DC vs Marve;l

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



armandovalles
judging on this picture, i would like to know who would win so of those fights taking place in this pic. I didnt put in the common ones like thor vs supes and cap vs batman though.

http://www.quantumzone.org/gallery/pin-ups/perez_avengers-jla.jpg

So who wins?
1) Hercules vs Big Barda
2) Vision vs Martian Manhunter
3) Falcon vs Hawkman
4) Wonder Man vs Captain Marvel (Shazam)
5) Quasar vs Firestorm

So who wins each fight?

Hulk Power
Marvel. Hands down.

stormfront13
even though you left out some good fights i think DC wins

kgkg
Originally posted by armandovalles
judging on this picture, i would like to know who would win so of those fights taking place in this pic. I didnt put in the common ones like thor vs supes and cap vs batman though.

http://www.quantumzone.org/gallery/pin-ups/perez_avengers-jla.jpg

So who wins?
1) Hercules vs Big Barda
2) Vision vs Martian Manhunter
3) Falcon vs Hawkman
4) Wonder Man vs Captain Marvel (Shazam)
5) Quasar vs Firestorm

So who wins each fight?

1) Hercules vs Big Barda --- i give it to Big Barda
2) Vision vs Martian Manhunter ---- MM
3) Falcon vs Hawkman ----------- XXXXXxXX
4) Wonder Man vs Captain Marvel (Shazam) -------- Captain Marvel
5) Quasar vs Firestorm ----------------- Quasar


DC wins

JRW
herc would kill barda........marvel wins

gautam
hey..does anyone noe all the face offs in the pic?....id say barda takes herc and so DC wins

Magee
I say DC wins.

Superman vs Thor - Superman
MM vs Vision - MM
Flash vs Quicksilver - Flash
Green Arrow vs Hawkeye - Green Arrow
GL vs Iron Man - GL
WW vs She-Hulk - WW
WM vs Captain Marvel - Captain Marvel
Batman vs Captain America - Batman

Way I see it is DC win every (major) fight.

Bialaska
Originally posted by Magee
I say DC wins.

Superman vs Thor - Superman
MM vs Vision - MM
Flash vs Quicksilver - Flash
Green Arrow vs Hawkeye - Green Arrow
GL vs Iron Man - GL
WW vs She-Hulk - WW
WM vs Captain Marvel - Captain Marvel
Batman vs Captain America - Batman

Way I see it is DC win every (major) fight.

Some of those are pretty much mismatches. In particular GL vs. Iron Man. I'd put Quasar on GL personally. And someone like Jean Grey on MM.

dawsey28
Originally posted by gautam
hey..does anyone noe all the face offs in the pic?....id say barda takes herc and so DC wins

The Wasp vs The Atom
Captain America vs Batman
Hawkeye vs Green Arrow
Scarlet Witch vs Zantana
Quicksilver vs The Flash
??? vs Ice
??? vs Plastic Man
Wonderman vs Captain Marvel
Thor vs Superman
Warbird vs Powergirl
Goliath (Atlas) vs Orion
Tigra vs Huntress
Iron-Man vs Green Lantern (Kyle Rayner)
Triathalon vs Steel
Namor (Sub-Mariner) vs Aquaman
Black Widow vs Black Canary
Black Panther vs Blue Beetle
Vision vs Martian Manhunter
She-Hulk vs Wonder Woman
Quasar vs Firestorm
Firestar vs Fire
Falcon vs Hawkman
Hercules vs Big Barda
??? vs Red Tornado


I'm sure somebody can fill in the question marks or any mistakes I made.

I say DC wins. Most of the battles are in their favor.

stormfront13
well ice if facing crystal, and i think red tornado if facing justice

dawsey28
Thanks Stormfront13.

I also forgot to put Beast vs ???

That pic was actually from Wizard Magazine's Avengers vs Justice League.

May-June Issue #105 or so.

stormfront13
i'm pretty sure beast is against vixen

dawsey28
I think you are correct on all of those and I think Machine Man is against Plastic Man.

stormfront13
yeah me too, but i couldn't think of the name

dawsey28
Originally posted by dawsey28
The Wasp vs The Atom
Captain America vs Batman
Hawkeye vs Green Arrow
Scarlet Witch vs Zantanna
Quicksilver vs The Flash
Crystal vs Ice
Machine Man vs Plastic Man
Wonderman vs Captain Marvel
Thor vs Superman
Warbird vs Powergirl
Goliath (Atlas) vs Orion
Tigra vs Huntress
Iron-Man vs Green Lantern (Kyle Rayner)
Triathalon vs Steel
Namor (Sub-Mariner) vs Aquaman
Black Widow vs Black Canary
Black Panther vs Blue Beetle
Vision vs Martian Manhunter
She-Hulk vs Wonder Woman
Quasar vs Firestorm
Firestar vs Fire
Falcon vs Hawkman
Hercules vs Big Barda
Justice vs Red Tornado




Can anyone confirm this?

armandovalles
yea, i can, it's all correct.

jrodslam
Originally posted by dawsey28
Can anyone confirm this?

Great.

Cosmic Cube
1) Hercules vs Big Barda - Unless Barda has a Mother Box, she loses.
2) Vision vs Martian Manhunter - Vision (MM will try telepathy, it won't work.)
3) Falcon vs Hawkman - Hawkman
4) Wonder Man vs Captain Marvel (Shazam) - Could go either way.
5) Quasar vs Firestorm - Quasar

all4carnage
this is how i see marvel heros vs dc heros
1) superman vs thor...........well they are both matched with strenght,speed,and stamina...(even though sup might be alittle faster) but with the addtion of thor's magic hammer thor would come out to be to much......winner...thor!!!!
2)cap vs batman......well it would be a even fight but cap woould win
3)quasar vs gL........the cosmic bands of quasar are more powerfull then gl ring...quasar wins
4)vision vs mm.......mm would come out on top
falcon vs hawkman.....im a marvel fan but folcon is the worst hero of all...hawkman wins
5)she hulk vs wonder women.....wonder women wins
6)mr. fantastic vs plasticman.... i cant take plastic man serious... mr.f all the way..
7)Qsiver vs flash.........flash
8)Hawkeye vs Green Arrow....hawkeye

all4carnage
9)Wonder-man vs Captain Marvel...open...leaning to Wonder-man
10)the atom vs iron-man......iron-man
11)firestorm vs human torch.....human torch
12)batman vs spider-man....spider-man
13)sub mariner vs aqua man.....sub mariner..
14)iron-man vs cap marvel......iron-man....
15)siversurfer vs gL.....ss

now....the sentry vs superman?????

spidermonkey
Ummmm... that is a lot of fights.

hitemup
Originally posted by Magee
I say DC wins.

Superman vs Thor - Superman
MM vs Vision - MM
Flash vs Quicksilver - Flash
Green Arrow vs Hawkeye - Green Arrow
GL vs Iron Man - GL
WW vs She-Hulk - WW
WM vs Captain Marvel - Captain Marvel
Batman vs Captain America - Batman

Way I see it is DC win every (major) fight.

i agree. DC takes it.

hitemup
Originally posted by all4carnage
this is how i see marvel heros vs dc heros
1) superman vs thor...........well they are both matched with strenght,speed,and stamina...(even though sup might be alittle faster) but with the addtion of thor's magic hammer thor would come out to be to much......winner...thor!!!!

a lil faster, supes can surpas lightspeed. he could grap thor and take him to the sun in less than 1 sec. thor will loose.

Thanos_THOTU
Wanda: No more DC!

Juntai
In those matchups?
DC.

don't shiv
Barda's suit houses the Miracle Man + Motherbox + Green Lantern Corps guardian ring + Boom Tube device.
Count on Barda to tame Wanda & her wild ways

Scoobless
Originally posted by armandovalles
judging on this picture, i would like to know who would win so of those fights taking place in this pic. I didnt put in the common ones like thor vs supes and cap vs batman though.

http://www.quantumzone.org/gallery/pin-ups/perez_avengers-jla.jpg

So who wins?
1) Hercules vs Big Barda
2) Vision vs Martian Manhunter
3) Falcon vs Hawkman
4) Wonder Man vs Captain Marvel (Shazam)
5) Quasar vs Firestorm

So who wins each fight?

Herc wins
Hawkman wins
Captain Marvel wins
Quasar wins

Vision Vs MM is the only one I'm not sure about... MM's telepathy and strength are pretty useless in this fight... as is his shapeshifting....I'll give it to Vision purely due to his stamina

Originally posted by dawsey28

??? vs Ice

??? vs Plastic Man

??? vs Red Tornado



The pic shows

Crystal (the elemental Inhuman) Vs Ice

Machine Man Vs Plastic Man

Justice Vs Red tornado

smile

hitemup
i say dc will win the greater outcome. they wont win every fight, but overall, dc wins it.

hitemup
who can forget this fight

bigbran
Originally posted by hitemup
who can forget this fight What? That Superman got his ass kicked by Vision, Wonder Man, Iron Man, SHe-Hulk, and Hercules?

Plus I seem to remember a different version around here, somewhere...

dawsey28
Where the pic go? confused

spidey-dude
marvel wins

LORDSIDIOUS01
Originally posted by armandovalles
judging on this picture, i would like to know who would win so of those fights taking place in this pic. I didnt put in the common ones like thor vs supes and cap vs batman though.

http://www.quantumzone.org/gallery/pin-ups/perez_avengers-jla.jpg

So who wins?
1) Hercules vs Big Barda
2) Vision vs Martian Manhunter
3) Falcon vs Hawkman
4) Wonder Man vs Captain Marvel (Shazam)
5) Quasar vs Firestorm

So who wins each fight?

Sidious likes Team Marvel

darkfan76
This is how I think things would go:

The Wasp vs The Atom - The atom . DC 1 - Marvel 0
Captain America vs Batman - Batman DC 2 - Marvel 0
Hawkeye vs Green Arrow - tie DC 2 - Marvel 0
Scarlet Witch vs Zantanna - tie DC 2 - Marvel 0
Quicksilver vs The Flash - The Flash DC 3 - Marvel 0
Crystal vs Ice - Crystal DC 3 - Marvel 1
Machine Man vs Plastic Man - Plastic Man DC 4 - Marvel 1
Wonderman vs Captain Marvel - tie DC 4 - Marvel 1
Thor vs Superman -tie DC 4 - Marvel 1
Warbird vs Powergirl - PG DC 5 - Marvel 1
Goliath (Atlas) vs Orion - tie DC 5 - Marvel 1
Tigra vs Huntress - Tigra DC 5 - Marvel 2
Iron-Man vs Green Lantern (Kyle Rayner) - GL DC 6 - Marvel 2
Triathalon vs Steel -tie DC 6 - Marvel 2
Namor (Sub-Mariner) vs Aquaman -Namor DC 6 - Marvel 3
Black Widow vs Black Canary -tie DC 6 - Marvel 3
Black Panther vs Blue Beetle -tie DC 6 - Marvel 3
Vision vs Martian Manhunter - MM DC 7 - Marvel 3
She-Hulk vs Wonder Woman - WW DC 8 - Marvel 3
Quasar vs Firestorm - Q DC 8 - Marvel 4
Firestar vs Fire -tie DC 8 - Marvel 4
Falcon vs Hawkman -HM DC 9 - Marvel 4
Hercules vs Big Barda -Hercules DC 9 - Marvel 5
Justice vs Red Tornado - RT DC 10 - Marvel 5


In all ties, depending of circunstances battle can go to any side. I only give a win when there is an obvious advantage, e.g;

-batman's intelligence and gadgets vs. Captain America,
-Overall power and versatily of any GL vs. Ironman
- Hawman weapons & strength over Falcon
-MM versatility vs Vision
etc...

It looks to me that the odds of DC are better than Marvel's.

Symmetric Chaos
They fight for a long time.

Then the TOAA and ThePresence effortlessly kill everybody and start talking about merchandising right and how they can buy Image.

jesserw21
wait ORION wit kill ATLAS

Ethereal
Superman vs Thor - Toss up
MM vs Vision - Vision
Flash vs Quicksilver - Flash
Green Arrow vs Hawkeye - Toss up
GL vs Iron Man - GL
WW vs She-Hulk - WW
WM vs Captain Marvel - Lean towards CM
Batman vs Captain America - Cap

dawsey28
smile

carver9
DC stomps.

Prep-Man
Originally posted by carver9
DC stomps.

You're not fooling anyone, Carver!

Eon Blue
DC

Batman-Prime
Originally posted by carver9
DC stomps.

Current Hulk could solo DC and Marvel, right? stick out tongue

JakeTheBank
Originally posted by armandovalles

1) Hercules vs Big Barda
2) Vision vs Martian Manhunter
3) Falcon vs Hawkman
4) Wonder Man vs Captain Marvel (Shazam)
5) Quasar vs Firestorm

So who wins each fight?

Hercules beats Barda.

DC wins the rest of their fights handily.

Cogito
Winners bolded. Didn't call some fights because they were too close to call, don't know the character(s) well enough, or don't care.

Also doesn't take into account some horrific stomps in DC's favor (She-Hulk vs. WW anyone?).

Overall DC stomps

The Wasp vs The Atom (Atom wins a long and drawn out shrinking battle, nearly all other fights end before this)
Captain America vs Batman (Also drawn out, all other fights end first)
Hawkeye vs Green Arrow
Scarlet Witch vs Zantanna
Quicksilver vs The Flash
Crystal vs Ice
Machine Man vs Plastic Man
Wonderman vs Captain Marvel
Thor vs Superman (Good power matchup vs. Superman, Superman is superior otherwise, IMO)
Warbird vs Powergirl
Goliath (Atlas) vs Orion
Tigra vs Huntress
Iron-Man vs Green Lantern (Kyle Rayner)
Triathalon vs Steel (Don't care)
Namor (Sub-Mariner) vs Aquaman
Black Widow vs Black Canary
Black Panther vs Blue Beetle
Vision vs Martian Manhunter
She-Hulk vs Wonder Woman
Quasar vs Firestorm
Firestar vs Fire
Falcon vs Hawkman
Hercules vs Big Barda
Justice vs Red Tornado

Glorificus
Wanda blinks everyone else out of existence.

Prep-Man
DC overall.

Batman-Prime
Originally posted by Cogito
Winners bolded. Didn't call some fights because they were too close to call, don't know the character(s) well enough, or don't care.

Also doesn't take into account some horrific stomps in DC's favor (She-Hulk vs. WW anyone?).

Overall DC stomps

The Wasp vs The Atom (Atom wins a long and drawn out shrinking battle, nearly all other fights end before this)
Captain America vs Batman (Also drawn out, all other fights end first)
Hawkeye vs Green Arrow
Scarlet Witch vs Zantanna
Quicksilver vs The Flash
Crystal vs Ice
Machine Man vs Plastic Man
Wonderman vs Captain Marvel
Thor vs Superman (Good power matchup vs. Superman, Superman is superior otherwise, IMO)
Warbird vs Powergirl
Goliath (Atlas) vs Orion
Tigra vs Huntress
Iron-Man vs Green Lantern (Kyle Rayner)
Triathalon vs Steel (Don't care)
Namor (Sub-Mariner) vs Aquaman
Black Widow vs Black Canary
Black Panther vs Blue Beetle
Vision vs Martian Manhunter
She-Hulk vs Wonder Woman
Quasar vs Firestorm
Firestar vs Fire
Falcon vs Hawkman
Hercules vs Big Barda
Justice vs Red Tornado

thumb up

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.