Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

There's one of these in most of the forums :

Rate the DVD above on the following criteria :

Quality of Film
Special Features
Packaging/Design
Price
Free Gifts
Collectability
Price

You can give a rating to each criteria or just an overall rating for the whole package :


Lets Start with .......

THE DEVILS REJECTS

Maybe something that more people will know.........

How about ....

Star Wars ( The Original Trilogy )

10/10 (overall)

Brazil: criterion collection

Okay... How about?

Batman Begins

9/10

war of the worlds

8/10 (fullscreen )

Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith

9/10

Kill Bill Volume One

8/10

Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou- 2 disc Criterion Edition

8/10 on the dvd itself.


Se7en-2 disc special edition.

9/10

Black Hawk Down

Quality of Film = 5
Special Features = 7
Packaging/Design = 7
Price = 7
Free Gifts = N/A
Collectability = 3

Overall = 6

The Devils Rejects

Check the Devils Rejects specs here........

www.killermovies.com/forums/f45/t375348.html

How About....

Back to the Future Trilogy

10/10


Donnie Darko Directors Cut

8

Indiana Jones Trilogy

Sorry, I felt compelled to do ALL the previous.

"The Devil's Rejects" - The 2 Disc Unrated DC is fantastic. It has it all, including a 2 1/2 documentary on the making of the film.

"Star Wars" - The OT set is alright. The commentaries are boring for the most part, they're not the original forms of the movie, and the bonus disc could have been better, i.e. deleted scenes.

"Brazil" - It's 3 discs, and it's Criterion. Can't go wrong.

"Batman Begins" - 2 Disc is good content wise, but the navigation and menu SUCKS..BAD. Very hard to get around, albeit clever.

"War of the Worlds" - No comment.

"Star Wars: Episode 3" - Good extras for a subpar movie. Same for the other 2.

"Kill Bill: Vol. 1" - Horrible R1 disc. 1 SPECIAL FEATURE! That's IT!

"Life Aquatic" - Criterion again, so that says it all.

"Seven" - There was actually some useless extras that werten't all that great.

"Black Hawk Down" - It's been released on DVD 3 times, so be more specific. There's the initial release, then the stripped Superbit, then the absolutely IMMACULATE and well put together 3 Disc SE which is still one of the best DVD's around.

"Back to the Future" - Nice content, but early releases had the movies incorrectly framed which really sucks.

"Donnie Darko: DC" - The 1 disc has features the 2 disc doesn't and vice versa, so they're about even.

"Indiana Jones Trilogy" - Same as "Star Wars", skimping on extras.

...now for my selection....

"The Alien Quadrilogy" 9 Disc Set

Alien Quadrilogy is outstanding. One of the best box sets available, even if you aren't a big time Aliens fan it's definately worth owning for the extras.

Clerks X

I don't have the Region 1 Kill Bill, I rated the region 3 two disc.

Clerks X is one of my favorite DVDs I own. The extras are great, a extended original cut, The Flying Car short, the lost scene wake cartoon, in detail documentary about Kevin Smith trying to make Clerks. 10/10

Dawn of the Dead original SE

7.5

(Region 2)Document of the Dead documentary and commentary are good.

Evil Dead Trilogy

-Evil Dead 7/10
-Evil Dead 2: Dead by Dawn 9/10
-Army of Darkness 8/10

8.5 Overall

Schindlers List

Schindlers List = 7


Romero's Dead Trilogy