monthly xmen comic review

Did a search and found nothing.The closet thing is comic of the month in the comic book movie forum,but this is different.
Basicly,on a monthly basis,we review all x titles based on the following😖tory,art,etc.the rating system is from 1.0 -10.0.
Hope you guys like this.
All start with the X books I read this month

x4 number 5: I guess this is the last instalment in this series.I thought it had a pretty cool ending.Rating:8.2
cool art!

xmen number 169:I thought the ending to this issue was awesome,but logan kissing rogue was just dumb!the art is good
rating:8.0

astonishing xmen 10:I love astonishing xmen!This issue was just crazy and i can't wait to read issue 11!rating:9.5

uncanny 459:Alright I guess.Personaly,I'll be happy when this savage land arch ends.I'm half and half on the art as of now.rating:5.0

academy x 14:wolverine kills northstar and this issue just tries to rush past it in my opion.Other than that,I thought issue 14 was decent.
Seeing the blob was pretty fun.
rating:7.5

I didn't read any other x titles this month 😕

Originally posted by mr.smiley
astonishing xmen 10:I love astonishing xmen!This issue was just crazy and i can't wait to read issue 11!rating:9.5

Astonishing X-Men 10: I agree with you I love this comic book, only one I'm reading at the moment, but Whedon is able to produce such a great story for readers to enjoy. This issue had me shuddering while I was reading it, and now for the return of ***** I can't wait until the next issue, can't believe its coming to an end.

Rating: 9.3

that sucks so bad.I wish they would do about 12 more issues.

Originally posted by mr.smiley
that sucks so bad.I wish they would do about 12 more issues.

isnt it just the end of this current run? wont there be a second run?

I belive so,but joss whendon won't be back.
Which,imo,it might be better if they just stop while their ahead

Originally posted by MysterioxX619Xx
This issue had me shuddering while I was reading it, and now for the return of *****

Who?!? RETURN OF WHO?!?

Spoiler tags or something buddy, I need 'em!

PM me if that'll help. BUT I MUST KNOW.

I don't read comics, perhaps I should start.

o.O Please PM me

well once you find out,let me know

Originally posted by munkiesarus
Who?!? RETURN OF WHO?!?

Spoiler tags or something buddy, I need 'em!

PM me if that'll help. BUT I MUST KNOW.

I don't read comics, perhaps I should start.

o.O Please PM me

Spoiler:
xavier i think

Was that whole thing with kitty and colussus getting spiked a simulation or real?

Originally posted by mr.smiley
Was that whole thing with kitty and colussus getting spiked a simulation or real?

real as far as i know...

It was real.

****** IS BACK! FRICKEN AWESOME!

Though can the X-Men really trust him and all that? I mean, he did abandon the school, and if it was for alternate reality future Phoenix, it'd still be closed...

look what joss whendon is going to leave us with!
how awesome.
It's realy hard for me to think of a book that has held up to the awesomeness of whendon and cassideys xmen.

my top three (in no order)

1.grant morrisons xmen
2.whendons astonishing xmen
3.claremount/phoenix saga.

Originally posted by mr.smiley
I belive so,but joss whendon won't be back.
Which,imo,it might be better if they just stop while their ahead

Erm, Joss has already stated that he's comin back for a second year. Astonishing will be on haiatus durin House of m, but will be comin back.

sweet!

Ultimate X-Men #59

Horrible art. OK story. Ultimate X-Men is not as good as it was before.

6.8

New X-Men Academy X #14

Unbearable art. And the story is not that good either.

6.5

Originally posted by DarkCrawler
Ultimate X-Men #59

Horrible art. OK story. Ultimate X-Men is not as good as it was before.

6.8

New X-Men Academy X #14

Unbearable art. And the story is not that good either.

6.5

I thought New X-Men Academy story was quite good, but then again, it almost always is. But i HATE the art Medina is a crap artist. he makes the nose way too big and the limbs are all out of proportion

That's the one where Northstar dies right? If the artist is the one who drew the cover...yikes.

I mean, when was the last time you couldn't recognize someone off of their own memorial statue?!?

ultimate is going down the tube big time...

uncanny is ok, hate the art though...

academy is alright, and the art isnt bad...

astonishing is still the best by far...

what I hate about ultimate xmen,is that they went threw too much too fast.
Are we even on issue 100 yet?
yet we already got gambit,rogue,nightcrawler,etc.
They already touched on the phoenix,which sucks