2005 X awards
Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.
mr.smiley
Since another year is passing us and where going on into 2006 I think we shoud have the year end award for all things X.While I can't post multiple polls I divided up a lot of things to vote on.(suggestions are most welcomed because I actualy haven't read an X book in some time and some of my knowledge is a little outdated)
Lets vote on best X book
Best X artist
Best character
worst character
Best new character
Best X writer
Best solo X book
Best story arch
Which character was written the best in 05
who was written the worst
Best X villian
most shocking moment
botcherby
Best X artist - Sean Chen
Best character - Emma Frost (all titles shes appeared in :P )
worst character - ShadowCat (really dissapointing in Astonishing)
Best new character - Can't Comment
Best X writer - Joss Whedon
Best solo X book - do you mean single character? Gambit gets it
Best story arch - Cure
Which character was written the best in 05 - Collosus... I'd say Emma but she sucks in Xmen - Thanks Austen and Mully
who was written the worst - ICEMAN.... you'd have to be living on the moon to not know this - Thanks Austen and Mully... oh yea Havok was written poorly too!!
Best X villian - Cerebra
most shocking moment - When AUSTEN GOT RID OF JUGGERNAUT AND SAMMY, HOW COULD YOU DAMMIT...
mr.smiley
I thought Juggernaut how some cool parts in Uncanny this year,but I feel they could have done better towards the end of the year with him.I'm sure they'll do some crap writing with him around the time X3 comes to theatres.
hotsauce6548
Astonishing X-men was the best series in my opinion.
Iceman was written horribly like an a-hole.
I like Shadowcat in Astonishing X-Men.
Emma was written well.
xx_Storm_xx
Best X artist - the ppl who drew endsong
Best character STORM!!!!
worst character - banchee
Best new character - no comment
Best X writer -stan lee
Best solo X book - storm
Best X villian - magneto
most shocking moment - when jean died for the billionth time
thundercracker
now i will probly say x23 for almost everything but thats jus me
best X book - astonishing
Best X artist - John Cassaday
Best character - x23 (ok im biased)
worst character - juggs after the power down
Best new character - x23
Best X writer - Joss Whedon
Best solo X book - x23 innocence lost
Best story arch - cure
Best X villian - danger
most shocking moment - i havnt been shocked much this year
xmarksthespot
Lets vote on best X book: Astonishing X-Men
Best X artist: Greg Land, although all his female faces look the same.
Best character: Undecided. Maybe Emma.
Worst character: Jobbernaut
Best new character: Don't know.
Best X writer: Joss Whedon
Best solo X book: Mystique (Okay it started before '05 but I haven't I haven't been that impressed with any of the others.
Best story arch: Cure
Which character was written the best in 05: Emma Frost, in Astonishing at least.
Who was written the worst: Iceman
Best X villain: Can't decide. Maybe Danger.
Most shocking moment: "No more mutants." Well, it would have been shocking if nobody had known in advance.
hoorayforpeepee
best X book
Astonishing, followed by cable/deadpool.
Best X artist
i like LaRocca
Best character
Anybody in astonishing (practically), deadpool
worst character
iceman, jobbernaut, i couldn't give a shit about polaris.
Best new character
last good new character was Kid Omega.
Best X writer
Joss Whedon
Best solo X book
Gambit's has been pretty consistent
Best story arch
"Gifted"
Which character was written the best in 05
Cyclops (astonishing cyclops is the first good cyke in a while)
who was written the worst
iceman
Best X villian
gotta love Golgotha
most shocking moment
...colossus?
xmarksthespot
Oops I meant "Gifted" for some reason I thought it was called "Cure" which book and arc was "Cure"?
And if it's the last new character that I've liked I'll go with Dust.
8bitChris
best X book - Astonishing and Cable and Deadpool
Best X artist - Salvador Lorocca does it for me.
Best character - Deadpool
worst character - Kitty has always been a rather contrived character to me. Not much to her. If she wasn't such an old character she would have been dumped with the rest of the New Mutants.
Best new character - Were there any good new characters?
Best X writer - Greg Pak (Phoenix Endsong)
Best solo X book - Gambit was good, people just didn't read it.
Best story arch - The Burnt Offering.
Which character was written the best in 05 - Niceaza did a good job with Deadpool this year. Everyone else was so-so to me.
who was written the worst - Rachel has been acting like a baby all year. Iceman a close second, he's better than what they wrote.
Best X villian - Magneto
most shocking moment - Wolverine kills Northstar.
bitca730
Best X artist: Salvador Larroca
Best character: Emma Frost
Worst character: Moonstar
Best new character: Hellion
Best X writer: Joss Whedon
Best solo X book: Emma Frost
Best story arch: Cyclops/Jean/Emma triangle
Which character was written the best in 05: Emma Frost
who was written the worst: Moonstar
Best X villian: Xorn
Most shocking moment: Emma not being a natural blonde...
xmarksthespot
Originally posted by 8bitChris
worst character - Kitty has always been a rather contrived character to me. Not much to her. If she wasn't such an old character she would have been dumped with the rest of the New Mutants.
Best solo X book - Gambit was good, people just didn't read it.How can you say Kitty is contrived......? And then give Gambit - possibly one of the most contrived characters ever - best solo....
Everyone's entitled to opinions I s'pose... but imo somethin' ain't right there...
botcherby
Originally posted by xmarksthespot
Oops I meant "Gifted" for some reason I thought it was called "Cure" which book and arc was "Cure"?
And if it's the last new character that I've liked I'll go with Dust.
that would be my bad too.... I liked the first arc in astonishing the most too.... I just couldn't figure out the name so I went with what went on :P
botcherby
Originally posted by xmarksthespot
How can you say Kitty is contrived......? And then give Gambit - possibly one of the most contrived characters ever - best solo....
Everyone's entitled to opinions I s'pose... but imo somethin' ain't right there...
I felt Kitty is such an awesome character, but she just wasn't major in anything in astonishing... I mean Lockheed(sp?) had a more significant role... in the fact that he saved the xmen
Taku
best X book: Uncanny X-Men
Best X artist: Salvador Larroca
Best character: Emma Frost
worst character: Cyclops(S---s)
Best new character:X-23
Best X writer: Chris Claremont
Best solo X book:Gambit
Best story arch: JeanEmma/Scott (murder at the mansion, I liked how they brought Sage and Bishop in and For the record, Cyclops was a f--king idiot.)
Which character was written the best in 05: Emma Frost
who was written the worst: Rachel Grey
Best X villian: Xorneto
most shocking moment: Wanda saying: No more mutants.
Ps. Igor Kordey and Chuck Austen and the other who worked on NXM s--ked. The artwork was freaking lousy, it made me hate that storyline and i regretted buying the comic.
xmarksthespot
Originally posted by Taku
Best X writer: Chris Claremont
Paola
^ he brought back Psylocke, so don't make that face sly
DarkCrawler
Best X artist: I really, really, really liked the art on Astonishing...so John Cassaday
Best character: Beast
worst character: Has to be Bishop.
Best new character: X-23
Best X writer: Joss Whedon
Best solo X book: X-23
Best story arch: Dangerous
Which character was written the best in 05: Beast
who was written the worst: Iceman
Best X villian: Danger Room
most shocking moment: When Iceman lost his powers.
xmarksthespot
Originally posted by Paola
^ he brought back Psylocke, so don't make that face sly But he's the one that killed her in the first place...
mr.smiley
Claremont also brought back mojo.That made me sick to my stomach.
Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.
Copyright 1999-2024 KillerMovies.