Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

What happened to valinor after the last ship sailed to it?

Nothing, it had changed/moved after Middle-Earth had become a round planat like Earth today

I don't know.

I think maybe it's just an island type place that know one knonws about!
LOL
Or, maybe it's in heaven!

actually it's Avalon beyond the Sea of Mists....where magic still rules and faeries roam and have tea with goblins and gnomes

and there sits Manwe in all his glory as the elves sing and feast in his great hall....and all day they make works of crafts and poetry and the gifted ones play on their harps and wander freely the green fields strewn with multi-coloured flowers....ah! the glory

Valinor turned communist.

fight the power?

Indeed.

Ho Chi Manwe

Valinam

i am at a loss to retort

i thought i would imply Valinor was, being a communist place, like Vietnam.

Communist Valinor.....hmmm you could imagine Ilvatar being Stalin..............................lol

Thats what the ice age was, a nucler winter. The result of a middle earth Cold War.

I think what happened was, when mordor fell Rohan, Valinor, Gondor and the shire split it into quarters for each of them. But Valinor built the Mordor Wall. Internation relations went downhill. If i remember rightly there was even a period where Valinor placed weapons in Osgiliath, The Osgiliath Missile Crisis.

lol! its all coming together....maybe Tolkien was trying to warn or tell us something after all, he had fought in WW1

Originally posted by The Inkeeper
Thats what the ice age was, a nucler winter. The result of a middle earth Cold War.

I think what happened was, when mordor fell Rohan, Valinor, Gondor and the shire split it into quarters for each of them. But Valinor built the Mordor Wall. Internation relations went downhill. If i remember rightly there was even a period where Valinor placed weapons in Osgiliath, The Osgiliath Missile Crisis.

your mind simply amazes me....

Flattered

'natch.....