Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Which chapter of any of the LoTR books did you hate the most? Which one did you like the most?

I couldnt stand to read the COuncil of Elrond. It was too long.

I liked Shelobs Lair, though.

I liked all parts of the book until after the last battles was fought.

It cannot be said that any of the early chapters are exactly a thrilling ride though excitement-ville.

true...but important to introduce the ring and its effect

every chapter are just as good as the other

The only thing I can say that I didn't like was reading all of those names during the Council of Elrond. I read all of it, but it was really long!

I liked the chapter with Rivendell,Tom Bombadil(funny) and.....i guess I like hobbiton too.

I hated that chapter on that snowy mountain before Moria.

The fight for Minas Tirith

counsil of elrond was incredibly looooonnnnnggggg..........

i loved the whole book
but i hated the last chapter, not because it was bad (maybe i should say disliked it) but because it was the very last chapter and that made me really sad

I just started reading the books im on the 1st book in the prologe

I can understand why some of you would dislike the Council of Elrond chapter, and I agree it can drag on for a while. Though in that one chapter Tolkien was explaining what's going to happen and what the consequences would be if they just did nothing, and in the movies, PJ , Fran, and Phillipa had some trouble writing that scene.

My favorite chapter in the books would have to be the Minas Tirith chapter in the RotK book.

My least favorite, was more when Frodo and crew first start their journey.

I don't realy like the council, simply cause it's long, it's not boring though, so i read it every time (6 so far ) I can't choice a favorite, are you kidding? that's too hard has anyone read the Simmarillian? (i can't spell it ) i'm reading it and it's interesting, but long...anyone read Leaf and Tree?? a 25 p. essay by Tolkien? I did, interesting, but kindof boring Tolkien loves to talk

Minas Tirith Fights... and the Mines of Moria

LoTR are great books - excellents - but I agree that Silmarillion is BRILLIANT...

hey, im re-reading the lotr book, and am currently on long expected party i love the early chapters, before all the, haha if you do one thing wrong we will all die

minas trinth and plennor feilds were confusing. its like minas trinth under attack then all of sudden the riders of rohan, came then i don't remember eliphants and where the heck did ghost army come from. (this is when i read the book) Then aragon was fighting with mouth of sauor then they were crowning the king. it was like suddenly going from one part to the other. the rest was god. i wishhed the smauir guys from ttt were oin rotk, then this would have beaten spiderman.

the chapter where frodo "dies" that was realy sad i wanted to die myself

I never got the dead army that good, but that's ok the field chapter(s) isn't that hard...you must have skipped something, but Aragorn can't fight the mouth of Saroun (because he doesn't) and he's king so...yeah, I don'tknow what you're reading and what are the "smauir" guys? and ROTK pwns Spiderman Oh, smodden....i thought it was Eyown....or did you not mean her? sorry

u know when frodo gets stung by shelob and sam says "he's ....dead!!"

i just flung the book accross the room and wouldn't believe it. then i read the next couple pages and it was fine.

haha, when I got to that part I ran to my brothers and was like "is he really dead??" I almost cried, but they were like "just read the book" so i was mad but then happy, hehe