Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

So how many Jedi did die in the battle scene. I saw Obi Wan kneeling at somebody's body.....

around the 188, thought they sent 200

where did you get this information ?

you know, that question keeps bugging me the whole time! If I knew it, I would tell you!

I think there were about twelve survivors in the circle they made at the battle, and they sent in all the Jedis they had...

If anybody's gonna have accurate numbers it will be Raz or Ush.

OK, heres a more official answer:

There were 16 survivors of which 15 were Jedi

sure 'bout that?

Are the exact number so important?..

yes

Well some peeps here are kinda tooo die-hard fans. You gotta please 'em.

I thought 12 survived, but one was not a Jedi

However, I don't think we saw anything close to 100 Jedi in that battle.

that's because we only concentrated on a small thing of the battle

Yeah, the part where ALL the Jedi were...

Also,, as Ki-Adi Mundi was clearly seen attacking the arena, I wonbder if that whole thing about him attacking the DCS was even vaguely true?

or they digitally got him in to cover it up?

With all the action at the end, I didn't see Plo Koon get killed, if he was. Perhaps he was on the ship that got shot down as the Jedi left the arena?

if you tell me how he looks again, I might give you an answer
(I'm always confusing some people of the TPM JC)

He's the orange looking guy with a black mask on.

He was one of he characters in Jedi Power Battles.

tx
DN, he didn't got killed, when they stop shooting at the Jedi, they bring in Ki-Adi Mundi and Plo Koon in the circle

(I mixed him up with that hairy dude)

I agree with Ush...there was not 100 Jedi in that arena. 50, figuratively, maybe.

hmm dont have an opinion here have to check it out further in my second viewing of the film

I just came home from round two. Studied the arena scene closely... not near 100..

hmm have to look closer at that

I wonder who was buried next to Shmi. There were 2 other markers there.

probably other members of the Lars family

Maybe Cliegg's first wife ?

Yeah I would so

I hate you guys.

Being able to see AOTC twice before I even see it once.

You should be ashamed.

and so should you with those affection of yours toward us

Just to let you know I am kidding. It's just that I really want to watch it!

Well then stop reading these threads you idiot !

Why should I stop reading these threads?

Because Gundy told you so that's why!

Yes ma'am, you sure can be bossy.

I like it!

isn't there a spoiler from T'Bone about this all?

A spoiler about Lance not having seen the film yet ? From T'Bone ? I doubt it ! I doubt he even cares !

why not? he's me

Oh my gosh !!!!!!!!!!! :eek Chancellor Palaptine !!!!!!!! He's the sith lord Darth Sidious !!!!!

yeah, creepy isn't it?

Whoa there. You're Palpatine or am I reading this wrong?

It was a neo-realist attempt at left off centre humour lance ! u know ! yess reveals he's t'bone. palpatine reveals he's sidious.
Marijuana jokes !

Here's a pic of the survivors.

There are 7 Jedi and 1 senator that I recognize and know by name and by sight out of the 14 in the picture. They are:

Obi-Wan Kenobi
Anakin Skywalker
Mace Windu
Padme Naberrie
Kit Fisto
Bultar Swan
Shaak Ti
Adi Gallia

The other 5 in the picture I have no idea who they are. Some of them look vaguely like characters I've seen before.

Quinlan Vos
Eeth Koth

I could believe that Quinlan Vos is there, because his Padawan Aayla Secura is in the movie aswell. But if that is Eeth Koth in the ring of Jedi, I looks like shaved his head.

Anyone know any other Jedi standing in the ring of survivors?

the one behind anakin is Lt Worf from USS Enterprise.

Well, that's the one that reminds me of Quinlan Vos.

Plo Koon, he DOESN'T die, as I think you told me CR.

Yeah, I don't think he does.

I read somewhere that Ki-Adi-Mundi and Plo Koon storm the DCS. They push buttons to turn off the droids, but the Trade Federation has learned from it's mistakes, and the droids don't. But Mundi and Koon think the droids are off until a droid shoots Plo Koon. Koon is rushed to a hospital-type place in the Jedi Temple after the battle.

Who is left sitting in the JC room at the end of the movie? I know Yoda is. How about Mace, and Mundi?

Mundi is clealry alive and those rumours about storming the DCS appear to be so much nonsense; the DCS ships were protected by a droid army and were attacked AFTER the arena scene and Mudni is clearly seen activating his sabre to attack the arena; he was not elsewhere.

Hmm, I see. I haven't seen the movie yet, so I wouldn't know.

But I should be able to see it Wednesday!!!

So who is left sitting in the JC room after the battle?

in TPM:
Yoda, Mace Windu, Yaddle, Saesee Tiin, Ki-Adi-Mundi, Adi Gallia, Oppo Rancisis, Even Piell, Eeth Koth, Yarael Poof, Plo Koon, Depa Billaba


(is it just me or did Oppo got a tail in AOTC??)

in AOTC:
(before the battle)
Plo Koon, Mace Windu, Yoda, Ki-Adi-Mundi, Saesee Tiin, Shaak Ti, Even Piell, Oppo Rancisis, Adi Gallia, Sarr (something), Eeth Koth, Depa Billaba

from the pic:
OB1, Mace, Padme, Anakin, Eeth Koth (NOT Quinlan Vos! who has a yellow mark on his face!), can't see the next one, Adi Gallia, ???, Shaak Ti, ???, ???, ???, ???, Kit Fisto

mind you, Plo and Mundi still have to come into the picture

Well, we've never seen Oppo on his feet before, only sitting like a bum in the JC room.

watched AOTC...

It's not Eeth Koth, it's another Idorniak

survivers that I haven't written down yet: Plo Koon, Aayla Secura, one of those two women jedi (name forgotten).

that's two to go... can someone say if Mundi survives?

Almost certainly, unless he died after the point that we see him next to Windu after the gunships arrive.

now you say so...

ok, that's one down, still one to go,
human, long black hair...

Luminara Unduli and Barriss Offee are the two women Jedi.

he he. This Bespin Bart dude has got a good taste in pictures.

There was a padawan too, I think he's the one that Obi-Wan checks.

not really a survivor then huh?

Check out sw.com and recent Jedi Council questions.

Adi Gallia is not at the final battle, but she is in the Council scenes earlier in the film.

think rex posted that already

Really? Well, still relevant to update this thread, I guess.

ofcourse, it belongs here

Now I know who they all are in the pic. Saw the movie and been online, so on and so forth:

Obi-Wan Kenobi
Mace Windu
Padme Amidala Naberrie
Anakin Skywalker
Eeth Koth
Luminara Unduli
Stass Allie
Bultar Swan
Shaak Ti
??? (Zabrak)
??? (Human or Weequay)
Saesee Tiin
??? (Human)
Kit Fisto

The other survivors of the Battle of Geonasis are:

Aayla Secura
Barris Offee
Yoda
Ki-Adi-Mundi
Plo Koon

And of course: Count Dooku/Darth Tyranus

That should rap up the survivors with lightsabers and blasters that we know or are seen.

once again...that is NOT eeth koth, look at the haircolor

the one standing above OB1, can that be Plo Koon? or one of his species?

Well, Eeth Koth is somewhere in that circle...

No, that was Saesee Tiin. If you remember, Ki-Adi-Mundi and Plo Koon were added to the circle of Jedi when Dooku gave them a last chance. Then the clonetroopers came.

Then there's the switch of Council members during the time between TPM and AOTC. The colored names are according to lightsaber color at the time. White means I don't know the color.

The Jedi Council in TPM:

Yoda
Mace Windu
Adi Gallia
Plo Koon
Eeth Koth
Even Piell
Depa Billaba
Oppo Rancisis
Ki-Adi-Mundi
Yaddle
Yarael Poof
Saesee Tiin

The Jedi Council in AOTC:

Yoda
Mace Windu
Adi Gallia
Plo Koon
Ki-Adi-Mundi
Eeth Koth
Saesee Tiin
Shaak Ti
Sarr Labooda
Oppo Rancisis
Depa Billaba
Even Piell

that was also posted already...

I have another picture from a slightly different angle and the one that I thought that could be Plo is indeed Saesee Tiin

That's what I said.

Here's the remains of the Jedi Council after the battle, before assigning new members:

Yoda
Mace Windu
Ki-Adi-Mundi
Plo Koon
Adi Gallia
Shaak Ti

Who do you think will be on the Council in Episode III, if they have new members? I think Kit Fisto and Luminara Unduli might be two of them.

I think that they will leave it to the survivors. As a monument of sorts to their fallen comrades.

I used the word "indeed"

Will we even see the JC? I don't really think so actually

There is a chance. Maybe Vader walks in and kills them all and Yoda escapes and runs like hell. Another amazing Force power from Yoda.

that would mean some new aliens...again

I wonder what species Sarr Labooda is. I know that Shaak Ti is from Glee Anslem, although I forget the species.

they don't need to say it though

I'm surprised that both Luminara and Baris make it out alive......Though I did only see Luminara

well, Plo, Mundi and Secure got in the group later

I think I asked this before and forgot the answer....did both bariss and luminara live through the arena fight?

Did Adi Gallia even fight in the Battle of Genosis?.....in jedi starfighter (x-box/ playstation2 game) she's flying during the battle, but I don't even recall her in the council room during EpII

She is in the Council Room earlier. She is not at the fight.

or we are just unable to spot her in hte fight

Nope, it has been specified by Lucasfilm that she wasn't at the fight.

where?

Well, there was a certain amount of confusion over a person that looks like Adi Gallia but isn't. And in statements clearing up that confusion they confirmed that she wasn't there. You can check it out at the website.

Yeah I've seen it.

She looks almost identical to Gallia.

She's a close relative. Her name is Stass Allie.

I've confirmed it: the guy who Yerss says isn't Eeth Koth IS in fact Eeth Koth. He's a survivor.

IN YOUR FACE!

There are a few other Jedi that are not photographed, but they are there. There's this dark-skinned Jedi with black hair and a ponytail-type hairdew.

Do you think that in one of the Databank entries at the Official Site they'll put the N*stink characters and Ray Park's Jedi? Ray Park was there during the arena battle, or so I've heard.

Who the hell is Pablo-Jill? He was a Jedi in the battle that ignited his lightsaber next to Coleman Trebor (Sarr Labooda was his assumed name ) in the arena. But why do we care, he's not even on the Council!

never the less he/ she/it was part of the story

Capt. Rex....who was the "n-stink" jedi???

N*Sync. One of the Jedi throwing the sabers to Ob1 and Anakin was a N*Sync member. The other was Steve Sansweet from the Official Site...I think.

But do you think that the Official Site will say anything more on that subject of the N*Sync members being in the film? Make a few databank entries just to let you know that they were going to be part of the film?

and Rex, I have read several reports of N'SYNC fans that clearly say it's one that looks like him but is definitly not him, believe what you will...

And can you give me the source of that Eeth Koth? It's NOT on the official site btw

(whining...though I really don't give one way or another)
Will somebody please just tell me straight...is a member of N'sync in AOTC or not?????

NOT

I couldn't give a more clearer answer than finti...
all the other things you've heared are FALSE, NSYNC fans have watched the movies and they ALL have said no-one of that group was found on screen

I read somewhere that Joey Fatone of N*Sync and Steve Sansweet were the two Jedi tossing sabers to Ob1 and Ani, but half a second goes by too fast to tell who it really is.

yeah...taht's known till now....i dunno where i heard it...and i hate n'sync

we all do

you know what...for my own sanity I think I'll just go along with Finti's answer and put my poor mind at ease...( though I never was in too much turmoil over the situation )

N fans have said that he wasn't that one

well that really doesn't matter

unless he gave us some vocal.....naah...better he didn't

AOTC is one of the better movies mesa thinks

Yes, it is.

What people make an appearance as background Jedi Knights fighting in the Arena? Like Ray Parks and stuff.

well, it's very unclear and most people are not known that well

You beat me to it Yerss!

You were right, it's not Eeth Koth.

There were others in the Arena that had names, but were blown to tiny pieces, such as Belsed Qan-Idan...

Chellemi Chuovvick...

Jabidus Inspra...

Jojighar...

Jor Drakus...

Kel Finn-Surr...

Morvet Storm...

Quarmall...

Soara Antana...

Stam Reath...

...and Winso Bykart. There was also Pablo-Jill and Coleman Trebor, and two Nikto Jedi Knights.

yes... err... nice Rex...

btw, the new JC question is about thie survivors too

You mean the one about Barriss Offee surviving the battle, right?

I keep asking questions to the JC and they never answer!

yup, that one...

of course they don't, rex! They only take questions that are mostly rediculous, once in three months there is a good one

My most recent question asked: "Who is the Jedi that Obi-Wan Kenobi is checking when Dooku tells them to surrender?"

don't think they will ever answer that one

Sometimes I wonder if it's not really people asking.

who will know...
so this finally ends the long disussion about who was in the circle... now... who survived the battle?

We know that Mace Windu survived the battle in the Arena and on the dusty battlefields of Geonasis. Probability is that most of the ring of Jedi survivors survived. Just my 2 cents.

lots and lots died.....

I belive that everyone of the ring survived the battle that occured when the clone troopers came to the aid

think the same finti,
but you had Oris or something like that (appeared in Aproaching Storm) she wasn't in the circle but SWJC answered that specific question with saying she DID survived

hmm kind of euish

well, it isn't EU, I just don't remember her name but I know she was one of the leading role players in Approaching Storm

Baris Offee and someone else... don't know the name

Luminara Unduli?

yup, that's the one

that aint euish???

now finti's not making sense either..

not to the feeble minded no, but to the brighter ones....

because I didn't knew the name I said she was in that book, in the hope someone like Julie could help me out which she did

glad to know I could help you......sometimes finti...you might be too bright for your own good....

Still it was EU stuff

does anyone else feel that the battle of Geonosis was a rather costly battle for the jedi....?

I think that was the idea.

Jules... if you go with 10 000 and come back with only a few (don't know the EXACT amount anymore, thought I knew it), it IS costly

Not that they went with 10000, or anything close to that.

looks like there were maybe around a 100 maybe fewer than that.
I know there was 200 in the novel but it doesent look like that many in the film

hmmm, I pressed a few 0 too much

Understood.

Actually, in the AOTC movie...it doesn't even appear to be more than 75 or something...at least jedi...there were lots and lots of clones.

perhaps 100 Jedi died trying to get in the arena

There was no fighting before they got in the arena!

I think the name you were looking for was Barris Offee, Yerss.

There was also the brigade that was cut from the film that raided the Droid Control Ship. That's why Ki-Adi-Mundi, Plo Koon, and Aayla Secura were lead into the ring. There must of been many Jedi killed there.

You know, the only reason the Official Site told us the names of the Arena survivors was because it was coming out in an Insider magazine soon?

Julie answered it, but thanks again

And that scene is cancelled, so why would there still be Jedi killed there?

Um...because I think it would have been cool?

you think teletubbies are cool too

about jedi survivors http://www.starwars.com/community/askjc/jocasta/askjc20020903.html