Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Battle of the Obi-Wans! Can General Kenobi take down his three inferior selves?

What the hell? ANH Obi-Wan could take him alone.

Hasn't this been done before?

I dunno...ROTS Obi-Wan is pretty hardcore, but hey, he is fighting three other versions of himself, one of whom is his future self and knows him pretty well. If the trio can fight effectively like a team, I say General Kenobi is toppled.

Originally posted by Darth Faunus
What the hell? ANH Obi-Wan could take him alone.

How so? He hasn't fought for a very long time by ANH.

He likes to PWN sand people and has been studying under the Jawas.

Seriously though, its called muscle memory. I don't think he would be much worse after 20 years. Look at Ulic. Twenty years without the force and he was still able to use a lightsaber well enough to beat a Jedi.

How powerful was the Jedi?

Originally posted by Vapaad_Master
How so? He hasn't fought for a very long time by ANH.

Dooku hasn't fought for a huge amount of time (basically pre TPM) in AotC times and still was able to kick Anakin and Obi-Wan around. ANH Obi-Wan alone would kill ROTS Obi-Wan because:

- being wiser
- having probably developed more force knowledge (and power)
- having perfected form III and having even more patience than ROTS Obi-Wan in fighting.

See...if they had the technology back in the 70s Obi-Wan vs Vader in ANH would have been hell of a fight - just think about the fact that Obi-Wan is 25 years younger in ANH than Dooku is in ROTS.

Though I know almost nothing about Ulic, I have heard that he stalemated Exar Kun, who is leagues above ROTS Obi-Wan.

This wasn't Uber-Kun, and Marka ended the fight prematurly(why does he always do that?).


Like Nai said, he probably was a little better in saber skills and a lot in force skills. Remember, he was already THE DEFENITIVE MASTER or Soresu by ep3.

Originally posted by Nai Fohl
Dooku hasn't fought for a huge amount of time (basically pre TPM) in AotC times and still was able to kick Anakin and Obi-Wan around. ANH Obi-Wan alone would kill ROTS Obi-Wan because:

- being wiser
- having probably developed more force knowledge (and power)
- having perfected form III and having even more patience than ROTS Obi-Wan in fighting.

See...if they had the technology back in the 70s Obi-Wan vs Vader in ANH would have been hell of a fight - just think about the fact that Obi-Wan is 25 years younger in ANH than Dooku is in ROTS.

I stand corrected, thanks for clearing that up. So ROTS Obi is toast.

Oh my bad guys. Like Vapaad Master, I too thought ANH Obi-Wan was weak lol. Let's take him away then, leaving it to be rots obi vs. tpm and aotc obi, who takes it?

Originally posted by The_Executor
Oh my bad guys. Like Vapaad Master, I too thought ANH Obi-Wan was weak lol. Let's take him away then, leaving it to be rots obi vs. tpm and aotc obi, who takes it?

Now you have more of a battle rather than a lop-sided ass kicking. Now I will have to go with ROTS Obi, simply because he is more powerful, more experienced and hey, it's his two former selves. He'd know them inside out, enough to exploit weaknesses and beat them, he takes this.

ANH Obi-Wan could take ROTS Obi-Wan alone. But ROTS Obi could probably beat the other two. Unless he had been killed by ANH Obi-Wan first. lol

Well, Anakin is stronger than Obi-Wan in ROTS (Anakin, not Vader). Also (according to Anakin) he is twice as powerful in ROTS than he was in AOTC. Now, Both AOTC and TPM Obi-Wan are stronger than Anakin as in AOTC so that means they should be able to take ROTS Anakin, right? And if Anakin is stronger than Obi-Wan (ROTS) that means they could also take out Obi-Wan.

ROTC Obi-wan has a little chance with the ANH version of himself, but could easily defeat first two....

Originally posted by Darth Nhilus
ANH Obi-Wan could take ROTS Obi-Wan alone. But ROTS Obi could probably beat the other two. Unless he had been killed by ANH Obi-Wan first. lol Did you see A new hope? Just look at the duel in ANH and then look at the duel in ROTS.

Originally posted by JaehSkywalker
ROTC Obi-wan has a little chance with the ANH version of himself, but could easily defeat first two....
I didn't know Obi-wan was in ROTC. I didn't know there was an ROTC in Star Wars.

Originally posted by CobbleR
I didn't know Obi-wan was in ROTC. I didn't know there was an ROTC in Star Wars.

Must be the Return of the Clones that Lucas was talking about

Originally posted by Rand al'Thor
Must be the Return of the Clones that Lucas was talking about

fifty years after ROTJ, the clones have risen again....

This is a stupid question but aren't the Storm Troopers the Clones?

Originally posted by CobbleR
This is a stupid question but aren't the Storm Troopers the Clones?

Naw the Storm Troopers are Jedi in disguse

Originally posted by Rand al'Thor
Naw the Storm Troopers are Jedi in disguse

Ahh, so that's why they were so incompetent at shooting at Luke, they didn't really want to kill him.

Originally posted by Illustrious
Ahh, so that's why they were so incompetent at shooting at Luke, they didn't really want to kill him.

Of course. They vallently lay down there lives so that the farmboy might live to become the hated NJO Luke.

That clears so much up for me. I had my suspisions but never had any solid proof.