Ki-Adi-Mundi and Adi Gallia vs. Quinlin Vos and Aayla Secura
Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.
darthsith19
Just a guess, but I think most of you will say Quinlin/Aayla. I'm really not sure though. Ki-Adi-Mundi's a strong Jedi and Adi Gallia's pretty strong, too. Both are Masters who were on the Council. Quinlin was never on the Council but proved very strong in surviving ROTS, tricking both Dooku and the Jedi and killing Sora Bulq. He is a Master. Although Aayla Secura only even became a Knight she was also strong (though perhaps the weakest out of this bunch). She defeated Aurra Sing in a duel, a fairly big acclompishment, though not as big as taking iut Sora Bulq. I'd say Aayla/Quinlin, both having taken out an evil rgoue Jedi in duels, have more dueling experience than Ki-Adi/Adi. But Ki-Adi is stronger than Aayla, seeing as he put up a fight against the Clones that killed him whereas Aayla just got shot from behind. So if they fought Ki'-Adi'd win. Quinlin'd beat Adi and then it'd be Ki-Adi vs. Quinlin. Mundi's smarter (he has 2 brains) and I think probably stronger with the Force but not as good with a saber. So it'd be close. Not sure who'd win.
But if Aayla fought Adi first and Mundi fought Vos perhaps Adi could defeat Aayla quickly enough to help Mundi take out Vos. Together I'm sure they'd succeed. If Adi could take out Aayla quickly enough, for I have a hunch Quinlin could probably beat Mundi.
Comments?
Se7in
I don't know enough about Adi Gallia and her fighting skills to make a conclusion.
Darth Faunus
I want to clear something up. Quinlan didn't fare well at all in his duel with Bulq. If anyone here has read that particular comic, they can recall how Bulq was tossing Quinlan around like a fool, smacked aside his enraged blows, and literally brought him to his knees. He fell when, believing the battle to be one, he raised his lightsaber high, too high. He over-extended himself. Vos, after having his mind cleared by Aayla and Tholme, just rose from his knees, pivoting, and stuck Sora from midway between the side of the hip and the groin, then slashed upwards out of his shoulder.
Think Dooku vs. Anakin and Obi-Wan. He floored Anakin and Obi-Wan a combined total of three times, as did Sora. Dooku was the superior combatant and duelist, but in a moment of arrogance, he was defeated. (Yeah, yeah, orders, I know). But in this case, it was purely overconfidence on Bulq's part.
Don't get me wrong; Quinlan Vos is an exceptional saber combatant. But Bulq was shown to be the clear superior in this duel.
Se7in
Well, is attitude toward a duel not part of someone's skills? I hear many people say "Anakin is too hotheaded" and whatnot, why should Quinlan be lowered because of Sora's tendencies? The same goes for Maul, his arrogance got him killed and I believe the same is likely to happen. But really, does anyone have any info on Adi Gallia and her fighting ability, all I know is she got backhanded from Grievous' saber.
Darth Faunus
How am I discrediting Vos? I specifically stated that this was not part of my argument. I am simply saying that because he viewed himself as Vos' unquestionable superior, and believed the battle won, he left himself open to an easy kill. Period. I never discredited Vos there.
And of course Bulq's overconfidence would cost him a duel in some cases. But almost all of those scenarios would occur in a battle with Quinlan. Believe it or not, Sora had his own insecurities concerning the said Jedi. He was afraid that Vos may have become more favorable to Dooku than Bulq himself. And we all know how the Sith deal with that.
In a nutshell, I didn't try and discredit Vos. I merely tried to clear up a common misconception.
As to the thread. . .
I've seen on the net that Gallia uses a 'reverse grip' stance. I don't think she's exactly prodigial in her saber abilities, but she's probably good enough to take on Aayla. I must say however, that I myself wouldn't say for sure how this duel would turn out.
Se7in
Okay, sorry. But in reality, I think Ki-Adi-Mundi could take them both, with or without Adi's help. Well, maybe not by himself, but he would put up a good fight.
Darth Faunus
Who? Vos and Aayla? He'd likely lose against them on his own, and I have my doubts that he could defeat even Vos alone. But yes, he'd put up a good fight. The only problem here is the lack of info on Gallia's part.
And there's nothing to apologize for.
Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.
Copyright 1999-2009 KillerMovies.