Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Who wins?

NJo Luke can destroy Sidious like ten times over. This is a no-brainer.

Not destroy, but this would be the ultimate match up of light vs. dark, good and evil, skywalker vs. palpatine, jedi vs. sith etc etc.
IMHO Sidious is the most powerful Sith and Luke the most powerful Jedi. This would be incredible to behold. In fact I'll write out how I think it would work.

Uh, hate to break it to you, but Sidious is dead. If Luke's the "Son of the Son of the Force" like the prophecy says, he couldn't lose. Right? Besides, NJO Luke could contend with Exar Kun even at some level. I doubt Sidious could claim the same.

luke?
oh come on he would waste palps in 5mins

It'll be a good fight, but in the end, Palpy's ass is gonna have a painful meeting with Luke's foot.

LOL
GOOD one
jedimaster2000

Well, of course Sidious is dead, but it clearly says the ROTS Sidious.

Anyways, this IMO, is the ultimate Sith vs. the ultimate Jedi and I'm going to be finished with the battle soon.

what ultimate i mean luke IS ultimate bu sids is a b1tch compared to skywalker

Not true, Sidious is an incredible Sith lord and once episode 3 is out you'll realize how amazing he is. He has crazy powers and his saber style is...
you'll see

i m waiting hope i will see god fighting

DUUUUUUUUUUUDE, you have no idea....
The novels are just a hint compared the eye candy that awaits

i havent read the comics we can't buy them here so i just wait for the movie

usually batttles that are too good to be true only last for like 30 secs. For example Dooku vs. Yoda was an awesome match but it was only for 25 secs

Very true.

so I wonder how long Yoda vs. Sidious is.

All duels are supposed to be a couple of minutes each, with the epic 12 minute Obi-Wan and Anakin conflict. I read an interview with Nick Gillard a long time ago, and I know that isn't credible, but it was somewhere in this forum, so when I find it...

Since some folks are bringing back old posts randomly like dumb sh*ts, I figured this would be a good one.