Mary Jane must be played by another actress

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



K3VIL
Now guys, we all know who is Mare Jane.
Redheaded hot girl, big breasts, round back, small hips, she's hot.
Kirsten Dunst looks like a zombie, too light skin, she has no ****, and no ass.

Spiderman_RJ
indeed mary jane is the girl u look and are imeaditly attracted to, and if u look her body u have erection better than viagra, dunst sucks, she none of it ,but since this is the last movie, i dont bother, unless they kill her and bring gwen to be with parker, gwen is the real love of parker,everyone knows that.

Doc Ock
Dunst is simply awful as MJ.Get rid of her post haste!!!

Nevermind
Originally posted by K3VIL
Now guys, we all know who is Mare Jane.
Redheaded hot girl, big breasts, round back, small hips, she's hot.
Kirsten Dunst looks like a zombie, too light skin, she has no ****, and no ass.

Stop looking for something to masturbate over and watch the movie. Dunst is a good actor.

Blair Wind
Nevermind: like your sig....cuz its Jessica Alba, lol.

and just to say I dont think shes that great as MJ cuz shes not even approaching pretty (and shes supposed to be a model) and i dunno i dont think she can act either.....

Doc Ock
Originally posted by Nevermind
Dunst is a good actor.

http://radio.cbc.ca/programs/2newhours/images/flying_p.gif

hotsauce6548
I don't really care who plays Mary Jane.

Darth Nauj
yeah I dont like KD, shes a very terrible actor. didnt she say she was only going to do three sm movies? so I guess this is her last one then.

Nevermind
Originally posted by Blair Wind
Nevermind: like your sig....cuz its Jessica Alba, lol.

Alba is a good actor though.

And all you guys have bitched that she (KD) isn't a good actor but haven't given a said why. Is it just a hate thing?

symbiote ruler
ye im wid nevermind until u giv a gud reason hu do reckon shud play MJ then

*Georgina_A*
I actually like Kirsten Dunst as MJ erm She's a good actress, as she's prooved in many of her other films as well as the Spiderman films, and I think she's gorgeous.

JacopeX
Well its to late now! if they get another Mary Jane in the next movie, that will suck. In May 2007 when Spiderman 3 comes out, They better not make change screw ups in the movie.

doctorstrongbad
i hope they bring in Nikki Cox as the new MJ. Now she is way better looking and is younger then Dunst.

symbiote ruler
u got any recent pics?

doctorstrongbad
Nope but there are reports that she might be in Spider-man part 3.

Spiderman_RJ

Doc Ock
Ooooh she looks good.

Much hotter than Dunst.Though that's not hard wink

Spiderman_RJ
and she has the look of fun girl, and aired head, almost the image of early mj on comics

Jimmy Buggs
movie MJ is the girl next door that peter has a crush on since he was a little kid. Dunst is more a girl next door type , instead of being the super sexy comic mj.

Herr Logan

Sentry
A better look at Isla Fisher:

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v345/sifu1/isla008.jpg

droolio

Spiderman_RJ
WOW

doctorstrongbad
Okay she wins the part. No audition, she wins. wink

Mainstream
indeed either her or nikki cox

Spiderman_RJ
i saw nikki cox pics, she is hot but doesnt look like mj. :P

Mainstream
Originally posted by Spiderman_RJ
i saw nikki cox pics, she is hot but doesnt look like mj. :P


I suppose not....maybe she could be black cat or gwen....hopefully Black cat

NoFate007
Well you don't need to cast a redhead for the part, you get anybody, and make them dye their hair...idk why fans tend to think that if you cast a brunette in a blonde role, they'll never dye their hair.

Spiderman_RJ
whos talkin about colors? look at her, i posted that becouse he had died red for a movie.......

doctorstrongbad
I'm happy as long as she is hot and can act, they can always dye her hair or whatever. smile

DarkCrawler
Kirsten Dunst is annoying and whiny. Something that comic book MJ is not.

doctorstrongbad
Yeah they haven't done a good lob with MJ so far in the movies. I'm hoping when they get a new actress things will be better. Thats a cool namor sig you have. smile

BOHICA
I think she just needs longer hair, and better makeup and costume and she's got it nailed... i honestly dont think anyone could have nailed the "go get em tiger" line better than her....


OH and i read in a thread that was closed saying MJ should die... are you NUTS! HAVE you READ the comics..... just wondering

Cascador
well peter parker isn't as she should be in the movies either...thats because peter and mary jane still have that teenage look...Peter looks more adult in the comics now, so does mary jane...I agree that kirsten dunst isn't a good choice...but changing now would be a bad idea too

Marcus4600
Originally posted by K3VIL
Now guys, we all know who is Mare Jane.
Redheaded hot girl, big breasts, round back, small hips, she's hot.
Kirsten Dunst looks like a zombie, too light skin, she has no ****, and no ass.

She looked fine in the first movie. Also, whining no a forum is just gonna do sooooo much.

adscrawler
kd is fine leave her alone, alsa fisher is to austrailan to play her

atharpina
People tell me I look like Kirsten Dunst.

Are I to be offended?

DarkCrawler
Originally posted by doctorstrongbad
Thats a cool namor sig you have. smile

Thanks. smile

Cascador
Originally posted by atharpina
People tell me I look like Kirsten Dunst.

Are I to be offended?

No she's very beautiful...she just looks too young imo to play mary jane...I think many fans would have liked to see a period when he becomes spider-man and his life after he graduated...but Kirsten Dunst has a look that gives you the impression she'll always look teenage in the movies. She's pretty girlish in the movies. So you'll never really see Mary Jane as as a grown-up.

Knightfall93
*sighs*
"Would YOU turn her out of bed?"

Doc Ock
Redhead to heaven in 2007

Knightfall93
Eh?

Cascador
Doc Ock means that she will be dead in the next film or at least that he wants her dead lol

Knightfall93
LOL, I like KD, give her some slack, will ya? Or even cut it...

Silverstein
kirsten dunst is fugly and a terrible actress

SpyCspider
i thot she was OK the first time we meet her as a high schooler....but then as the story progressed, i became less thrilled by her appearance...

By the time the 2nd one rolled around, I was thinking "no way in hell can she be the hot supermodel/actress" that she's made out to be in the comics

Mr Parker
Originally posted by Silverstein
kirsten dunst is fugly and a terrible actress

yeah she was okay looking in the first film but god she was such an ugly dog in the second one,kirsten dunst was the worst thing about the second film. mad Her horrible acting of not portraying the character properly though and acting much more like gwen stacy instead of mary jane in the films cant be all blamed on her though.Raimi is the one to take most the blame for that.as you are aware,Raimi has been clueless about the spiderman movies.

Mr Parker
Originally posted by Adam Warlock
A better look at Isla Fisher:

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v345/sifu1/isla008.jpg

droolio

damn she would have been a perfect MJ.

Cascador
I dont think a girl like her would hook up with a guy like tobey mguire lol

Mr Parker
LOL.your probably right. laughing out loud

Silverstein
laughing

atharpina
You guys are mean.


That girl would make a good MJ though!

SpyCspider
hahah yea sorry Atharpina, we are mean...but it's a just criticism.

it's funny..cuz you hear a lotta guys (nonfans as well) talk about hot girls as love interests for superhero/comic movies all the time (Natalie Portman-Padme, Michelle Pfeiffer-Catwoman, Kim Basinger-Vicki Vale, etc) but i've NEVER once heard a guy say "man, Kirsten Dunst was so hot as Spider-man's girlfriend Mary Jane...

Black Cat called her "Mary Plain" in one of the comics. Fits well with Dunst's portrayal.

Mr Parker
Originally posted by SpyCspider
hahah yea sorry Atharpina, we are mean...but it's a just criticism.

it's funny..cuz you hear a lotta guys (nonfans as well) talk about hot girls as love interests for superhero/comic movies all the time (Natalie Portman-Padme, Michelle Pfeiffer-Catwoman, Kim Basinger-Vicki Vale, etc) but i've NEVER once heard a guy say "man, Kirsten Dunst was so hot as Spider-man's girlfriend Mary Jane...

Black Cat called her "Mary Plain" in one of the comics. Fits well with Dunst's portrayal.

thats a good point.You know all too well SpyCspider that I hate the Burton Batman movies as strongly as much as I do these movies but the only thing that made the Burton Batman movies worth sitting through were the scenes with Kim Basinger and Michelle Phieffer in them and like you said,there have been tons of people over the years say Basinger was hot or Phieffer was hot in the batman movies but like you,I have never heard anybody over the years on message boards ay they thought Dunst was Hot in the man-spider movies.

CaptainStoic
I wrote in another thread that Tobey looks great as Spiderman, and that I couldn't come up with anyone better, I also said that MJ was my main concern, the MJ of the 80's was designed to look like Cindy Crawford, picture here:
http://www.voodoo.cz/cc/swim/CCS008.JPG
But what about Scarlet Johanson? she's about the right age.

redcaped
I can't wait for CGI to master humans so we could have infinite sequels with no changes...like this one.

CaptainStoic
CGI will also put a lot of people out of the business... but you will get your wish one day.

redcaped
No, these people will still get paid but much less...no need to act just take a few scans naked so the measures are precise.

katie_girl09
I don't like Kirsten Dunst as MJ. Not only because she doesn't look the part, but for her acting as well. If I'm not mistaken, MJ has a bit of an attitude, right? She's sassy. But Dunst is so drippy sweet that its almost too much. She's a horrible actress IMO. They could have found a better MJ by holding auditions for unknown actresses. And that's my two cents.

katie_girl09
And you know what I think would have been cool? If they had made us wait to see MJ. Like maybe if she hadn't been introduced until the 2nd or 3rd movie.

Mr Parker
Originally posted by katie_girl09
I don't like Kirsten Dunst as MJ. Not only because she doesn't look the part, but for her acting as well. If I'm not mistaken, MJ has a bit of an attitude, right? She's sassy. But Dunst is so drippy sweet that its almost too much. She's a horrible actress IMO. They could have found a better MJ by holding auditions for unknown actresses. And that's my two cents.

Yes you are right Katie girl,Mj from the comics has an attitude and is sassy and we saw none of that from Dunst.But we cant blame ALL of that on Dunst.Raimi is the director and he should have done his homework enough to have been aware of that.They say that Raimi is a fan of the comic,but the movies are so disloyal to the comic,I dont believe that at all,that he ever read the comic.because if he did,he would know that Dunst acted far more like gwen stacy from the comic and nothing like mary jane.

katie_girl09
Originally posted by Mr Parker
Yes you are right Katie girl,Mj from the comics has an attitude and is sassy and we saw none of that from Dunst.But we cant blame ALL of that on Dunst.Raimi is the director and he should have done his homework enough to have been aware of that.They say that Raimi is a fan of the comic,but the movies are so disloyal to the comic,I dont believe that at all,that he ever read the comic.because if he did,he would know that Dunst acted far more like gwen stacy from the comic and nothing like mary jane.
Yeah, you're right. It isn't completely her fault. What is it with production companies hiring a director to do a comic book movie when the director doesn't seem to know anything about the comics (ahem- X-men)?

Still, I don't like Kirsten. I'm actually still trying to figure out who she slept with to get that part. Jeez! They probably could have found a better MJ just walking down the street!

Okay, rant over! laughing out loud

chucktaylor
Hahahahahaha!!!

Mr Parker
Originally posted by katie_girl09
Yeah, you're right. It isn't completely her fault. What is it with production companies hiring a director to do a comic book movie when the director doesn't seem to know anything about the comics (ahem- X-men)?

Still, I don't like Kirsten. I'm actually still trying to figure out who she slept with to get that part. Jeez! They probably could have found a better MJ just walking down the street!

Okay, rant over! laughing out loud


Yeah I know,it makes no sense. mad you said-ahem-xmen,also dont forget ahem-Batman as well. mad I dont think X-men is too bad. As a comicbook adaptation it sucks because of the costume changes.I mean if your not going to stay loyal to the source material and change the costumes so radically,call the movie something else for crying out loud. mad I can tolerate the x-men though because unlike spider-man or the burton/schumacher batman films,as a movie on its own merits its not bad because it at least had what they didnt have,a good story which is the most important thing for a movie. The thing Im wondering about now is now that they have ruined Mary Janes character making her into a Gwen stacy clone practically,since Gwen is going to be in the next film,what are they going to do next with her? Make her into a mary jane clone andhave her behave like mary jane? roll eyes (sarcastic) Yeah I agree,Dunst must have slept with the producers of this film or something for them to have cast her. sick

Knightfall93
Then who did RAIMI sleep with?

Mr Parker
Musy have been James Franco since he was really the only other actor in the movies that wasnt very good. laughing

CaptainStoic
Does this look like Kirstin Dunst? Don't get me wrong, I can't wait to see Spiderman 3. I think that Kirstin is a good actress, I can't knock her on this, but they really need to get someone that looks the part, as far as The X-Men movies... Halle Berry completely ruined it for me, she's really hot, but she's not Storm... Naomi Campbell is the look that they should have gone with, Storm is African.

Jean Grey would be perfect if they chose to go with the older look, but they ended up mixing that up in a huge way. Look at Cyclops he looks like he just got out of high school! Magneto??? for crying out loud! They could have easily used the guy who played the Punisher, all they had to do was dye his hair white. X-Men was a bust for me. Batman was worse by far. The key here is the directors, why hasn't anyone ever chose Ridley Scott to make a Batman movie... he directed Blade Runner.

Mr Parker
Well they FINALLY got a good Batman director in Nolan with Batman Begins so they dont need Ridley Scott for Batman.However Scott would be a great director for Spider-Man though.With Scott directing,there would have been a good spider-man movie made by now.

samishe
I like the guy who playes Magneto, and Storm is great. confused

Red Superfly
Dunst ain't a bad actress, but she is completely wrong for MJ.

CaptainStoic
Erica Durance would have been the perfect Mary Jane. Here's her picture.

CaptainStoic
Now compare

katie_girl09
Originally posted by Mr Parker
Yeah I know,it makes no sense. mad you said-ahem-xmen,also dont forget ahem-Batman as well. mad I dont think X-men is too bad. As a comicbook adaptation it sucks because of the costume changes.I mean if your not going to stay loyal to the source material and change the costumes so radically,call the movie something else for crying out loud. mad I can tolerate the x-men though because unlike spider-man or the burton/schumacher batman films,as a movie on its own merits its not bad because it at least had what they didnt have,a good story which is the most important thing for a movie. The thing Im wondering about now is now that they have ruined Mary Janes character making her into a Gwen stacy clone practically,since Gwen is going to be in the next film,what are they going to do next with her? Make her into a mary jane clone andhave her behave like mary jane? roll eyes (sarcastic) Yeah I agree,Dunst must have slept with the producers of this film or something for them to have cast her. sick
Oh yes. But I actually liked the first two Batman movies. The 3rd one with Jim Carrey sucked though. And Batman and Robin... let's not talk about that one...
And yeah, they may as well make Gwen like how MJ is supposed to be. At least we'll have an interesting female character.

katie_girl09
Originally posted by CaptainStoic
Halle Berry completely ruined it for me, she's really hot, but she's not Storm... Naomi Campbell is the look that they should have gone with, Storm is African.
Thank you! I could never understand that. Of all the black women in Hollywood, why Halle?

katie_girl09
Originally posted by CaptainStoic
Now compare
She would have been a good choice. Where is she from anyway?

roughrider
Who cares, she's been cast, she's done two movies, she's doing the third, the movies are blockbuster smash hits, no one is going to make changes for changes sake - Get The F*ck Over It.

I know Singer took some flak for casting Anna Paquin as Rogue, becuase she was so young. But anyone can see her growing into a woman before us as the movies are made, and into the character too.

Not all costumes from the comics can be put on the screen, and made to look plausible. They made have played the X-Men outfits a bit safe, but Wolverine's yellow bumblebee outfit would look laughable in real life.
How come no one is yelling that Batman needs to be not all black, but black & grey like the comics, if we are so anal for detail?

Kirsten Dunst is growing into Mary Jane with every film. Remember she was a teenager to start with, right along with Peter.

CaptainStoic
Originally posted by katie_girl09
Thank you! I could never understand that. Of all the black women in Hollywood, why Halle?

She's from Canada, I forget which province exactly.

roughrider
Originally posted by CaptainStoic
She's from Canada, I forget which province exactly.

Halle Berry was born in Cleveland, Ohio.
Someone else could do Storm better, perhaps, but she's what we got. Let's see how her expanded role works in X3.

Britrogue
Personally, I think that Kirsten Dunst looked the part in Spidey 1, but what the hell was with the hair in the ssecond film? It was ginger! Not red!

Mr Parker
yeah she is now not only acting and behaving like Gwen Stacy but NOW she even LOOKS like gwen stacy.Her hair was more blond than red in that movie. roll eyes (sarcastic)

katie_girl09
Originally posted by roughrider
Who cares, she's been cast, she's done two movies, she's doing the third, the movies are blockbuster smash hits, no one is going to make changes for changes sake - Get The F*ck Over It.

I know Singer took some flak for casting Anna Paquin as Rogue, becuase she was so young. But anyone can see her growing into a woman before us as the movies are made, and into the character too.

Kirsten Dunst is growing into Mary Jane with every film. Remember she was a teenager to start with, right along with Peter.
Ummm... Well yeah, obviously she's been cast and there is nothing that we can do about that- but opinions help make the world go around, right? And I disagree, she isn't growing into MJ because she just isn't right for the part... period.
And yes, I understand Singer's possible motives, but c'mon! Anna Paquin? Of all the actresses out there? Anna Paquin?!?

CaptainStoic
Originally posted by roughrider
Halle Berry was born in Cleveland, Ohio.
Someone else could do Storm better, perhaps, but she's what we got. Let's see how her expanded role works in X3.


Sorry I was talking about erica Durance not Halle, I miss quoted Katie-Girl. She asked where was Erica from.

groove
Hmmm i agree
kisten dunst is butterz

Sparkz
I think kirsten dunst could play MJ...if Raimi did the script right, I mean for saying he has like 1000 comics he dosn't show it. MJ was more like Gwen and even Gwen was fun loving and kind of party girly, not as much as MJ, but Dunsts MJ is like a goody tooshoes version of gwen stacy...lol raimi said he didnt want to include gwen cause he didnt want to do her character...then he had GG throw MJ off the bridge, and now Gwen is appearing 2 films later, god he's back to front

systemshock2
I like Kirsten Dunst in the part. The part that won me over was in the first movie, when Peter and her have a small discussion in their backyards after he's taken out the garbage, and after she's run out of her house because of her parents fighting. It was just the small talk that came about between the two of them, from her dreams after high school, to her commenting on Peter's height, that just made her work for me. Plus she's great to look at, especially in that Red Chinese dress from the first movie.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.