Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Couldn't find this.

What do you think?

Green Lantern Wins with out doubt - simply because of his ring. His ring has no electrons, no metal, and no gravity. Green Lantern forms his ring into a big ass plasma super electron decinergration ray. AND BBOOOMMMM Magneto face down ass up - 50 cent

That. Is. True.

GL's ring could quite easily put up a forcefield to resist Mag's powers.

Originally posted by ZephroCarnelian
That. Is. True.

GL's ring could quite easily put up a forcefield to resist Mag's powers.
false , Polaris did well against Hal

I made a thread a while back that had Mags vs Gl vs Invisible Woman.....and the conclusion (though I fought on the side of Gl and or IW....was that Mags won...) so ima go with that and say Mags wins.....

kyle forms a hammer inside mags shield but behind his head and knocks him out cold. or impales him on something.

Originally posted by kgkg
false , Polaris did well against Hal

Okay, but did he win?

Originally posted by Tron
Okay, but did he win?
he managed to jack his ring .

Hal got him back later tho

Lets see, a character who controls the em spectrum vs a guy who can do
anything he wants with willpower..

I think GL has this.

Anything you say?

I think it could go either way, since all of the Green lanterns have very bad imaginations. (The crap I could do with that thing...*sigh*) But GL has an edge.

Originally posted by Zenoside
I think it could go either way, since all of the Green lanterns have very bad imaginations. (The crap I could do with that thing...*sigh*) But GL has an edge.

Someone's forgotten about John Steward and Kyle Raynor.

It's not that they have bad imaginations, every GL uses their rings differently, whatever fits their personality. It was explained pretty well in Green Lantern: Rebirth #6.

It all comes down to whether magnetos powers to manipulate all forms of energy (em spectrum) will affect the green lanterns ring.

Magneto wins though, in my own.

And it's also a matter of whether the power in Kyle's ring can keep Magneto's power from having any effect on it or not.

hmm.. i see some false assumptions here.

Polaris took control of Kyle and the rest of the JLA in the artic.

Kyles armor costume was magnetic.

also was able to hold kyle in place and keep him from using his powers while he wandered about his end goal..

Kyle..he's more powerful..

magneto can give Kyle an aneurysm ala the pheonix.

Magneto 7/10...both are powerful but I give the edge to magneto and by the way I can't remember anything penetrating mags forcefield... same can be said for kyle.

Kyle for the solid

If we go by average Magneto, then Kyle. If we go by current uber Mags, then he can take it.

Originally posted by -Pr-
If we go by average Magneto, then Kyle. If we go by current uber Mags, then he can take it. average magneto is very very powerful

Originally posted by Starscream M
average magneto is very very powerful

And?

Originally posted by iceman24567
Kyle for the solid

Originally posted by -Pr-
And? he's arguably more powerful than average kyle

Kyle, easily.

Mags beats any other GL, especially Hal (PR) and Guy (ODG)

Originally posted by Starscream M
he's arguably more powerful than average kyle

And?

Originally posted by Mindset
Kyle, easily.

Mags beats any other GL, especially Hal (PR) and Guy (ODG)

lol.

Originally posted by -Pr-
And?
so I think you're wrong when you said average mags would lose to kyle.

Originally posted by Starscream M
so I think you're wrong when you said average mags would lose to kyle.

and you're free to think so.

I think Kyle would win, and by virtue of that, i think you're wrong.

Originally posted by -Pr-
and you're free to think so.

I think Kyle would win, and by virtue of that, i think you're wrong. couldn't mags pop a blood vessel in kyle's brain with a mere thought?

Originally posted by Starscream M
couldn't mags pop a blood vessel in kyle's brain with a mere thought?

No I don't think that would work.

I'm not a big DC guy but I remember during the "Crisis in Time" arc some doofy looking DC villain shot a Chronal Wave or something at Alan Scott and some other JSA guys. They all dropped dead from the extremely rapid aging, but Alan's ring completely protected him, he was unfazed.

If that ring's aura can stop that, Magneto isn't doing jack to Kyle or any other Lantern while they have that aura up.

Is the ring metal or plastic?

Originally posted by BattleMage
Is the ring metal or plastic?
Neither.

Originally posted by Mindset
Kyle, easily.

Mags beats any other GL, especially Hal (PR) and Guy (ODG) http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Even%20More%20Random/Phail07.jpg

Originally posted by Starscream M
couldn't mags pop a blood vessel in kyle's brain with a mere thought?

assuming he was able to do that while taking an onslaught from kyle and able to manipulate him through kyle's shield, maybe.

Originally posted by BattleMage
Is the ring metal or plastic? whatever material it is, it appears to be magnetic whit how polaris was able to manipulate it along with GL's suit construct

Originally posted by King Castle
whatever material it is, it appears to be magnetic whit how polaris was able to manipulate it along with GL's suit construct

When was this?

Polaris is a horrible example to use for most of the JLA imo. It's inconsistent and ignores several established power levels/abilities.

when Polaris went to the north pole or antartic to gather magnetic energy for whatever was up to. probably something stupid like move the planet so it crumbles apart.

Polaris for a smart guy is pretty stupid and doesnt think, things through.

only one he wasnt able to effect was plastic man who distracted him enough to rescue his team that were in a magnetic hold.

iirc polaris had GL smacking himself.. polaris was all like: why you hitting yourself, why you hitting yourself?

I was actually looking for an arc name or issue #s so I could download it....

Originally posted by -Pr-
Polaris is a horrible example to use for most of the JLA imo. It's inconsistent and ignores several established power levels/abilities. what.......ever.......

unless you can find a similar moment of Kyle being resistant and consistently .. it still counts just b/c u dont like it doesnt make it pis.

Kyle> Magneto.

Kyle is more powerful and should win.

Erik Lensherr all the way!

^Really? I would have never guessed you would have thought that....

Originally posted by King Castle
what.......ever.......

unless you can find a similar moment of Kyle being resistant and consistently .. it still counts just b/c u dont like it doesnt make it pis.

i don't like it because polaris hurts them; i hate it because it's retarded.

gl's can set their shields to block psionic signals, and it's been done enough on panel to make it a pretty reasonable tactic.

that, and we don't know what current gl rings are made of.

magneto removes the ring and crushes it. oh wait no magneto cant do that cause its kyle. but if it was a no name GL then he could remove it right ?

if u mean a no name GL who just got the ring for about an hour and doesn't really know how to use it..then yes..

Speaking of Polaris he has few good showing against Greed lantern and even the JLA using his powers but there are other times where he got owned by Kyle.

Originally posted by kgkg
Speaking of Polaris he has few good showing against Greed lantern and even the JLA using his powers but there are other times where he got owned by Kyle. Polaris is no magneto

Kyle ftmtw.

I bet even fatnude will get off Magneto's manmeat long enough to agree with me. 313

Oh, he'll be getting off, but not on the way you want.

Originally posted by carver9
Magneto 7/10...both are powerful but I give the edge to magneto and by the way I can't remember anything penetrating mags forcefield... same can be said for kyle.


thor's hammer makes quick work of mag's shields. at least it has in the past.

Iirc it was absorbing it, it didn't just smash through.

Mags makes Kyle punch himself, distracts him with a hologram of Wondy kissing him and steals the ring, then uses the ring better than Kyle ever did.

Originally posted by chomperx9
Polaris is no magneto

At his most powerful, Polaris certainly is.

Kyle

In this thread yet another example of Carver lowballing a DC herald.

Kyle is too much for Magneto, he'd still have to work for it though.

No name GLs would be crushed by Magnus.

Originally posted by 753
Kyle is too much for Magneto, he'd still have to work for it though.

No name GLs would be crushed by Magnus. LOL

Originally posted by -Pr-
i don't like it because polaris hurts them; i hate it because it's retarded.

gl's can set their shields to block psionic signals, and it's been done enough on panel to make it a pretty reasonable tactic.

that, and we don't know what current gl rings are made of. blocking psionic signals is not the same as magnetic energy. plus they at times have to be aware of the TP and explicitly raise a shield for it.

and even then Martian Manhunter has gotten past the shield to communicate report and coordinate with the team.

Originally posted by King Castle
blocking psionic signals is not the same as magnetic energy. plus they at times have to be aware of the TP and explicitly raise a shield for it.

and even then Martian Manhunter has gotten past the shield to communicate report and coordinate with the team.
And you don't think that Hal or Kyle might have a filter to allow J'onn's tp link through?

A friend managing to pass information on isn't nearly the same as a hostile telepath mindraping. Not even close.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
And you don't think that Hal or Kyle might have a filter to allow J'onn's tp link through?

A friend managing to pass information on isn't nearly the same as a hostile telepath mindraping. Not even close. a filter? you making this up or is this stated onpanel?

Originally posted by Starscream M
a filter? you making this up or is this stated onpanel?
It's conjecture, but supported conjecture.

Case in point: J'onn can communicate with Zatanna but when he tries to invade her mind she's shut him out. The same could be true of GLs.

GL consciously raised and lowered his Psi blocks when he visited the big head guy in prison so he could take his memories. GL struggled with him when he wouldnt let go of the memory download even though the guy wasnt necessarily attacking him a psi bolt would have put hal down even if he was actively resisting. a psi shield is need b4 hand to be effective. his regular shield dont actively keep out psi attacks.

also Hal stated that he needs to specifically Psi Block Martain manhunter to not be effected by MM when he talked about how to take down MM.

that He would summon a psi block helmet why do it if your normal everday shields can do it? answerL b/c he needs to consciously activate it not the helmet but the psi block itself.

has it ever been stated or proved that a GL ring is magnetic proof ?

Originally posted by chomperx9
has it ever been stated or proved that a GL ring is magnetic proof ? no. its actually bn the opposite.

Originally posted by King Castle
no. its actually bn the opposite. then magneto wins easy

When Hal faced Polaris, he channeled his energy right back at him, IIRC. This was a Polaris who was messing with reality from his powers.

Originally posted by chomperx9
LOL You LOLing me chomper? Awesome!

Originally posted by 753
You LOLing me chomper? Awesome! my pleasure

Even without manipulating the ring directly, Magneto can defeat GLs. Their shields do not make them totally, automatically or consistantly impervious to electromagnetic attacks at all.

Magneto has very impressive shielding of his own; atomic level manipulation of metal including trace amounts in living organisms (like the iron rip) and the atmosphere; neuro shutdown and other forms of metabolism crippling; and massive energy projection. He's got what it takes to face them.

I agree. Kyle will likely screw it up. But GL's have what it takes to counter anything Magneto throws at him. Hal has defeated magnetism users before and he can do the same with Magneto.

Just depends on who can adapt the fastest, if we use out of 10 system.

Plus Magneto can bend light )photons around his shield using electromagnetic.

i know i know ppl will say that a GL construct is not light.. whatever..

it is said to be a form of plasma energy as well as light whatevert its power source of the emotion the constructs description has not changed nor have the times they bn used against the wielder by others who can control various forms of energy..

even the oaths defines it as "light" even though its powered by emotions...

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=505689& amp;highlight=title%3A%28magneto+vs+green+lantern%
29

Originally posted by King Castle
Plus Magneto can bend light )photons around his shield using electromagnetic.

i know i know ppl will say that a GL construct is not light.. whatever..

it is said to be a form of plasma energy as well as light whatevert its power source of the emotion the constructs description has not changed nor have the times they bn used against the wielder by others who can control various forms of energy..

even the oaths defines it as "light" even though its powered by emotions...
I hope you're not saying that Magneto is as potent a light manipulator as Dr Light. Because that's the level you have to be to manipulate GL constructs in such a way.

Magneto is strong and powerful enough to resist it and "shunt" it off his shield.

Originally posted by King Castle
Magneto is strong and powerful enough to resist it and "shunt" it off his shield.
Right...so you are saying he's Dr Light's level?

Dr. light and him would be even in a forum fight against each other going either way.

but, i did not say that, dont put words in my mouth.

But, Magneto has shown he can keep back Mjonlir and its blast, pheonix blast etc etc..

he is also a multi tasker doing more then just resisting the attack but also attacking them.

i would put an average power blast from kyle below these ppl and mag should be able to do the same against his most powerful blast as he has done against the others.

magneto removes the ring. end of story

Kyle overloads Magneto. End of story.

Originally posted by King Castle
Dr. light and him would be even in a forum fight against each other going either way.

but, i did not say that, dont put words in my mouth.

But, Magneto has shown he can keep back Mjonlir and its blast, pheonix blast etc etc..

he is also a multi tasker doing more then just resisting the attack but also attacking them.

i would put an average power blast from kyle below these ppl and mag should be able to do the same against his most powerful blast as he has done against the others.
Saying that his shield could resist Kyle's attacks (for a time anyway) is fine, but implying he can do it by directly manipulating the constructs/blasts is ascribing him light manipulation on the level of Dr Light, which is pretty baseless.

not really.. the magnetic shields shunt off photons/energy off the field, some marvel physic reason.

magneto has taken control of optic blast shunted off Dazzler's attack, even heat and powerful flame blast b/c he could "shunt the Energy itself"

but that would not the be the only reason kyle relies on will power as well when facing another person. magneto's power is based on psionic.

both of them fighting would be a strength of who has the greater will of breaking whose defenses. i go with magneto.

Originally posted by King Castle
blocking psionic signals is not the same as magnetic energy. plus they at times have to be aware of the TP and explicitly raise a shield for it.

and even then Martian Manhunter has gotten past the shield to communicate report and coordinate with the team.

i never said it was the same thing. magneto's command of metal is psionic, though.

when the ring starts to become affected (assuming it even is), then they would know to put up a shield. even then a lantern can just demagnetise their ring.

he doesn't go past their shield. don't be silly. rings can allow telepathic communication even between non telepaths. it has filters.

Originally posted by -Pr-
i never said it was the same thing. magneto's command of metal is psionic, though. Is it? Didn't they settle on a physiological or at least both psionic adn physiological explanation after all? Something to do with ultra high concetration of 'electrolytes in his organism.

Originally posted by -Pr-
i never said it was the same thing. magneto's command of metal is psionic, though.

when the ring starts to become affected (assuming it even is), then they would know to put up a shield. even then a lantern can just demagnetise their ring.

he doesn't go past their shield. don't be silly. rings can allow telepathic communication even between non telepaths. it has filters. when has a lantern demagnetise their ring ?

Originally posted by 753
Is it? Didn't they settle on a physiological or at least both psionic adn physiological explanation after all? Something to do with ultra high concetration of 'electrolytes in his organism.

i tend to believe that almost any power activated by the mind is generally a psionic signal.

i honestly don't know if they settled on it.

Originally posted by chomperx9
when has a lantern demagnetise their ring ?

hal did it back in the day against the old doctor polaris. it's not exactly a difficult feat either.

Originally posted by -Pr-
i tend to believe that almost any power activated by the mind is generally a psionic signal.

i honestly don't know if they settled on it.



hal did it back in the day against the old doctor polaris. it's not exactly a difficult feat either. but how would kyle know to do that before bumping into magneto ? all it takes is one sec and if kyle does not demagnetise then its over.

Originally posted by chomperx9
but how would kyle know to do that before bumping into magneto ? all it takes is one sec and if kyle does not demagnetise then its over. I think Magneto's name might provide Kyle a slight clue as to Magneto's powers aside from the common knowledge he's given. Not that I'm saying he does it instantly... but y'know... Kyle isn't exactly dumb.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
I think Magneto's name might provide Kyle a slight clue as to Magneto's powers aside from the common knowledge he's given. Not that I'm saying he does it instantly... but y'know... Kyle isn't exactly dumb. right so when they meet eachother the 1st sec before they go at it they are gonna stop for a sec and shake hands and introduce themselves ?

Hi im magneto

and I am kyle, Nice to meet you


Just thought we'd might want to get to know one another before fighting.

U bet good luck to us both, SHAKE

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
I think Magneto's name might provide Kyle a slight clue as to Magneto's powers aside from the common knowledge he's given. Not that I'm saying he does it instantly... but y'know... Kyle isn't exactly dumb.

you made me laugh while groggy at 8am in the morning.

Thank you.

Originally posted by chomperx9
right so when they meet eachother the 1st sec before they go at it they are gonna stop for a sec and shake hands and introduce themselves ?

Hi im magneto

and I am kyle, Nice to meet you


Just thought we'd might want to get to know one another before fighting.

U bet good luck to us both, SHAKE

u should read the rule..they got basic knowledge of each other before the fight..

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
I think Magneto's name might provide Kyle a slight clue as to Magneto's powers aside from the common knowledge he's given. Not that I'm saying he does it instantly... but y'know... Kyle isn't exactly dumb.

Originally posted by Slaanesh
u should read the rule..they got basic knowledge of each other before the fight.. the rule is the basic knowledge of the populace.

one is a well known mutant terrorist on the morning to evening news.

the other is a superhero celebrity.