Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

WHICH ONE?

This is no contest! Dawn of the Dead is far better. Even the remake of DOTD is better than Saw.

Dawn of the Dead original and remake. Didn't think much of Saw.

Ditto.

BOTH! Both of them are in my top 10 favorite movies, so you can't expect me to choose.

I enjoyed the Dawn remake and i bought the unrated DVD.. i kinda liked Saw but i never bought the dvd. i won't until the price goes down cause i don't think its worth full price.

Saw was better than the DOTD remake, IMO.

Saw was good... but Dawn of the Dead remake FARRRRRRRRRRR better.. cant believe you would compare them

Why? In saw you could have never EVER guessed the ending. Dawn of the Dead is like Oh no Zombies Run.

I think Saw was VERY over-rated. It was more of a thriller than a horror, and had too many twists and turns to be genuinly scary.

DOTD however was bloody scary AND fun. Bit like Scream, then, except it's the end of the world...

saw was over rated, but dawn of the dead was NOT scary. it was more action than anything.
i enjoyed both though

I thought it was scary. Scariest Movie of the year actually. But then again we were in a year when Open Water was complete cr@p, The Village was done as a romance and The Grudge was a copy of The Ring...

saw sucked dawn of the dead was ok

i found both of them good, not bothered

Originally posted by Goldenskull777
WHICH ONE? I thought this was a trick question.

saw was okay but dawn of the dead is the best hands down

Both DOTD's are better then Saw.

dawn of the dead

how did that guy in saw come out of his bed in the hospitail and no one ever notice? Just wondering

well i guess with the help of the guy who everyone thought was jigsaw. dont worry it was one of those holes the movie cant explain

Saw was a cheap piece of shit. Dawn of the dead was a cheap piece of perfection

there imo is only 1 dawn of the dead and that would be romeros,i did like dotd 2004 version but it just aint in the same league as the original,the origianl is 1 of the all time classic horror movies ever,i dont think the 2004 will ever be seen like that but its still pretty fun movie,saw for a film makers first movie (is and i really dont care what every1 else thinks) is a great well made movie
u didnt say which dawn u meant if its the romero version then the question doesnt need to be asked imo,but if its the 2004 version id say saw

opinions are like arse holes every1 has 1,live with it

Difficult to say , they are 2 different types of film, DOTD was more visceral and physical, whereas SAW , which is not perfect but admirable,was slightly more cerebral and suspensefull.

I liked both, but for overall enjoyment id have to go with DOTD.

to retrostationdvd: the reason they didnt notice him was because the camera was in the wall and they were 100% focused on it

Dawn of the Dead is one of my all time favorite horror films.
I like the newer version because... well, I don't know why. I just do.

im goin with dawn of the Dead, im a zombie movie freak. even the Dawn remake was kool. the previews of Saw were all i needed to see that it was a P.O.S....and ite sequel. and the advertisements couldnt help themselves could they....ie "see Saw" get it?? Saw would have to stand on a ladder to kiss Dawn of the Deads ass.

Loved all 3 of them, but the original Dawn of the Dead is definitly the best IMO.

The original and remake of DOTD is far much better than Saw I and II.

Zombies pwned jigsaw!

Dude, zombies are pure brute force, and they just eat anything that moves, so I doubt even if Jigsaw or whatever his real name is makes the most awesomest plan to eliminate the zombies, he'll still get pummeled.

Dawn of the Dead I knew this was gonna be Here MY ALL TIME FAVORITE MOVE EVER!

I liked DOTD i thought Saw was a piece of shit.

wow........I leave for a minute and newbs start comparing classic masterpieces like Dawn of the Dead to Saw?....

really, did this question even need to be asked? There's a reason why Dawn of the Dead is so heralded among horror fans and has been for more than two decades..............

IMO, there is no comparing the two. Saw and DOTD are two complete oppostie films. As far as which is better, well I dont exactly need a Magic 8-Ball here. DOTD has stood the test of time and, like Evil Dead stated, is still heralded as the best zombie flick ever. Saw, IMO, was dreck.

Well i fink i wil choose saw, comeone way better than dawn of the dead, yeh its a classic but saw is so much better ! i mean dawn of the dead yeh i like it but saw i love, saw 2 came out on that 20th n we r rented it out today ! YAY

BoTh

I enjoyed bot Dawn of the dead's more. Killer zombie's killed more people than Jigsaw.