Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Here's a fresh new thread for suggestions! If your idea wasn't used last month, suggest it here again!

Happy posting.

is Kreacher really up to something

What will happen to the malfoys.

The Fate of Draco Malfoy.

Victer Krums future role in Harry Potter

Will the actors get the boot? Or will the filmmakers let em ride it out?

As I suggested for last months debate: Should Harry tell the Order of the Phoenix about the Horcruxes / Will the Order find out about the Horcruxes?

should ron and hermione get it on?

Will Hermionie go out with Ron or Harry?

what happened to Snape

wow...lol...ron and hermione getting it on?...hmm...i think that highly unlikely to happen...lol...but sure!...y not?...i think harry will go oout with a new character...maybe...ron and hermione kinda have their own thing to figure out

Originally posted by dansdaman
wow...lol...ron and hermione getting it on?...hmm...i think that highly unlikely to happen...lol...but sure!...y not?...i think harry will go oout with a new character...maybe...ron and hermione kinda have their own thing to figure out
he like ginny.

Is there someone among the friends who will be a traitor, just as Wormtail was for the maudarers, and who?

What is beyond the veil which Sirius fell through?

Predictions about Harry's future.

what would harry find when he is forced to live at number 12? he has to live somewhere

will siruis and or Dumbledore come back?

will harry create his own army to take on voldemort

I think a but of 'meta-debate' would be nice. Rather than arguing out a plot-based subject- nwhich is turning up pretty thin lately- a debate about the process behind the plot.

For example, I think it would be interesting to discuss if Rowling made a mistake in the whole 'Snap kills Dumbledore' thing. The dramatic advantages are obvious- but hasn't she rather painted herself into a corner? Debate about Snape is now so rampant, and everyone so set into one camp or the other... but there is no hidden 'third' option; either Snape is on one side or the other (at least when he killed DD, anyway), and inevitably people are going to be disappoitned either way.

I worry she has set up a payoff here that she will never be able to deliver.

character pairings? who should go with who? how do you feel about them?

Originally posted by Ushgarak
I think a but of 'meta-debate' would be nice. Rather than arguing out a plot-based subject- nwhich is turning up pretty thin lately- a debate about the process behind the plot.

For example, I think it would be interesting to discuss if Rowling made a mistake in the whole 'Snap kills Dumbledore' thing. The dramatic advantages are obvious- but hasn't she rather painted herself into a corner? Debate about Snape is now so rampant, and everyone so set into one camp or the other... but there is no hidden 'third' option; either Snape is on one side or the other (at least when he killed DD, anyway), and inevitably people are going to be disappoitned either way.

I worry she has set up a payoff here that she will never be able to deliver.
I like Ush's idea. Quite interesting, if you ask me.

how about character debates like whos done what , what they do , what lies in their future... like ---> professor mcgonagall shes a teacher , new hogwarts head master etc!!how will she cope?? will she be stressed?? will, she be able to hold the fort stop hogwarts from being over run with evil dooers

Originally posted by Ushgarak
I think a but of 'meta-debate' would be nice. Rather than arguing out a plot-based subject- nwhich is turning up pretty thin lately- a debate about the process behind the plot.

For example, I think it would be interesting to discuss if Rowling made a mistake in the whole 'Snap kills Dumbledore' thing. The dramatic advantages are obvious- but hasn't she rather painted herself into a corner? Debate about Snape is now so rampant, and everyone so set into one camp or the other... but there is no hidden 'third' option; either Snape is on one side or the other (at least when he killed DD, anyway), and inevitably people are going to be disappoitned either way.

I worry she has set up a payoff here that she will never be able to deliver.
I third this.

The title should be something like "Has Rowling ****ed herself over?".

people on other message boards think dumbledore will nto return but Sirius may because u never know if he did die with the mirror

sirius better return.

Originally posted by danagrint
will siruis and or Dumbledore come back?

Dumbledore and Snape - were up to something??

Originally posted by takuto

Is there someone among the friends who will be a traitor, just as Wormtail was for the maudarers, and who?


I likes it...that would be a great one...lots of chaos about the subject would arise...

when will the debate be anounced that what i wan to know people are still talking about last months

if anybody hasnt noticed yet, its already november...

I am taking a good guess that we aren't having a November Debate... I mean, we haven't even started voting yet!

All righty, sorry for the delay. I've gotten all the ideas down on a poll.