frank became the punisher and Frankie his son became the Eliminator...I always felt bad for Frank so I said "hell, I could have his son still be alive". what if Xavier killed magneto?

No more brotherhood of evil mutants

hmmm...what if Sabertooth joined the Xmen and Wolverine joined the Brotherhood?

Sabertooh would be a cool x-man!

hmmmm..what if Rogue and Gambit had a kid?

Spiderman and Mimic are not mutants, possibly making them short term X-Men at the most. I doubt these two would get along with each other either causing a liability (Mimic was arrogant).



Actually done already in the "What if" continuum. Punisher was still a gun toting killer, but was less psychotic.



A person who's both attractive and charming, but untouchable? That child would eventually become the most irresistible person in the world!

WHAT IF.....A fanboy got laid?

never... unless it was with a fangirl...

DUDE......you gave away the surprise ending!

She would absorb it and kill it while its still in the womb. She cant help herself from killing or absorbing whoever she touches, so it would be the same there

In Exiles, Magneto and Rogue had a son (Magnus) and the reason he worked briefly with Exiles was for the fact that in his dimension change, he somehow changed the molecules of his mother that hardened/encased and killed her (something like that).

WHAT IF......Wolverine killed his fanboys?

what if the term fanboy didnt sound like a homosexual side kick

what if batman had killed the joker.

what if batman didn't stop superman from killing the joker?

what if:
2 of the x-men had a gay marrage

there are gay x-men already (northstar in uncanny and colossus in ultimate, f*cking hacks...)

but what if they got married???

question, are there any gay characters in dc? just curious...

what if magneto's brotherhood became the x-men and xaviers x-men became he brotherhood

magneto would rule the world...

yeah thats what I thought cause he'd push the x-men to their full potential

no, just that they'd beat the brotherhood any day of the week...

well yeah that too - a lot of humans would be dead too

colossus is gay?

the ultimate one yeah

its a crock of shit...

I thought he was dead? is this another guy with the same power?

ultimate xmen is a parallel universe where they're all teenagers, its colossus...

in astonishing x-men he was brought back from the dead recently...

what if Batman had Superman powers and attacked the marvel universe?
what if the Hulk stayed smart?
what if the Hulk movie didn't suck?
what if the smurfs joined the Xmen?
what if Fred Flintstone was Spiderman?
what if Yogi Bear joined the Sinster Six?
What if the Teen Titans cartoon looked like the Justice League Unlimited Cartoon?
What if Doc Ock would have married Aunt may?
What if Batman went to vist Robin on the TT cartoon and had a run in with Slade?
What if we didn't have to wait 3 years for Xmen movies?

what if Batman had Superman powers and attacked the marvel universe ? Batman would crush the Marvel universe, Until he ran into a God or something.

what if the Hulk stayed smart? Than Hulk would not go on his anger rages.
what if the Hulk movie didn't suck? Than it would be a Good movie.

what if the smurfs joined the Xmen? The Xmen would have some one to counqer the evil plans of Grogale(You know the evil wizard guy with the Cat)

what if Fred Flintstone was Spiderman? We would have a very FAT Spiderman. And he be busy eating Burger King out of food, and letting the Robbers get away)

what if Yogi Bear joined the Sinster Six? He would send the Sinster 6 on Pincitk Bastket raids.

What if the Teen Titans cartoon looked like the Justice League Unlimited Cartoon? It might not have been as good as it is than. Not offense to JLU, that is a great Series too.

What if Doc Ock would have married Aunt may? They have childen with 6 robot arms on there backs lol. Oh yeah and they live happy ever after except Peter Parker, Who would hate his new step father.

What if Batman went to vist Robin on the TT cartoon and had a run in with Slade? Batman would put the smack down on Slade.

What if we didn't have to wait 3 years for Xmen movies? Than the movies will get bad, if they hurry them in to thearters undone and ete.

All by Mainstream

you like the fact the TT is set in a tiny toon like universe?

Yes, it not made to be seious, expect from a few shows like After Shock.

I like the slick it has, I would not put them in Tiny Toon artwork, But more like Mini Anime, NOT true Anime, But not Daffy Duck cartoon like either.

I dont know what to call it, but it looks good.

JLU has great artwork, Still useing the Dark Getko or so they call it.

okay far enough...more what if then.
what if Beast boy got Raven knocked up?
what if peter parker was raised by norman osborne?
what if Poppa smurf had to fight magneto?
what if Iceman joined the JLU?
what if the Joker was a superhero?
what if Batman was president?
what if they made a spider girl movie and Ashlee Simpson was Spider-girl.
what if Cable got a Talk show?

what if Batman had Superman powers and attacked the marvel universe?

he'd be sent packing by thor or surfer...

what if the Hulk stayed smart?

you know who professor hulk is?

what if the Hulk movie didn't suck?

it didn't... its better than x2 anyway...

what if the smurfs joined the Xmen?

jubilee would actually have someone to look down on...

what if Fred Flintstone was Spiderman?

he'd be dead... all the yabba dabba doo's wont stop a pumpkin bomb...

what if Yogi Bear joined the Sinster Six?

flintstone would kick his ass

What if the Teen Titans cartoon looked like the Justice League Unlimited Cartoon?

it would be an improvement...

What if Doc Ock would have married Aunt may?

peter would most likely be dead...

What if Batman went to vist Robin on the TT cartoon and had a run in with Slade?

batman takes him apart

What if we didn't have to wait 3 years for Xmen movies?

we might have some decent ones...

Again some easy answer lol. Maybe

okay far enough...more what if then.
what if Beast boy got Raven knocked up? They will have offspring, with Raven Powers and BB powers, the child will than grow up and be the greatness Superhero of all time. Think of it, He can change into any Beast he wants, and have Raven's Powers to boot. T-Rex useing thsos pick up powers lol.

what if peter parker was raised by norman osborne? We have the Green Spider. lol. He would ride on the Goblin jet, Thoughing Punkim bombs and useing the Spiderpowers. Oh yeah he would be a better Villian than Harry.

what if Poppa smurf had to fight magneto? Magneto would step on him

what if Iceman joined the JLU? MMM, He be on the back seat just like MM Man, (We dont need two guys with Ice Powers, So you have crowd potrol).
what if the Joker was a superhero? We have one CRAZY superhero lol. He catch the villians of couse, but bystanders will be killed by the Joker's reckless crazy actions.

what if Batman was president? He make a better Prez than Luthor. He also have the police in USA. Dress up as Batmen.

what if they made a spider girl movie and Ashlee Simpson was Spider-girl. The movie will bomb, and It will remind evey one of the time Sliverstone became Batgirl in Batman and Robin. lol

what if Cable got a Talk show? He be just like Space Ghost, And he have a supervillian to fill in Zoraks place on the show. Maybe Sinster?

okay.
what if Darkwing Duck fought Batman?
what if Cyborg never got hurt and became a pro athlete?
what if the world knew Peter Parker was Spiderman?
what if Batman never had a robin?
what if the Punisher learned his son Frank Jr was alive?
what if Iron Man went to the George Jetson universe?
what if Slade raised Beast boy?
what if 90 Xmen had to fight ten of the best fighters in the JLU?
what if the regular Titans had to fight Titans East to the death?

what if Darkwing Duck fought Batman?
Dark wing duck would get killed and batman out of guilt will take in launch pad as the new robin.

what if Cyborg never got hurt and became a pro athlete?
He would of been cought up in a high profile kidnaping , and in the rescue he would have gotten injured and become cyborg. cant escape fate.

what if the world knew Peter Parker was Spiderman?
Spiderman would be a world hero, and peter and his loved ones would targeted more then ever. But a spiderman with nothing to hide would become stronger.

what if Batman never had a robin? He would be alot darker, with alfred the only thing keeping him from becomeing someone like the punisher.

what if the Punisher learned his son Frank Jr was alive? He would go on a rampage killing spree untill he recovered his son.

what if Iron Man went to the George Jetson universe? He would bang judy

what if Slade raised Beast boy? Beast boy would be 100000 times more powerful, but slade would control him.

what if 90 Xmen had to fight ten of the best fighters in the JLU? They would lose, or join forces for some other stupid reason.

what if Robin fought the lizard?
what if Batman ruled the marvel universe?
what if micheal Jackson joined the Xmen?
what if Dazzler was on american idol?
what if Wolverine was on fear factor?
what if the justice league never formed?
what if Goku fought the Justice League Unlimited?
what if Terra wasn't a tratior?

Originally posted by Mainstream

what if micheal Jackson joined the Xmen?
That would be Hilarious.

Owwww.

He's start dancing and child mollesting in the middle of a fight

ahahhahahahahhahahahahahhahahahahaahhahhahaha!!!!!

Micheal Jackson: good job xmen sleep over in my room!

lol.
who would he team up with???

The new x-men acadamy kids ?

proberly...the underage mutants.

thats disturbing.

yet true...so very true.

What if...
Spidey ended up w/ Black Cat?
a symbiote bonded w/ the human torch?
Batman lost (or never had) all his money?

What if...

Spidey ended up w/ Black Cat? He would of been one happy camper and better super heros, the kidd-os would be raised as heros if they had powers and ether way would be great leaders as adults.

a symbiote bonded w/ the human torch? it would die the first time he flamed on

Batman lost (or never had) all his money? he would become the punisher, founding his revenge with dirty money taken from dead criminals. would not be as tech advanced and would use more fire arms. probly would meet his downfall sooner rather then later.

what if a symbiote boned with ice man?

lol typos are great

Originally posted by Jimmy Buggs
what if a symbiote boned with ice man?
what if the symbiote BONED iceman ????
He's have a sore behind.

what if Hulk went to Bedrock?
Angry Smurf became Hulk Smurf?
what if Darkwing duck fought Slade from the Teen Titans cartoon?
what if they did a "real world Justice League watchtower"?
what if Magneto killed Superman?

Originally posted by Mainstream
what if Hulk went to Bedrock?
Angry Smurf became Hulk Smurf?
what if Darkwing duck fought Slade from the Teen Titans cartoon?
what if they did a "real world Justice League watchtower"?
what if Magneto killed Superman?

nothing much...

blue hulk...

ok...

it would be run by america...

magneto could try... and fail...

try and fail...you don't think mags could use the earth magnetic forces to crush Kal-el?

he's not that powerful...

Superman has fought much tougher opponants before.
DC's version of magneto is FAR underpowered (D Polaris )

What if Jar Jar joined the JLA?
What if Batman became the spectre?
What if Dick Grayson became batman (by killing bruce)?
What if Wonder Woman was a lesbian??

Originally posted by eleveninches

What if Jar Jar joined the JLA?
What if Batman became the spectre?
What if Dick Grayson became batman (by killing bruce)?
What if Wonder Woman was a lesbian??

sweet f*ck... meesa kill dee darkseid...

bruce would run riot...

dick would never do that... but he might kill the joker...

there'd be some great ww comics...

what if time!
what if Raven were evil?
what if Batman were blind?
what if the Justice League went Rogue..or bad?
what if Cable were raised by Apoc?
what if Spiderman had to fight The Rogues...you know Captain Cold, kid Boomering, mirror master, Heatwave
what if the Xmen fought Doomsday?

Originally posted by Mainstream
what if time!
what if Raven were evil?
what if Batman were blind?
what if the Justice League went Rogue..or bad?
what if Cable were raised by Apoc?
what if Spiderman had to fight The Rogues...you know Captain Cold, kid Boomering, mirror master, Heatwave
what if the Xmen fought Doomsday?

meh...

batman would just invent something to help him fight crime... or make someone else batman...

batman would take them down...

new world order...

spidey would have an easier time methinks...

x-men go bye bye...

What if they made a Batman vs Wolverine movie?
what if they made a Justice League movie?
What if Superman fought Onslaught?
what if Batman was raised by Ra Al Ghul?
what if Harry Osborn had become spiderman and Peter Parker was the Green Goblin?
what if proffessor Hulk led the Xmen?

Originally posted by Mainstream
What if they made a Batman vs Wolverine movie?
what if they made a Justice League movie?
What if Superman fought Onslaught?
what if Batman was raised by Ra Al Ghul?
what if Harry Osborn had become spiderman and Peter Parker was the Green Goblin?
what if proffessor Hulk led the Xmen?

batman would win...

too expensive...

ra would rule the world...

not much would change...

they'd have a lot more clout...

I was reading the lastest issue of Wizard and I learn they're a better chance of seeing a JLA movie than their is of seeing a Wolverine Spiderman movie...I found that kinda odd.
what if Static Shock fought Electro?
what if Wolverine were President?
what if Batman would have stayed "broken " when Bane beat him?
what if Beast boy led the Titans?
what if all the marvel ulitmate heroes switched worlds with the regular marvel heros?

Originally posted by Mainstream
I was reading the lastest issue of Wizard and I learn they're a better chance of seeing a JLA movie than their is of seeing a Wolverine Spiderman movie...I found that kinda odd.
what if Static Shock fought Electro?
what if Wolverine were President?
what if Batman would have stayed "broken " when Bane beat him?
what if Beast boy led the Titans?
what if all the marvel ulitmate heroes switched worlds with the regular marvel heros?

no idea...

wolverine... thats funny...

no more batman...

titans...

the villains would rule the world...

what if Magneto fought Dr. Polaris?
what if the Beast got caught it the explosion that made the Hulk?
what if Wolverine remembered his origins?
what if Superman was evil and Lex were good?
what if the 2nd Robin didn't die?

Originally posted by Mainstream
what if Magneto fought Dr. Polaris?
what if the Beast got caught it the explosion that made the Hulk?
what if Wolverine remembered his origins?
what if Superman was evil and Lex were good?
what if the 2nd Robin didn't die?

magneto would wipe the floor with him...

"beast annihalate puny x-men..."

didnt he do that yet?

didnt they already have a story with luthor good and supes bad?

lot of pissed off fans...

what if the JLA fought Apoc?
what Spiderman would have joined he Xmen?
what if Venom made a movie?
what if Thor was a rapper?
what if Gambit joined the Brotherhood?

What if the Amalgam comics featured pantheon gods crossovers.

Thorus (thor-horus)
Zeudin (zeus-Odin)
Apposiris (apollo-osiris)

What if the Rock (wwe) joined the JLA???

what if pumpernickle peat was an X man

What if Wolverine would have died at the age of 6?

hmmmm he'd be the coolest dead mutant boy from Canada.

coolest DEAD mutant..

im still the coolest canadian mutant there is

What if...
There was a real-life detective called Bruce Wayne.


That would be SOOOO cool.!!!

WHAT IF....batman had superpowers?

he'd kick ass! and he wouldn't need that belt

then his pants would fall down

matrixness that'd suck

what if there was no correct answer to this 'what if' question?

what if , that made any scence to me?


what if , spidey become a GL?

Originally posted by Mainstream
matrixness that'd suck

but would he be as smart as he is currently? i mean he became super smart and street smart and physically good because he had no powers, and he hd to go the hieghts of human ability...iof he had powers, would he still be as intelligent and a strategist?

depends on the powers. what if he had a healing factor like wolive, or just the agility of spidey

say....enhanced strength and flight

What if the there was no chocolate!?!?!??!

so super-bat? maybe he would have studied fighting skills as much, and defently wouldnt spend as much time in the lab working of thingy things for his belt

Originally posted by eleveninches
What if...
There was a real-life detective called Bruce Wayne.


That would be SOOOO cool.!!!
Do you think that has come true in real life.???

what if spiderman became homosexual.

What if the Kyrptonite made superman 100000000000000 times more powerful and gave him other powers to his colection , and dicided to rule the Universe.

What if Silver Surfer had the full power of Galactus.

What if all the bad ass DC villans attack Marvel.

What if Darkeid didn't loose to Superman.

Originally posted by kgkg
what if spiderman became homosexual.
Oh gawd, that just caused the recollection of repressed mental images from atrocious Brock / Parker slash fanfiction *shudders*