Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Two very similar fantasy tales... if youve read both series, which do you prefer over the other?

I like Terry Brooks better, so I choose Shannara!!!

I really didn't care much for the LOTR books, Tolkien just rambled on and on. There should be a limit to how well something can be described!!

I just finished reading Tanequil, good book!! Excitedly awaiting the next one. Though I have to say I liked the story better before they introduced the flying ships and such. It was cool as just a magic story...

Yeah, I would have to say Shannara too... its really kick ass. Hey can you tell me how many books are in the series? heh

Offhand no, but I can go count from my bookshelf *runs to do that*

13

Come August it'll be 14!! (unless I'm a dunce and can't count :P...which wouldn't surprise me!)

And very happy you agree!!

Wow, amazing... it says in my book too. But are all of them related? do they all go in a same line? is the main character Shea the whole time? lol

Yes, I do like SOS better, just because of the... idk it's just better! lol

Originally posted by LeAtHerRFace
Wow, amazing... it says in my book too. But are all of them related? do they all go in a same line? is the main character Shea the whole time? lol

No its not the same main character evertime.Though each book is related to the others. The Ohmsford's *sp* are in every book.

brooks is the more refined writer. however his content feels sloppy, rushed and redundant.

Originally posted by ragesRemorse
brooks is the more refined writer. however his content feels sloppy, rushed and redundant.

It probably is a bit rushed now days. Since he probably has a deadline to make and whatnot.

....

yeah, but when the story and characters dont seem rushed, they seem to drag on and go in circles. The guy is a good writer, but it doesnt appear that he has good balance in his writings.

Each to his own I guess....I personally enjoy reading his books.

Then again I read them spaced out....

Originally posted by sai12
I like Terry Brooks better, so I choose Shannara!!!

I really didn't care much for the LOTR books, Tolkien just rambled on and on. There should be a limit to how well something can be described!!

I just finished reading Tanequil, good book!! Excitedly awaiting the next one. Though I have to say I liked the story better before they introduced the flying ships and such. It was cool as just a magic story...
I like Terry Brooks too I have to go and find Tannequil somewhere if its good

OH its good alright, just another cliffhanger ending!! I would suggest you read it!! Though make sure you read the book before it to remember what's going on. Cuz I was more than slightly confused throughout the book trying to remember characters and situations!!

Originally posted by sai12
OH its good alright, just another cliffhanger ending!! I would suggest you read it!! Though make sure you read the book before it to remember what's going on. Cuz I was more than slightly confused throughout the book trying to remember characters and situations!!
Oh I hate those cliffhanger endings!! But yeah I'll have to do that, since I haven't read those books in a while lol

Both are not a patch on something like The Chronicles of Thomas Covenant or even the original Belgariad (not all the rubbish that followed)

Originally posted by whirlysplat
Both are not a patch on something like The Chronicles of Thomas Covenant or even the original Belgariad (not all the rubbish that followed)
Hmmm haven't read any of those...

Originally posted by Coldfire
Hmmm haven't read any of those...

trust me you should