See, I don't like the question because I'm a HUUUGE fan of all 3, and it's like comparing apples n' oranges.
However, you're comparing Jordan, the greatest basketball player ever, who played in more of an individual sport than the other 2, whose successes were not nearly so influenced by the performances of his teammates. Football and baseball, even though pitching is quite an individual competition, need one's teammates to perform well to also get the success.
I'd pick Mike, I suppose.
Nolan Ryan arguably is the greatest pitcher of all time...7 no-no's, 300+ wins, and the all time k's leader is nothing to sneeze at. Funny though, when the question is raised who is the best baseball player of all time...you always get Bonds, Mays, Ruth, Aaron, blah, blah...never any pitchers. 🙁
Joe Montana, IMO, is the best QB ever....3 rings, a genius behind the helm, incredible accuracy, and the FIRST master of the 2 minute drill.
although the question was who had a better career I suppose you could think of it like this:
If you had to pick one of these guys to bet your money to win the game which would it be?
Nolan Ryan to come in and strike out the side.
Montana to drive for the TD
Jordan to make the game winner at the buzzer.
Obviously this doesnt represent the entire career but another way of tryin to think about it. Basketball is also a team sport. Jordan did have help. He won those championships with a very talented guy named Scotty Pipen. Also I think one of the reasons you dont hear pitchers as the best players as all time is because they arnt complete players. Guys who are great hitters and can play the field well bring a lot to the table, these guys also play every game and not 1 out of every 5.
Originally posted by BobbyD
See, I don't like the question because I'm a HUUUGE fan of all 3, and it's like comparing apples n' oranges.However, you're comparing Jordan, the greatest basketball player ever, who played in more of an individual sport than the other 2, whose successes were not nearly so influenced by the performances of his teammates. Football and baseball, even though pitching is quite an individual competition, need one's teammates to perform well to also get the success.
I'd pick Mike, I suppose.
Nolan Ryan arguably is the greatest pitcher of all time...7 no-no's, 300+ wins, and the all time k's leader is nothing to sneeze at. Funny though, when the question is raised who is the best baseball player of all time...you always get Bonds, Mays, Ruth, Aaron, blah, blah...never any pitchers. 🙁
Joe Montana, IMO, is the best QB ever....3 rings, a genius behind the helm, incredible accuracy, and the FIRST master of the 2 minute drill.
You truly think Montana's number 1? Deff top 5 dont get me wrong. But over all career statistics I'd put Elway, and Marino ahead of him.