Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Who wins? I think it's close, but Maul barely wins this one.

i agree with u
maul wuld win barely though

Well, here's my two cents.

Kyle Katarn after Jedi Outcast had mastered force choke, force grip and all force powers. It is my belief that he is more experienced that Maul. Kyle was a Jedi Master, Maul was a sith Lord but not a master yet. It would be extremely close but I say Kyle wins by a HAIR'S BREADTH.

thank u ,sir
i apreciate ur opinion

thanks man. This is indeed a very evenly matched thread and Maul can certainly win it. It would be a great fight.

i agree they are pretty much equal

They are very equal. But because of Maul's saber he wins.

I'm giving this to Katarn... He faced more did more, became a Jedi Master and mastered more powerful force techniques, it would be a nice fight but he would eventually kill Maul

I Kyle manage's to destroy Mauls saber(like Obi Wan did in TPM,but it still works.)He would have a big chance of winning.If he can't then i guess it would be a matter of luck for the one who wins.

Very even, but i think Maul would eventually get angry that hes not winning and through his anger feul himself with the darkside.

Good fight though, Maul wins barely.

I think my homie takes this one, after an amazing effort on Katarn's part.

I agree with Darth Dantheman. Close fight but even Kyle couldn't defeat Maul (imo). Kyle later got defeated by Jaden whom I think is weaker than Maul.

Kyle grabbed Jaden told tried to convince her to drop the Dark Side and was defeated by that. Not because he was weaker

Katarn is overpowered. He is built up to be stronger than Luke. I got to go with Maul because I don't like Kyle and Maul kicks ass.

Kyle wasn't trying to kill Jaden, he trying to convince Jaden to turn back to the light side. Besides, Jaden had to use the force sceptor to stun Kyle in order to defeat him. Throw them both into an arena again with no sceptor, Kyle would win.

Now about the battle, Kyle has the advantage in force powers because if Maul could choke or use lightning, he most certainly would have against Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan. I would say Kyle wins after one long and awesome fight.

i think Jaden wuld kill maul

Kyle would waste Maul IMO

Maul can use force choke.

read shadow hunter.

Ahem... I've read Shadow Hunter and DM can use force choke, btw. Even though Shadow Hunter shows his potential and how good he really was; I still think Kyle is more than a match for him. I have played all of the games involving Kyle, and he is just better overall. He has mastered both sides of the force, and seems to have more darkside power than Maul and has recieved training from Mr. Luke Skywalker himself. (Plus: he has defeated MANY more opponents).

Kyle. he and Luke are the top ranked jedi

This goes to Kyle. Why? How many people with lightsabers did Maul kill? Now, if you've played the games Katarn's in, then you'll know he kills thousands of them. I believe Kyle has a great advantage over Maul in lightsaber dueling just because he's has more time to ractice it in action then Maul.


Force powers. This is a hard one. I believe that Kyle has better control over the force, but in the words of Dooku: It is obvious that this contest cannot be decided by our knowledge of the Force... but by our skills with a lightsaber.

So it comes down to the lightsaber duel. And I believe Kyle is smart enough to use Maul's arrogance against him and win.

yup