Count Dooku vs. Ki-Adi-Mundi, AOTC Obi-Wan, and Cin Drallig

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Dark Thor
Who wins?

Admiral Akbar
Count dooku would take out Ki adi and obi wan, in a matter of seconds.
Ok, he was toying with Obi and owned him in less than 2min, lets see him actually fight for real. OBi wan is gone. Ki adi is weaker than obi so he dies faster. And its Basicily really Cin vs Dooku, which dooku surpasses him in any force powers. So Cin drallig would have a hard fight. I really dont know if an old man could fight all three jedi at once, he might deafeat the first 2 and then be too tired to finish the rest.

Dark Thor
ki goes down first. aotc obi and cin drallig get him together, so its pretty difficult for dooku

Admiral Akbar
Difficult, Cin died to anakin(which really strikes me suprised, but it happened.) ANd dooku would own anakin with his force experience. This team is nowhere near victory. Dooku would not be horsing around, ok this is a dman serious fight. He is smart, he would force throw cin across the room and choke obi wan while defeating Ki adi.

Nai Fohl
Well...throw Cin Drallig into a thread is pretty much...welll...I don't know...unfair.

Drallig (except for his scene in ROTS) is quite bada$$ since he is the lightsaber instructor of the Jedi Order and Nick Gillard himself said that Drallig (in a "normal" fight) would pretty much beat everyone else in the movies except Yoda. Keeping that statement in mind I'd suggest Drallig could take Dooku on his own.

If you want to take reasons just directly from the movies I have to say that Dooku would take all three Jedi.

Darth Windu
I doubt that Drallig could take Dooku on his own. Highly. And maybe Nick was displaying sarcasm and humor. You've convinced me on a lot of things, but nothing could neverconvince me that the second best duelist in the galaxy is Cin Drallig. Maybe in the top five, but not at the top. And saber skills aren't the only thing that are applied in a saber duel. Force powers are a huge factor as well, and that is what would allow Dooku to take this.

darth vraya
Dooku Would own Ki Adi Mundi and Aotc Ob1. Although I think he would be tired from facing the two other jedi and be defeated by drallig

Darth Windu
I doubt it. He could take Ki and Obi-Wan easily, and Cin with a bit of Force power or something.

Shadow_Star
Obi-Wan and Ki-Adi gets beat in a few secongs because Dooku is far stronger then both of them and he wouldn't even have to draw his lightsaber. Dooku would then overpower Cin in terms of force and his supreme form II.

Arbiter
I agree with Shadow_Star

Fishy
As do I...

There is just no way that Cin is number 2 in the galaxy, it just doesn't make sence, where was he when anything important happened? If he was that good he would have been there, he wouldn't just have been sitting around on his lazy ass watching porn and children fight.

kamikz
Actually I don't think Cin would be any harder to fight after he defeated the other two jedi. He beated Anakin and Obi-Wan and faced Yoda after that and still was able to keep him away. You can't say that Dooku was tired when he was fighting Yoda, cause then if he wasent he would be better than him and we know he's not.

War_Lord
Dooku would win this fight.

MAKASHIMAN
Tyrannus would own drallig and ki in seconds and there would be a repeat of the hangar fight in aotc between Obi-Wan and Tyrannus.

JediMusician
I think Tyrannus would defeat OB-1 in seconds, than defeat Ki-Adi Mundi after he tired, and find his match against Cin Drallig. I don't think Drallig is even in the top five duelists, though Nick Gillard definately would be. If you go by actor, then Darth Maul would be the best duelist ever.

Darth_Janus
No, Nick would whup Ray Park's ass.

JediMusician
Originally posted by Darth_Janus
No, Nick would whup Ray Park's ass.
Ever watched the extras on the Episode I DVD? The way they worked out much of the duel was Ray and Nick banged up a couple of poles, and occaisionally one of them would say something like, "Oh, that was good, let's use that."
But the point here is that in the above example, on the DVD, Nick can only back away and defend against Ray's rapid onslaught.
You could say, Well, that's what he wants to do.
Okay....gee, that kind of shuts me up.
Oh, wait. I haven't seen Nick Gillard's name in any World Championship results, whereas Ray Parks has won numerous awards in competitions throughout Europe and Asia.

I invite you to investigate the following link for more detailed information:
http://www.jenshome.com/mabits.html

Gillard is a master at choreographing stunt sequences for movies. He has no professional experience in anything remotely similar to combat. Martial Arts competitions are not really combative, either, but they can at least be nearly so.

Darth_Janus
Relax.

I was merely mimicking Nick's own words in an interview.

darthsith19
Any one of those Jedi could give Dooku a good battle. All 3 together would dominate him.

DarthMaul9123
ray park is better than any of the actors except ewan samuel and liam so thats enough said

Darth Faunus
Samuel and Liam. . . ? Ewan is an excellent duelist, but Samuel and Liam? Not really.

Darth_Janus
Actually, Ray Park is perhaps the best, while Nick Gillard SAYS he's the best, and Ewan definately has the most training besides those two. All else are partime duellists.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.