Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

who wins?

What is EP2?

Maul wasn't even in Episode 2.

Luke automatically wins, becuase Darth Maul, at the time of Episode 2, has been dead and decaying for ten years...

If you mean that it's Maul ten years older than in Ep.1, then Luke's up for a fight, maybe Maul gets a bit wiser and less cocky, but then remember Ep.1 Maul had a bunch of special effects and the role of trying to reprise a bad film with a bit of flashy marketing to young kids, thus the double bladed saber and tattoos.
Luke could beat him though, he could probably force choke Maul anyways!

Maul would own ROTJ Luke, whether in TPM times or AOTC times if he lived somehow. ROTJ Luke is still poorly trained at the time, and certainly not ready to take on a full on Sith. Vader didn't fight him to kill him, he was just messing around because it was his son.

Maul took on Qui Gon who was considered super powerful Jedi, and obi wan at the same time. Ya maul died in the end due to a major fuk up, but still, he manhandled two jedi's at once easily, and one of the jedi's was very strong.

Maul is underestimated, simply because that last 10 seconds of his life made him look like an idiot. Overall though, he owned the jedi's he fought.

hard to believe some people in this world thinks that he can relive

what is EP2?

EPISODE 2 ATTACK OF THE GODDAMN CLONES!

some ppl.......

Maul isn't in episode 2 so Luke already won. Maul was dead.

zombie maul vs. luke. i still say luke has this

Originally posted by Admiral Akbar
EPISODE 2 ATTACK OF THE GODDAMN CLONES!

some ppl.......

Luke will grab a gun and shoot off his head.

This is sooooo strange...

yeah this is pretty weird

a better battle would have been TPM Leia vs AOTC Maul vs ESB Dooku

that would be a doozie

Or ROTJ Revan vs TPM Luke.

Originally posted by General Zodiac
Or ROTJ Revan vs TPM Luke.



LMAO!

Luke wins, after finding Maul's rotting carcass at the bottom of some random generator shaft.

Luke finds Maul's body and kicks it.
Luke: I win!

Originally posted by Vanquish
Maul would own ROTJ Luke, whether in TPM times or AOTC times if he lived somehow. ROTJ Luke is still poorly trained at the time, and certainly not ready to take on a full on Sith. Vader didn't fight him to kill him, he was just messing around because it was his son.

Maul took on Qui Gon who was considered super powerful Jedi, and obi wan at the same time. Ya maul died in the end due to a major fuk up, but still, he manhandled two jedi's at once easily, and one of the jedi's was very strong.

Maul is underestimated, simply because that last 10 seconds of his life made him look like an idiot. Overall though, he owned the jedi's he fought.

Don't you understand, if RotJ was done in the late 90's, RotJ Luke would be flipping around and stuff, and I don't think you can accurately pitch a PT character against an OT character because of this!

If they had done the OT in the nineties, Vader would be flipping about and they would have probably shown him being as powerful as Qui-Gon and Obi together. Or vice versa; if they'd done the PT in the seventies, the TPM duel what be fought at a slow pace!

Alright, you noobs are banned from making assinine posts. Like, all of you. If I had access to my well of pics right now, oooo... you would all be in trouble.

But because I'm at work and killing time online, I can only fume and pout. Damn.

Seriously, I was hoping to see some idiot argue for Luke against Maul.

You should look around more this is far from the worst thing you will see.

Revan vs Desann still takes the top spot for me.

Desann? Is that Super Shadow nonsense or a water purifying company?

Its the guy from Jedi Knight, worthless enemy that defeated his master maybe even when he was sleeping or just stabbed him in the back some day we don't know so he is suddenly all powerful.

Oh, him? Is he the same guy who killed the Mandalorians and 103 dark Jedi and became Qui Gon Jinn? Yeah, I know him.

Yeah the same guy he is also the guy that owned Maul in Episode one even though he was clearly weaker, oh and he also easily defeated Vader when he was barely a knight. Not to mention that he is the son of the chosen one and the chosen one so he is all powerful.

And don't forget he can manipulate midi-chlorians, kill Jedi masters with obvious, slow moves, and can dance the chicken dance on request. Yeah, that guy.

That guy selling deathsticks is far stronger then anyone from ATOC.