Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

The dark side is tempting... must not fall... But they have peach cobbler. Must resist... Ok two jedi masters that eventually get killed. Who ever wins it does not really matter... Peach Cobbler...

Gonna have to go with Windu on this one, although Obi wan has a real skill for beating those who are better then him

This will be a very close fight. Mace has the edge on sheer skill, but Obi-Wan's resourcefulness will probably make up for that. Could go either way.

Mace, because in the book he is tied with Palpaltine. They are going to kill eachother in the fight if no one ifterfears. Later, when Yoda and Obi-wan are deciding who to fight, Obi-wan wants to fight Palpatine instead of Anakin but Yoda forbids it because it says he will NEVER be strong enough to challenge him. Maybe Yoda just thought that he would lose and was exagerating, but Mace tied with him. I think Mace came as almost as close as Yoda to beating him.

I say Mace.

Mace he is greatly honoured because of his lightsaber skills. Obi may be good, but he's no mace

but in the other thread u said how he was just sum wimpy guy who was legendary in a time where fights were rare.

He's no wimp, but indeed in legendaric in a time when fights are rare, but isn't Obi as well?

And if you have to choice between the two of them then its obviously Mace.

I agree Mace is a more devoted swordsman, but Obi-Wan has the resourcefulness, endurance and persaverence to win here. And if he did, it would be an extremely rough battle for him.

Also, Obi-Wan has been in more action during the clone wars, so you could argue that Obi-Wan is at least Mace's equal. Yes, Mace was a general too, but from my research, Obi-Wan was on the front line a lot more. thus he could reach the same level as Mace.

However, Vaapad is the X factor here, and that's why Mace would likely win. It attunes you to the entire force and that's why he matches Sidious. (Even though Sidious does let him win)

probably mace ,but ob1 is ninja and yoou never know what to expext from a ninja

exactly, he might just ninja kick a testicle or two and slice down windu

Well, I think that Obi-wan knows Mace well enough to expose a weakness or two, allowing Obi to escape the battle or something. Yet... If it had to be a battle to the death, I would probably have to go with Mace.

he cuts mece's balls and mace commits a suicide

he cuts mace's balls and mace commits a suicide

spam!

But seriously, Mace would likely take him down.

-Mace searching for obi's shatterpoint-

" I found it!"

http://images-eu.amazon.com/images/P/B0000DK4PO.02.LZZZZZZZ.jpg

LOL! pure genius my friend

lol

So it's Nicole Kidman?

Stupid, its the Ewan McGregore!

If you have think, Was Sidious Holding back in the Mace Vs Sidious Fight, Then you have to watch Sidious Fight in the Yoda Duel. is he wasnt holding back there

he was holding against yoda.....lol

I don't think he was holding back against Yoda because he was very eager to take out Yoda. The symbolism of their duel is very epic. Sith Master vs. head of the Jedi order