Stupid bad reviews

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



OB1-adobe
Surely you guys have been reading the reviews.

But have you guys noticed that the bad reviews have mainly been from people that:

1. Not interested in Star Wars and all, and never understood it.

2. Enjoyed them but have only seen the orignal trilogy a couple of times, and only saw the last 2 once or twice.

3. Overly obsessive Star Wars nerds who think there ideas were better.

4. People who think they are too mature for a film like this

5. Old fogies still trying to recapture that "old feeling" which is impossible because they have become too snobbish and cynical in their old age.

Mainly their reviews are really superficial, and whats up with this:

"Sith" is the longest "Star Wars" episode, its running time augmented with subplots involving younger versions of well-known characters like Chewbacca and Boba Fett. These cameos are of little use beyond nostalgia and demonstrate how the filmmaker's reverence for his own creations has clouded his judgment as a storyteller.

yodafan
Yep I agree.

Whisper
Pooey to these guys who gave the bad reviews. Real Star Wars fans love the prequels because they understand what Lucas is trying to achieve and the story he is trying to tell. The true Star Wars fans will be blown away by ROTS.

TheElectricFox
Yeah some people are way to overly critical of movies. Why cant someone just go see a movie like SW just for the action or fighting. Thats why my dad likes it, considering he doesnt give a rats ass about the story.

DarkYoda
Ding Ding Ding Ding eek!

We have a winner.

I completely agree. I am especially annoyed by those that are so arrogant that they think their own ideas are so much better.

Whisper
God bless George Lucas, Star Wars and all the real Star Wars fans around the world.

theshakl
also some of these people are dissing the hype...they see hype for the movie...and since they aren't part of the hype..they diss them

Texansfan05
I think Star Wars is amazing and I don't need a critic to tell me what's good and what's not.

Darth_Vader05
So the point of this thread is what!?

LandoSpeeder2
Originally posted by Darth_Vader05
So the point of this thread is what!? to talk about Stupid bad reviews

Anakin_20
I totally agree. Ur opinion is what matters. Your eyes and ears are the judge when u see the movie not the Critic's. Don't pay attention to them, enjoy the movie for its worth. Don't let them get to you.

hunchy
Originally posted by Whisper
Pooey to these guys who gave the bad reviews. Real Star Wars fans love the prequels because they understand what Lucas is trying to achieve and the story he is trying to tell. The true Star Wars fans will be blown away by ROTS.

What a load of shit. Just cuz you cant take negative reviews of a film you like, doesnt mean everyone has to like the film. I think Revenge of the Sith will be good, but that doesnt mean people aren't entitled not to like it. I mean, I think the first two were okay, but nothing great, and actually buddy...if you wanna go by who a true star wars fan is, its the OT fans....most people who rave about and love the prequels are new fans. I'm sick of hearing this.

Originally posted by Texansfan05
I think Star Wars is amazing and I don't need a critic to tell me what's good and what's not.

And as for this guy, thats cool, however a critic is supposed to write how they liked the movie...they aren't trying to say don't like it or like it. Everyone has their own opinions, which a real critic is supposed to write about.

Texansfan05
I understand the job of a critic hunchy but like I said it's my opinion about a film that matter's most to me and not somebody else's.

hunchy
Understandable. I mean its not that I trust other critics tastes always on anything. But I'll find a critic I generally agree with, and then read his reviews.

Texansfan05
I'll sometimes do the same thing I read reviews but I won't always 100% rely on them but review's from critics can be helpful if you trust the critic. I find they can also be helpful if it's a movie I'm not sure about seeing.

OB1-adobe
Oh yeah:

Another one,


6. People who are just purposfuly being an dick and write a review just to piss people off.

OB1-adobe
EDIT

hunchy
Originally posted by Texansfan05
I'll sometimes do the same thing I read reviews but I won't always 100% rely on them but review's from critics can be helpful if you trust the critic. I find they can also be helpful if it's a movie I'm not sure about seeing.

Exactly. I agree.

J.M FcThumbs-Up
Good analysis Adobe!
My thoughts exactly.....
When I read some magazines, the reviewers/critics always seem to think their jokes about the movie are sooooo funny.....
Actually IT IS funny, they're just frustrated, because when they return home they've got nothing to say...like their husband/wife is the BOSS.
They're the real homejerkers...drowning in their own missery!

Mulletman262
J.M FcThumbs-Up=Hey, don't make fun of people who drown in misery!

*Runs to room and cries*

Whisper
Originally posted by hunchy
and actually buddy...if you wanna go by who a true star wars fan is, its the OT fans....most people who rave about and love the prequels are new fans. Now THAT'S the biggest load of shit I've read so far.

Red Superfly
People are entitled to not like the movie, as long as they back up their reasons properly.

However, most of the time, the bad reviews have been by complete dumbasses.

Most bad reviews are from idiotic, pompous fools who glorify their reviews with attempted wit and sarcasm, only to look completely out of their depth when they say things like "The lightsaber fights are great but apart from that the movie sucks".

Why do critics think that Star Wars fans only want to see the lightsaber fights? Why are the lightsaber fights considerred as the number one reason to see it? Since when? I'm so sick of these ignorant assumptions made by so-called movie-gurus who have obviously not even seen the Original Trilogy, which is considerred as arguably the greatest movie series of all time.

I only consider a critic to have a legit opinion when they have a good understanding of Star Wars in general. I mean, it's only the most important set of movies ever made, you'd expect even the n00biest critic to have a good knowledge of Star Wars and it's mythos.

jedi2187
Add this one to the Stupid Reviews™.....
http://www.stltoday.com/stltoday/entertainment/reviews.nsf/movie/story/9A10AAD51622C96C86257005004324AB?OpenDocument

jon84
I found another one... teh b*****d! he gave ROTS 1/5 stars.

http://film.guardian.co.uk/News_Story/Critic_Review/Guardian_Film_of_the_week/0,4267,1482359,00.html

queeq
Hey, I'm a loyal SW fan and have been for 28 years. But I don't think too highly of TPM and AOTC, they are not great films. I hope ROTS is, we need one by now. I will always love SW, but that doesn't mean they are flawless (with the likely exception of ESB wink ), and we can be critical.

putin
the awful truth sad
read this

DOES IT LIVE UP TO THE HYPE?

No, and before any of you Star Wars geeks go for your toy Lightsabers, hear me out! I loved the story, I loved the action, I loved the pace, I loved the music, but once again the acting is the problem. I don’t know what’s worse, the banal dialogue, or the way in which the entire cast moves around like a bunch of wooden Pinocchio’s desperately looking for director George “Geppetto” Lucas to turn them into real actors. If just seems like Lucas doesn’t care much for getting the acting right; too much time was obviously spent perfecting the special “effects” and not enough concern about the “affect” of such bad acting.

You know those love lines between Padme and Anakin in "Episode II" that made you cringe; well, they’re back baby and worse than before. In one scene, Padme runs to Anakin, grabs him and says, “Hold me Annie, hold me like you did down at the lake back on Naboo!” I wanted to get up and scream, “Lucas, what the hell is this? Star Wars or Dawson’s Creek?” I actually love Dawson’s Creek, but I don’t admit to that in public. If I ever see Lucas in person, I am going to ask him to “hold me George, hold me the way you used to down by the lake on Naboo!” Do you think he will hold me? I hope so. Really, the only advice I can give you is whenever you see Anakin and Padme together on the screen, put on some earmuffs and hum “My Sharona” until one of them leaves the frame. Ma Ma My Sharona…

You know, when Anakin snaps and turns to the dark side, can you really blame him? The Jedi council was a bunch of fools anyway. I mean here you have this group of so called enlightened thinkers that taut themselves as the cops of the cosmos and they are all looking for a mysterious Sith lord…Hello, guys, he’s right next door. No, not on the other side of the galaxy, but next door! Just take the elevator down to the third floor, walk through the Jar Jar hallway, you’ll see a women’s bathroom on the left and it’s the second door on the right. Make sure you ask for Sidius, he’s tired of everyone calling him Palpatine..

Lucas wants you to see this movie and use your eyes and not your brain. There are so many inconsistencies and improbabilities taking place at once that Lucas almost seems hell bent on moving things along so we don’t get too suspicious. For example, in the opening scene, R2-D2 is shown displaying an array of impressive moves. He can zap people, create oil slicks, he even can fly by using rocket boosters attached to his feet. Very cool stuff and the crowd loved it, but Lucas, where did all of these R2 talents go when the droid meets Luke 20 years later? He’s just a trashcan on wheels in that film. It’s like Lucas sat down and said, I am going to find a way to get R2D2, C3-PO and Chewbacca into this film regardless if it makes sense or not. You did it Lucas, and it doesn’t make much sense. Is there any reason for Yoda to visit the Wookie planet other than to have Yoda and Chewie share screen time? I swear, I am shocked he didn’t have a young Han Solo appear at some point to serve coffee or something. Han, I’ll take it with cream and no sugar, thanks!

And what’s with the General Grievous? He’s a robot with asthma for something? Um, ok, sure George, whatever you say. Care to explain why a robot is having respiratory problems? Grievous, how many packs you smoking a day bud? I didn’t know if I wanted Obi-Wan to fight Grievous or offer him some Robotussin?

The reason we have put up with these mediocre films for the past six years is to see how and why Anakin turns into the legendary Darth Vader. No, it wasn’t to sell more Yellow Pages, but I won’t give away any spoilers here. But I know why Vader was so pissed later on. After Obi-Wan defeats Anakin and leaves his charred, dismembered body to die, the Emperor rescues the battered Skywalker and outfits him with the infamous Darth Vader costume. But hey, Emperor, how about cleaning off Anakin’s torso and face before making him dress up and talk like James Earl Jones? I bet Vader just wanted to take a shower before getting dressed, just like everybody else does. Can you blame him? Hey Vader, you can shower at my place, but you’ve got to be out by 8:30am so I can hop in real quick before work, thanks man. And there’s some leftover Pizza if you want it, I know you get hungry watching that Death Star being built.

Fans of this franchise will love this movie more than oxygen itself, but at the end of the day, George Lucas’ last three Star Wars films have all been somewhat of a disappointment. And as we move into the brave new world of computer-generated films, Lucas has unknowingly, and surely with no intention to, taught us all an important lesson. That great films have a soul, and that soul cannot be computer generated. Episode I, II & III all lacked that intangible soul that was ubiquitous to the original films.

Lucas once gave us intimate, cozy settings on planets and ships that seemed so real, it was almost as if we were there. Isn’t that what a fantasy movie should do? Transport us from the movie seat into the story on the screen? Lucas once had the ability to do that, that ability to make us believe and feel what it must have been like to be Luke standing there on Tatooine and looking up at the moons wandering what destiny awaits him? And we shared a cockpit with Chewy and Han and felt their anxiety as they tried to flee from Imperial Star Ships. But now, it’s all eye candy with no emotion.

Once the emotion is gone, what we see up there is nothing more than a video game with humans acting in it. Think about it, aren’t those just graphics we are seeing and not actual scenery, landscapes or sets? When’s the last time you were emotionally moved by a video game? So it’s with great relief that we can finally move on from the Star Wars universe and it’s safe to say that The Lord of The Rings is the reigning trilogy champ at the moment. Although Peter Jackson better not get too comfortable, I hear there are rumors of a Sister Act 3, wouldn’t that be sweet?

Look there’s no going back, these last three movies were terrible, but what we can do is fine someone to blame. I always find placing the blame on somebody else an essential part of living a happy, healthy life. So whom should we blame? Lucas? No that’s too easy; I say we blame Jimmy Smits? Who’s with me? What does LA Law have to do with Star Wars? Nothing! I thought Yoda settled that lawsuit with Kermit about the rights to Its Not Easy Being Green out of court. I’m going to Jimmy Smits’ house right now, come on! Jimmy Smits ruined Star Wars!!! Let’s get him!!!

By Angry Chris Kooluris

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.