Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Who would in a duel between Bastila and Phantom Menace Obi-Wan?

I myself am undecided.

Obi-Wan all the way. He had practice with Darth Maul so Bastila wouldn't do better in terms of dueling.

what practice was that? he was owned. even when he had all that determination.

Maul pushed him in a hole. Ohhhhhhhhh. That's owning alright.

A very deep hole...

Bastila before she is turned or after?

To be honest, I think it might not matter, actually, because Bastilla was respectably skilled and Obi-Wan was still really a padawan. He did defeat droids and put up a good fight against Darth Maul, but Bastila was seasoned enough to beat off Obi-Wan Kenobi (even though I think Darth Maul is better than Bastila and Obi-Wan killed Darth Maul, admittedly not in fair combat). I like the fight, though.

bastilla was a padawan as well though dipsit

and before anyone says it, because i know people will. bastilla can not use her battle meditation without being killed. she has to actually sit down and meditate, giving any person shes fighting a free shot

IMO she still takes it though. she was trusted enough by the jeedai council to lead a strike team against revan, who im sure the jeedai were underestimating, but still, they sent her in against a sith lord, that has to say something about her.

As to Bastila being a padawan, yes, I know - but thank you, Vader, for the well-put correction. I have to learn to make sure to cover all bases and write everything I think. And I agree that that point of view is completely valid. Good job filling in the gaps!

Bastila has this. She is one of the best padawon Jedi ever.

I agree with Human Vader as usual. Bastila was sent to stop Lord Revan, she escaped from that cage even with a neural disruptor, she had a Force chain with Revan, went everywhere he did, fighting with him, and even held off Darth Malak for a short time.

Originally posted by Darth L. Dipsit
Bastila before she is turned or after?

To be honest, I think it might not matter, actually, because Bastilla was respectably skilled and Obi-Wan was still really a padawan. He did defeat droids and put up a good fight against Darth Maul, but Bastila was seasoned enough to beat off Obi-Wan Kenobi (even though I think Darth Maul is better than Bastila and Obi-Wan killed Darth Maul, admittedly not in fair combat). I like the fight, though.

You mean Obi-Wan didn't do fair combat against Darth Maul? What wasn't fair? When Obi killed Maul because he's a dumb@$$?