Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

I say the Twi'lek. Anakin was arrogant, impatient, and dumb in AOTC. Aayla was already a JEdi Knight. Who'd win?

^agreed.

Aayla...Aayla...I know that name.

She was promoted to general in ROTS, Anakin was only a commander.

Anakin...Anakin...I know that name from somewhere.

Anakin was a general too.

hee wuz duh chozen 1 duh ful

Originally posted by Deus Ex
Anakin was a general too.
he was? did you get that from a book? in Jedi Trials, he was called commander. I dont know about the movies though.

Originally posted by DrDoom101
he was? did you get that from a book? in Jedi Trials, he was called commander. I dont know about the movies though.

Labyrinth of Evil. 'General Skywalker.'

k, thanks

That and the fact that he lead an army. That makes him a general. Generals lead army groups. Commander is not an army title so much as it is a generic title for one who commands.

I don't think there was a fighting Jedi who wasn't made general.

That's probably true. But as we've seen from AOTC, the jedi weren't the best for the general position. debatable why they would be appointed it.

There was virtually noone else sensible and perhaps cunning enough?

Well, war is a good teacher. I doubt that any of those particular Jedi had had much experience in all out combat up until AOTC.

Still, they should have been classically trained. I mean, the jedi have their own personal archives, and must instruct their students in all branches of learning.

And if you want to get nitpicky, hell... even governor Tarkin of Eriadu, some industrialist planet official, was classically trained in warfare.

Just like Gene Shalett.

Jedi still weren't good generals, when you look at Obi Wan for instance. In LOE he leads by just going in and doing a few things and then something happens and he can move on. Basically the way he leads his army's is by just going in there with a group of soldiers and then constantly adapting to the situation. Nice but not going to work in a full scale battle.

Still i'm sure the Jedi would have learned a lot in the wars. And you can't put the general in any less of a position, when you don't have a traditional army to speak off. Besides the Jedi wouldn't agree to it, maybe they should but they wouldn't. They think they are to good and valuable to be send into battles by others. Not to mention that its going to be hard for others to judge the powers of the Jedi. Jedi are nice to have in an army, but you need them in high ranks because as foot soldiers they are worthless. You just need to hope that there are some good generals in the Jedi Order.

Which there wasn't. Anakin lead from the front, and made many mistakes, creating overblown casualties in Jedi Trail. Yoda's troops on Kashyyk are apparently schooled by morons, because they were dug in and ready for the enemy, and then suddenly get up and charge only to get slaughter. Geonosis- 'nough said.

The point is, the jedi don't think like tacticians. They don't realize that you have to think smart and play dirty. Revan understood this quite well, which is why he was able to defeat the Mandalorians at their own game. I doubt any PT jedi could have done this.

I'm sure they couldn't have, I mean every battle you see them in makes them suck as generals. Their tactics are worthless.

Me either. And these pop-ups are killing me. This computer has no pop-up protection.

Tsk. I have to shut off my connection to get rid of them, there're so damn much.

Okay, download service pack 2 (if you have Windows XP that is) or Firefox...

Dude, this work computer can barely load KMC. I am NOT downloading the Service pack. takes forever anyways.

Both in AOTC huh? Well, by this time Aayla is a Knight and probably almost is probably almost as strong as Obi-Wan. Then again, Anakin's nearly as strong as Obi-Wan too. I guess there probably about tied in saber skills but Aayla'd win since she's stronger with the Force.

Firefox takes a few minutes at most, and if you don't feel like doing that. Put it on an USB stick or a floppy disc or CD or whatever and bring it to your work, put it in the pc and enjoy

Not on the admin account for the comp. Can't install either.

well that sucks.. Can't you get somebody from system management to do it? I mean those guys probably love firefox.

Pfft. Sunday. No one here.

The bastards, break your computer and go home early. Post at home you can use firefox there

aayla