Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Who will prevail?

Obi-Wan; Vader's too weak at that point to beat someone who is properly trained.

Obi-Wan Kenobi.

MICKEY MOUSE BULLSQUASH!
Maul outclassed Obi-Wan and could have won, but he let his arrogance get the better of him.
Vader would squash this chump like a bug

Originally posted by ArthasKnight
Obi-Wan; Vader's too weak at that point to beat someone who is properly trained.


I want to know, is that ACTUALLY true, or is it just because thats the way it was filmed? i mean it's a hell of a lot easier i'm sure to do fast lightsaber scenes now than it used to be. Plus does anakin lose all of his abilitys when he becomes Darth Vader? I read somewhere before that he shouldn't lose his abilitys cause he can still use the force. DUnno if i'm right or wrong, just bringing up my thoughts lol.

omg whoever said obi wan....go to like an "i dont kno jack sh1t forum" no offense or anything, but give me a break. vader would lay waste to TPM obi wan with ease. the only obi wan that culd beat vader is ROTS.

Vader goes from being more powerful than Sidious(potentially twice as powerful) to 80% less powerful. But he was still incredibly powerful, and had cybernetic enhancements General Grievous style, so he would still have really good reflexes and the force to beat some Obi-Wan ass with.

Jedi_Knightall, you're right, back then it was much harder to film a fight and the sabers they used weren't able to be moved as fast because they could have broken easier back then.

Truth is Vader is still more powerful than Obi-Wan and he wouldn't be wreckless like Maul was. Although Maul TOTALLY outclassed Obi-Wan.

OK what's all this about Maul TOTALLY outclassing Obi-Wan? Are there two different versions of TPM out there? Cause in the one I saw, Obi-Wan clearly held his own against the sith lord and had him on the run. I agree Maul is more powerful but saying he totally owned Obi-Wan in that duel is just a masterpiece in the art of BULLSHIT. And Yes, Vader very likely takes this one. I know OT Vader is weaker than ROTS Vader but still, you can't give the guy no props at all. Obi-Wan in TPM was still a padawan and was much less experienced than Vader. But I bet ROTS Obi-Wan can take Vader down though.

It's youth vs. experience. I have to give Vader props on this; he fought Luke one-handed early in the fight, and played it smooth like James Bond in a Playboy lounge.

Originally posted by Darth_Nefarus
Vader goes from being more powerful than Sidious(potentially twice as powerful) to 80% less powerful. But he was still incredibly powerful, and had cybernetic enhancements General Grievous style, so he would still have really good reflexes and the force to beat some Obi-Wan ass with.

Jedi_Knightall, you're right, back then it was much harder to film a fight and the sabers they used weren't able to be moved as fast because they could have broken easier back then.

Truth is Vader is still more powerful than Obi-Wan and he wouldn't be wreckless like Maul was. Although Maul TOTALLY outclassed Obi-Wan.

Maul was wreckless for an instant, and the instant cost him his life. if you'll notice(you know, during the entire duration of the fight up until that point) Maul makes Obi Wan his ***** the entire time. Point is though....Vader would eat TPM obi wan for breakfast.

Originally posted by jedimaster2000
OK what's all this about Maul TOTALLY outclassing Obi-Wan? Are there two different versions of TPM out there? Cause in the one I saw, Obi-Wan clearly held his own against the sith lord and had him on the run. I agree Maul is more powerful but saying he totally owned Obi-Wan in that duel is just a masterpiece in the art of BULLSHIT. And Yes, Vader very likely takes this one. I know OT Vader is weaker than ROTS Vader but still, you can't give the guy no props at all. Obi-Wan in TPM was still a padawan and was much less experienced than Vader. But I bet ROTS Obi-Wan can take Vader down though.

Maul was wreckless for an instant, and the instant cost him his life. if you'll notice(you know, during the entire duration of the fight up until that point) Maul makes Obi Wan his ***** the entire time. Point is though....Vader would eat TPM obi wan for breakfast.

sorry nefarus, i quoted the wrong one!!

Vader would win, Obi stands no real chance

Exactly. Although he's filled with rage, the darkside, etc. Mech Vader is experienced enough to whoop up.

Well, Obi-Wan did get a few good licks in before he got pushed into the pit. I really didn't think Maul had that much of an upper hand.

lol, he did.

If Maul didn't have that much of an upperhand, how come he was seperated from the fight for as long as he was?
Oh yeah, because Maul ninja kicked his ***** ass off the platform

LmFaO

Nefarus ur a tru sTud.

lol, thanks.
But I mean did everyone watch the same fight, Maul was toying with him almost. I admit, Obi-Wan pulled a slick move when sliced Maul's saber in half, but what did Maul do? He leaped upward, dodging a swing at the same time, then did this crazy flip over another swing, then parry parry, force push.
Pathetic Jedi

darth vader