Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Who would win this epic battle...

magic vs. light sabers......magic!

they will reflect it......

Dumbledore is far a greater and stronger character then Master Yoda/Joda so Hogwarts will WIN!!!!

Hogwarts all the way!

hogwarts any day this aint a hp forum fot nuttin lol

if you wanted sw to win, you came to the wrong thread....

^ exactly.

Mages own the battlefield

Originally posted by RaventheOnly
Mages own the battlefield

sooooo...Hogwarts, or jedi Academy??

hogwarts all the way the jedi acadamey can shove there light sabers up there a## lol

Hogwarts again!

But this gives me an idea to organise something between the us (the Harry potter ) and the Star War forum.
What do you people think?

hun I thought intre forum wars were a banable offence lol

Luke Skywalker could take down Dumbledore...no hard work from Luke's side...(Luke's victory dance)...

http://www.rabittooth.com/800x600StarWarsWallpapers/LukeSkywalkerWallpaper.jpg

i dunno, to me they're not comparable, they're completely different - but seeing that im in an hp forum i'm going for haz paz, ... if i see the same poll in star wars i may reconsider ... but 4 now HP!!!

Originally posted by Darth Plagues
Luke Skywalker could take down Dumbledore...no hard work from Luke's side...(Luke's victory dance)...

http://www.rabittooth.com/800x600StarWarsWallpapers/LukeSkywalkerWallpaper.jpg

dude, what are the star wars junkies gonna do? Fling their light sabers at the wizards/witches? Magic would so kick jedi a$$. With light sabers you need to get close enough to the enemy to make contact, where as with magic you can allow yourself to stand farther away still throwing a decent attack. and there are so many diffrent spells those jedi fighting wanna-be's woudlnt have any clue what hit them.

Lightsabers can deflect laser blasts. Not spells. The most they could do is fling things around with Force powers, maybe even use force lightning for the more skilled. But Hogwart's teachers could sure as hell block it with a shield charm, or disapparate and apparate to dodge. Then the Hogwarts students shoot curses and hexes everywhere which CANNOT be deflected.


Case closed.

^ agreed

there are spells to block lol is this turning in to a forum war lol I hope not

Hogwarts will win

hmm.........LIGHTSABRE NUMCHUCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
nah lol jk i dunno if it was ALL the jedis lik including ALL the siths then they'd put up a good fight.........im not saying that hogwarts will lose, but they wont win completely.......they might wipe out all the jedis and hav a coupla wizards left but wizards wont own the battlefield.....oh and dark1365, you cant apparate or disapparate on hogwarts grounds........

dumbledore will just say accio light saber and there you have it one defenseless luke skywalker lol

Originally posted by Raven Guardia
dude, what are the star wars junkies gonna do? Fling their light sabers at the wizards/witches? Magic would so kick jedi a$$. With light sabers you need to get close enough to the enemy to make contact, where as with magic you can allow yourself to stand farther away still throwing a decent attack. and there are so many diffrent spells those jedi fighting wanna-be's woudlnt have any clue what hit them.

HAHAHA!!! havn't laughed so much in years!! well said!

lol me too lol

I mean, I don't even think this is fair Star Wars.

Avada Kedavra, anyone?

I'd rather have a light saber than some stick.

Originally posted by hotsauce6548
I mean, I don't even think this is fair Star Wars.

Avada Kedavra, anyone?
yes every jedi will die!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
that would be sad, though............

lol!

Originally posted by keiji
yes every jedi will die!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
that would be sad, though............

lol!

...

Not really...

Originally posted by Raven Guardia
sooooo...Hogwarts, or jedi Academy??

Mages = Wizards Pooker

Comeone people. Look. If all the Sith and Jedi vs Hogwarts?

Fine, Hogwarts contains Dumbeldore, and some cool proffesors.

The rest are inexperienced.
The Jedi and the Sith are all very experienced if they become one of their "kind."

Jedi and Sith tap into the force and could feel everything. THey would already sense the spell which was sent at them, they would dodge it. And go ahead, let a wizard or a witch use accio on his lightsabre. A Jedi would just use Force Pull/Push. At close distance (2 meters about) Force push would be more powerful then the Accio spell.

Bring out Master Yoda, Anakin Skywalker(Evil but before he became wounded by the lava) Darth Sidious, Darth Plague, Obi Wan, Luke Skywalker, and hogwarts wil perish.

w8......u forgot gen grievous!

and i agree who else does? o and u might be in the wrong forum if u want star wars to win.........dis is a HARRY POTTER FORUM!!!!!!!!

Originally posted by RaventheOnly
Mages = Wizards Pooker

eep! I knew you talked about them before, I just didnt make the connection that they were wizards

but you choose wisely

What are you talking about?

1) General Grievius cannot use the force. Therefore he will get wasted with a simple spell
2) I'm a fan of both, Star Wars and Harry Potter. So if you say someone doens't belong in this forum when they say Star Wars wins, then why make the topic if you think everybody in the Harry Potter forum votes for Harry Potter? Respect my opinion, since I respect your's.

I'd rather go to Jedi Academy then Hogwarts.

She has a good point.
It's cooler to weild a lightsaber then a wand.

Jedi can use their mind tricks on the students. They can block their spells with their lightsabers.

Hotsauce. The students aren't strong enough to use Avada Kedevra.

mm... well it depends on who's fighting...
but like if Harry fights Anakin, Id say that Anakin would win

C'mon people, this is the Harry Potter Forum. Of course the majority of people will say HP. Also, there seem to be a war brewing so I'm gonna close this temporary until Phoe and I have had a chance to talk. If you all can state your position maturily, we'll see if it is opened again, but I'm not sure if bashing other fandoms is allowed.

Closed for now.