Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Lets say, that instead of the Cloned being on Geonosis, they were replace by Warhammer 40k Space Marines.

Any difference?

Probably less deaths. I'm assuming 200?

What if they replaced the Jedi instead?

they would all have died and jango would still be alive.

All have died? What a ridiculous statement. Two hundred marines would pound thousands upon thousands of bolter rounds into the droids. Jango would get shot to pieces and the Super Battle droids would die.

Agreed. Marines would CURBSTOMP the droids.

So a space marine is stronger than a Jedi?

No. They seem to be Warhammer Fanboys just because the Warhammer guys look cooler. It's quite annoying, actually.

Glentract, don't insult me, I'm not a fangirl.

Jedi are superior to SM in many ways and vice versa, they both have their merits.

Agreed. Space Marines are smarter and tougher (AKA not rushing a bloody planet with no support). Glentract, it seems like you have a grudge against ANYONE who argues ANYTHING against your point of view. Learn to accept certain facts, and deal with it.

Sorry Traya, how about fanpeople


Gryn, I hope you do realize that there was NO reason to believe there would be an army on Geonosis.

Which is even more reason to have Space Marines, curbstomp.

Originally posted by Darth Traya
Glentract, don't insult me, I'm not a fangirl.

Jedi are superior to SM in many ways and vice versa, they both have their merits.

It's funny.... No one mentioned the word Fangirl


Assumptions clog your bloodstream!

Ok, geez, look, enough is enough. THis is stretching the definition of a vs. thread VERY far.

I am putting a moratorium on non-Star Wars related threads here. No more 40K!