Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Just seems like a good fight to me. I always liked both of them, but I think that Luuke would win personaly.

Qui-Gon would win. Without him, there is No luke, no anakin, and no Obi-Wan.

Depends on which Luke we're talking bout. ANH, ESB, ROTJ, NJO, or what?

~wickerman~

It's Luuke, so Luke's clone. He was about equal to the real Luke five years after endor.

Qui Gonn owns him with his defensive style. Luuke isn't aggressive enough and that falls right into Qui's abilities of kick assery.

Qui-Gon Jinn wins this one. I say this because Luuke (The clone of Luke Skywalker) was grown very rapidly to meet Luke's age at that time. In doing so it denied the clone to fully develop his mental capabilities, leaving him mentally unstable. Though it did not play a good weakness for the true Luke Skywalker...Qui-Gon with more experience might pick up on it and exploit it.