When does Qui Gon Jin speak in episode 2 or 3???

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Obi-wan2005
Whats all this talk about him talking...telll me what sceanes?

astrofan428
You hear him in episode 2, after the tusken slaughter.

During Yoda's meditation your hear him say "Anakin, Anakin" followed by Anakin screaming "Noooooooooooo".

Then some(me) believe you can hear a faint Vader breath.

Tulak Hord
After Shmi dies, Anakin gets his first taste of the darkside and starts killing tuskans. When the scene switches, you can hear him saying Anakin! Noo!

Obi-wan2005
How are you sure?

Obi-wan2005
man that was obi wan

astrofan428
Who you asking?

Obi-wan2005
you!

astrofan428
No it is QGJ, it is a looped clip of him yelling at Anakin as Maul rides up behind him.

If you turn on the subtitles it says QGJ says it, but it also says he said the"noooooooo", but that sounds just like Anakin.

Obi-wan2005
In episode 2......maul is notin it!

astrofan428
I know, it is a looped clip from E1 because they couldnt get Liam Neeson to do the line.

Obi-wan2005
not in*

Obi-wan2005
ohhhh....i'll watch it again thx...wat about in episode 3?

astrofan428
They simply mention him near the end.

Obi-wan2005
kool...whats all this Exar and stuff thats not in the movies?

Camo Di Mass
I heard that the "Noooooooo" is Luke's from TESB after Vader tells him he's his father but it's just a rumour ...

SixOfTwelve
Originally posted by Camo Di Mass
I heard that the "Noooooooo" is Luke's from TESB after Vader tells him he's his father but it's just a rumour ...

Nope, Luke's voice sounds completely different, much higher.
And the "Nooo" is too raspy to be Anakin's voice at that time.
It's all definitely Neeson/Qui-Gon.

Darth Maverick
might be the "nooooooooooo" Vader does after he has the suit on in episode 3?

Obi-wan2005
it says anakin anakin no-o-o

JediMasterRetro
I hopes it a deleted scene where he talks to yoda and obi wan

SixOfTwelve
Originally posted by Darth Maverick
might be the "nooooooooooo" Vader does after he has the suit on in episode 3?

After rewatching ROTS at the cinema just now - no, Vader's "nooo" is definitely not the one in AOTC. And to be fair, why should it?

Obi-wan2005
omg in aotc it is faint clearly qui gon's

Deadlyshot07
its qui gons

DeVi| D0do
it's Qui Gon.

Morgoths_Wrath
if you put on closed captioning, it clearly states "Qui Gon Jinn" yes

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.