Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

In the one scene where Organa returns to the Jedi Temple, the stormtroopers tell him, it is time to go... and he just turns back and says something to the effect of "so it is".... whaaaa? Why didn't he put up a fight or something instead of just submissively give in... he didn't even question the order... I thought it would have been cool if he at least tried to stand up to them or something.... but no. That was a dissapointment. Jimmy Smits should have kicked their butts.

yeah. and then get a laser up his ass. he knows he should help the rebellion. what the hell was he gonna do? force push them outta the way? cuz, he didn't have the force. he knew his worth to the planned rebellion, so he walked.

Gee let me see 1 normal forceless person vs. oh don't know countless clones with excellent accuracy. what are the odds? gee let me count 0 to a million

nice sig kalsemo

What would he say, 'move or I'll slap you?' He showed no weapons on him.

I agree; he was completely outnumbered. I believe that he did the best that he could afterward. It's possible Obi Wan or Yoda may also have been killed had he not gotten word to them.

Well seeing as how he went on to help create the rebel alliance which played a huge role in defeating the Empire.. I'd say offhand he made the correct decision

If he died what would have happened with the Alliance?

well my guess is taht its still would have been formed... but the real question would be what would have happened to Leia?? Doesnt really matter but adds to the arguement that Bail did teh right thing by not taking on the Clones...

Yep. Bail not leaving = Bail dead. He wasn't an idiot.

I love your new sig, Bilb

Originally posted by Darth Halo
nice sig kalsemo

Thank You

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f38/t352088.html

what did you expect bail to do, bust out some kung fu?

honestly....

He had a hard enough time getting back into his ship without busting his a$$, how do you think that he would take on a bunch of clones. I also think we are to believe that he didn't understand the situation fully, until the padawan got killed as he was leaving.

In the original script.. Bail told the Clones he had a meeting with the Council and Yoda, and the clones said the council was desolved permanently.... that part was cut out.. that is why the scene feels jerky

And his 'I have a meeting scheduled with the Jedi Council.'

Originally posted by Lana


I love your new sig, Bilb


thanks Lana!! quite the compliment coming from you

Yeah I gotta admit, it was kinda wierd and outta place seeing Detective Simone from NYPD Blue actually taking shit from a bunch of punks. But seriously, he was incredibly out numbered, and on top of that HE was a politician and THEY were soilders. That would be like a U.S. senator trying to take on a bunch of MP's or National Guardsmen. See the logic???(or lack-there-of)

Originally posted by BAILY
the scene feels jerky

Thank you, that's exactly what I thought... so I wasn't the only one then who thought something was amiss there......

Originally posted by kalsemo
Thank you, that's exactly what I thought... so I wasn't the only one then who thought something was amiss there......

No you werent bud.... I expected more of Bail.. i was very disappointed in his character screentime.. i wanted more.. oh well... maybe the Deleted Scenes on the DVD?

What would he have done otherwise?

Organa: "Let me in"

Clone: "No, f*ck off"

Organa: "Why?"

Clone: "Cos we'll shoot you"

Organa: "Oh yeah, well how about I kick yo ass!"

*Clone shoots Organa*

ORGANA: Hey, what's up?
CLONE: We didn't kill any Jedi, not us!
ORGANA: ...right...so...can I come in?
CLONE: No!
ORGANA: ...how about now?
CLONE: No! Get out of here!
ORGANA: I don't feel like... *gun nozzle pressed to neck* ...um...yeah...I think I should be going, really...

BAIL: What is going on here?

CLONE: There has been a rebellion, everything is under control

BAIL: Yeah right....

(Bail pulls his blaster out shoots some clones and ducks behind his speeder)

CLONE: Freeze Senator, you are under arrest

BAIL: Under arrest my ass.....

(Bail releases two cannons out the sides of his speeder and picks off every clone)

BAIL: No one messes with the Bailster!

Parody overload!

I should have seen that coming from Baily...

Originally posted by Captain REX
I should have seen that coming from Baily...

Damn straight!

at least he didnt do it third person (cept the last line)

Bail probably was going to persist until he saw that Padawan get it.....

George Lucas gave him a blaster but would'nt have made a difference and was right decision to get in his speeder and leave.

how about...

"...the Senate won't stand for this..."

what was that on his right belt though? it looked like a blaster.

Water pistol.

Originally posted by Darth Halo
Gee let me see 1 normal forceless person vs. oh don't know countless clones with excellent accuracy. what are the odds? gee let me count 0 to a million

you know the clones aiming was a lot worse in the OT for some reason.

The were no Clones left by the time of the OT. They all died due to their accelerated growth. Stormtroopers were enlisted men.

no they weren't

Some were clones some were enlisted men