Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

If you had to choose ONE member of the fellowship to die at Amon Hen, instead of Boromir, who would it be?
or would you still let Boromir die?

Legolas!!!





















joking.

As much as I love Boromir, I'll still want him to die, because it's the only way.


yeah, I'm being terribly lame today, but I'm loving it.

I want FRODO to die














...well...I know he couldnt...but I dont like him...and he irritates me... so DIE FRODO DIE!

I wanted frodo to die so much that I chanted for shelob just because he is a whining weak fool who hasn't got a violent or strong bone in his body, but no boromir died instead a guy who killed at least eleven uraks with three arrows in him, enough said.

Is violent physical strength the only strength?

How can you decide on someone else to die. Its impossible, there is no other way, Boromir had to die So I'm afaid I will have to vote for him.

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!

i don't want any of them to die cry
no! don't kill frodo! or legolas! or gimli or agagorn or sam! no no no don't do it! fear
*remembers that the books have already been written*

FRODO MUST DIE!

Lots of people seem to want Frodo to die.

But after reading exa's post it seems like Boromir IS the only member of the fellowhip that should die in the story.
And he does seem like the most obvious choice. And no doubt if any of the other characters died...it would change the rest of the story dramaticly.

But perhaps it is the TIMING of the deaths that would choose wheter it be fitting or not.

True that Gimli's death at Amon Hen would seem like an unwanted character...easily exited to make room for more 'important' characters. But what if he had died at the black gate instead?

But at the TIME...Amon Hen, at the end of the Fellowship of the Ring, Boromir is the only choice.

Had Merry been killed...the orcs might have taken SAM and pippen. Leaving Frodo to defend for himself. And even altering the paths of Rohan -Theoden, and Eowyn.

Had Aragorn been killed, Merry and Pippen would have been abondoned to torment and death, leaving legolas and gimli...following frodo, or just going back to their own lands.

But everything happened for a reason. and if any of these events were altered or changed, the outcome and ending would be very different.

The lives and even deaths of each character, are what drives the story of the 3rd age.

Merry

Legolas, cant stand him.

ill stay with the death of boromir im not a fan of his

noooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! noone can die

Legolas gots to die

borommir. i don't like him
or legolas, coz he was played by bloom

nooooooooo

what no?

no one can die!!!

world is too small for everyone to survive

yes, but not in Middle Earth crybaby

so gollum and sauron should survive too?

Well sauron should, definately.

*starts SAVE THE SAURON campany*

Thankya hug

you're wlecome hug

nooooo, only GOOD people should survive. Everyone bad DIE DIE DIEriflespam_laser

don't kill chris cry

only bad people, hang on, he is sauron!!!!

i'm confused

*joins campaign to keep sauron alvie*

If boromirs gonna live I too will join!(fellowship music)

gollum definatly should not die

everyone else ismy favorite and borimir has to die because then there wouldnt be much good sub-adventures after the fellowship breaks up and if he dosnt die then he would be alone cause he triedb to kill the ring berer and take the one ring and also if he didnt die protecting merry and pippen they both would be dead and thats not nice

Originally posted by gollum 921
gollum definatly should not die


gollum not a choice